About This Video
The CSE is excited to partner with MNP for our virtual event, ESG in the Capital Markets, on October 4-5, 2021.
ESG: A Journey to Strategic Advantage
The growing push towards great sustainability and accountability is resonating across all industries and sectors. For publicly-traded companies, executives face pressures from progressive customer bases, strict regulators and investors who want to minimize risk wherever possible. This means that companies must demonstrate unparalleled agility and innovation across the global business landscape.
Many companies are turning to environmental, social and governance (ESG) strategies to differentiate their companies among investors and consumers. But how best to implement these – and what are the most important factors to consider?
Join us on October 4 to learn more about ESG fundamentals and how to implement sustainable strategies for your publicly-traded company. Gain insightful takeaways as we discuss:
ESG 101 – What it is and why should you care as a public company executive, board member, and investor
Why ESG is more than a value economic-driver
ESG Frameworks – Choosing a framework for your organization that best supports the growth and trajectory of your business
0:00 - Intro
2:19 - Introduction and general overview of ESG practices with Richard Carleton
13:29 - Role of the CSE in supporting the initiatives of CSE listed companies with Mark Faulkner
21:14 - Introduction with Mary Larson and Edward Olson from MNP
27:48 - What is ESG?
42:18 - The State of Sustainability in Canada
51:22 - ESG Standards & Frameworks
1:12:00 - Where to Begin
1:25:23 - Wrap Up & Final Thoughts
Subscribe for more great CSE insights and interviews here: https://bit.ly/CSETVSubscribe
STAY CONNECTED WITH THE CSE
=============================
- PODCAST: https://blog.thecse.com/cse-podcasts/
- INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/canadianexchange/
- LINKEDIN: https://www.linkedin.com/company/canadian-securities-exchange/
- FACEBOOK: https://www.facebook.com/CanadianSecuritiesExchange/
- TWITTER: https://twitter.com/CSE_News
- BLOG: https://blog.thecse.com/
- WEBSITE: https://thecse.com/
Read the TranscriptAuto-generated by YouTube; names and terms may be misspelled.
welcome to esg in the capital markets a special presentation of the csc in partnership with mnp join us as we explore environmental social and governance strategies and their importance in the global business landscape the push towards sustainability is resonating across all industries and sectors many publicly traded companies are turning to esg to differentiate themselves among investors and consumers but how should these strategies be implemented and what are the most
important factors to consider we will explore esg fundamentals for publicly traded companies and include a special focus on cannabis and mining where education meets opportunity this is esg in the capital markets welcome to esg in the capital markets brought to you by the canadian securities exchange in partnership with mnp this two-day event will look at the subject of environmental social and governance strategies from a macro level on day one
while we peer into specific industries like cannabis and mining on day two today esg a journey to strategic advantage many publicly traded companies are turning to esg to differentiate themselves from investors and consumers but how best to implement these and what are the important factors to consider esg 101 what is it and why you should care as a public company executive board member and investor why esg is more than a value economic
driver esg frameworks choosing a framework for your organization that best supports the growth and trajectory of your business i will now turn it over to richard carlton ceo of the canadian securities exchange afterwards we'll hear from mark faulkner vp of listings and regulations at the cse next mary larson partner mnp and to close it out edward olson leader environmental social and governance at mnp thank you for your time and i hope you
enjoy the presentation thank you hello my name is richard carlton i'm the chief executive officer of the canadian securities exchange we're here today to talk about esg environmental social and governance which is a very popular investment theme that's moving a lot of people to change or look at their investment portfolio to see whether or not their investments in fact line up with their views about
society climate change and other issues that are gripping us all across the capital markets globally in fact at the present time so i guess there are a number of associated with with esg but if we talk about the capital markets specifically there's been some research dating back several years now that indicated that not only did it make people feel better if they were trying to match
their investment portfolios with their outlook on a variety of social issues as i discussed whether they be environmentally related or or social change or social progress as well as attempting to reward companies which had the most advanced governance practices and procedures including being significantly more reflective of the societies which they come from whether it's a gender diversity racial diversity and other diversities that we are much more aware
of and talk about a lot more than perhaps we we did at one point in the not too distant past but that these investments had the potential to not only make you feel better about your investments in the capital markets but provided a return which was better than that expected for a broader portfolio of securities and this has been a matter of some significant debate in the academic
community that watches the performance of the financial markets as well as looking at you know the impact on capital formation and cost of capital for issuer companies around the world so i guess a few basic points to keep in mind when we think about and talk about esg in the in the capital markets the again there is significant debate about
how companies should be scored according to these different environmental social and governance measures they're in fact competing measures at this point many of them come from europe and they may not necessarily score companies the same companies the same way and again there's substantial debate about many of the scoring systems that have come into place as to whether they do in fact properly capture
all of the issues from the esg scorecard it's clear that this is still a developing discipline we see a lot of investment time and energy from the index providers for example and companies that are involved in the classification of companies to try and provide standards so that investors know that there or they can understand how the companies are being scored on an esg basis for those of us in canada
esg can present some very specific challenges because as we know the canadian market public equities a very substantial percentage of the market capitalization is derived from oil and gas and mining exploration and production companies and i don't think it takes much understanding into the esg framework to realize these companies tend not to score very well on the e part in particular there's a view that of course these
companies are enormously productive of carbon and carbon-related emissions and that the environmental harm inflicted by the activities of these companies certainly historically is greater than companies in many other fields of endeavor and we have similar extractive industries whether it's forest products and again canada certainly in comparison to the united states the information technology sector which tends to do very well on esg measures is significantly underrepresented so the
challenge for companies in canada particularly those engaged in extractive industries is that they have a they have an immense hill to climb compared with their peers in the broader markets in many other parts of the world and so i think companies do have to keep in mind that regardless of how they feel about whether or not they're being fairly judged in comparison both with their peers in the industry
as well as with companies generally in the public capital markets that investors from around the world are going to be looking at how they project themselves how are they telling the story that they are looking to minimize the environmental impact of their activities how they respond to social issues obviously many of these companies in in canada are operating in lands either
seated by first nations or unseated territories from first nations that are subject to continuing land claims and you know again companies that have a positive productive working relationship with the local first nations are going to find themselves in a better position when it comes to raising capital than peers who have not necessarily considered these these issues similarly from a governance perspective many of these industries tend to be
heavy on the engineering and geological professions and historically for a whole variety of reasons we know that those areas have pretended to be traditional male bastions those barriers are breaking down but clearly from a gender diversity perspective companies that take a leadership role have a considerably better story to tell to the market than obviously their peers in the in the area so this is something that as i say is a
particular challenge to canadian public companies in particular again because of the heavy weighting of those industries in the in the canadian the broader canadian public markets and that's becomes very important when beyond capital formation we look at the pressure that's being applied to insurance companies for example on a global scale again these industries require significant access or access to significant insurance capital to provide
the kind of guarantees that they require both by well by form of regulation in fact and as i say access to these services is being restricted by virtue of the low esg scores that some of these companies are receiving so as i say it's something that public companies have to keep really front of mind because again regardless of the validity of the approach or some of the academic challenges to the claims
that were made some years ago about the positive performance of of companies that score higher on the esg scale compared with the peers in the broader market that investors are looking to match their investments with their personal beliefs and values and increasingly of course folks are thinking about the environmental social and governance impact of the companies that they are investing in and again i think that's particularly
true of the new generation investors who have joined the public equity markets particularly since the onset of the pandemic the discount brokers have been opening accounts at record rates over the last 16 18 months or so and many of these new account holders skew to a much younger demographic that historically have invested in the public equity markets in canada and these folks are very much conscious of the wanting
to match their investment objectives with their social objectives as well and so as i say companies in their investor relations projects and programs as they think about how to engage with these new investors a story built around their commitment to esg goals is something that really has to be done and it will distinguish themselves from from their peers in some cases or as i say whole industries are going to realize
that in order to continue to receive public investment they're going to have to commit to a variety of objectives which are outlined under the esg framework so in conclusion there's still a lot of work to be done in terms of how you score companies either across industries or within a particular peer group that it's done fairly and accurately but as i say i think this is a powerful
idea it has certainly struck a chord in the investment community there's no doubt and i don't have the facts and figures at hand but it's been a very very powerful tool for investment managers to open new funds and to win new investment mandates from a variety of clients using esg strategies from the largest investment managers in the world like blackrock down to more boutique oriented services that focus very specifically on esg as
guiding principle so as i say much work remains to be done but companies really do have to understand that this is a significant and powerful theme in the investment community and something that they're going to have to focus on as they develop their investor relations campaigns and their corporate funding strategies in the in the near future i'm mark faulkner vice president of listings and regulation at the canadian
securities exchange richard carlton gave us an introduction and general overview to environmental social and corporate governance practices as they relate to investors and investing the experts our friends at mnp will go into a significantly more detail about esg practices i'm going to talk about our position and the role of the exchange in supporting the initiatives of our listed companies since its inception csc has believed that meaningful relevant and timely
disclosure is paramount there are requirements standards and stipulated timelines in securities law and in exchange policies but above all there are best practices a public company could ostensibly be complying with all of those requirements but still not actually meeting the disclosure objectives if they've left the investors wanting more a company that strives to provide meaningful relevant and timely disclosure will generally be complying with all the requirements simply as a
byproduct of those efforts and esg practices can be similar there are already basic environmental social and corporate governance practices that are dictated by law and there are some industry specific regulations that will apply as well compliance with the law is already a requirement for listed companies so how do we mandate best practices on top of that well in our view we don't we encourage best practices we support
the issuers that demonstrate best practices and we recognize that investors too will too when they can see the practices they're looking for reflected in the company's actions and detailed in the company's disclosure one of the greatest issues facing investors is the lack of any measurable standard richard mentioned that scoring systems are still a developing discipline currently standards are inconsistent undefined or non-existent an esg focused fund for example could
have stated investment objectives that align with an investor's desire to do better and invest with their conscience but how is it measured if a company aims to be carbon neutral for example and erects wind farms and solar turbines in one country while simultaneously polluting in another country would that meet the fund's objectives would that mean an investor's objectives if the environmental practices of a company were a significant consideration
in their investment decision the investors need the disclosure to determine that not just a statement from the country company about an objective or a statement that they're complying with a law in a specific jurisdiction investors need detailed disclosure to determine whether the company is meeting their own objectives and standards so then establishing those practices for each company is not necessarily something that should be done at the exchange level but requiring balanced
disclosure is already part of basic disclosure requirements not all companies would or should have the same approach even within the same industry so the stage of business development the laws and cultures of the jurisdictions in which a company operates or where they sell their products and services will all influence the strategy and practices of each company when raising capital companies will often provide volumes of analysis about the potential market for their products
or services the worldwide market for their products could be in the hundreds of millions of dollars and could be projected even supported with proper references could be projected to be a billion dollars within a few years of launching well that's all well and good but what is the company actually doing to tap into that market five pages of disclosure about the market and the potential and half a page
to describe the company's actual plans is probably not as balanced as it should be so we may find that as we push for disclosure about esg practices companies fall into that habit of simply describing in boilerplate language and format commendable but very standard objectives without explaining exactly what the company is doing specifically to meet those objectives in short they'll tick all the right boxes but spend too much time talking
about why without providing or demonstrating the how what or when so why then would we advocate a disclosure-based approach rather than imposing actual requirements because we don't believe the one size fits all approach works the board and management of the company are responsible for pursuing the business objectives of the company in the best interest of the company and its shareholders so in addition to compliance with the laws and exchange policies they're
accountable to the shareholders for their strategy and approach to achieving those objectives the role then of cse and iraq as its market regulator is not to dictate best practices for each company but rather to ensure that the disclosure by each company provides adequate detail to investors so they can determine whether the company's taking steps that align with their own objectives and standards should every company adopt esg practices
well the obvious answer is yes provided they're tailored specifically to each company a food and beverage conglomerate with packaging and bottling facilities worldwide would have significant impact on the environment and culture in each country in which it operates the practices at each facility would differ from others but they should all support the company's overall policies that would hardly be comparable to a junior mineral exploration company with a single project in northern ontario
their objectives may be similar but the risks and challenges and therefore the resources and strategy will be very different in many cases companies that already have policies procedures or guidelines in place will simply be organizing and presenting the relevant disclosure in a format consistent with what investors are looking for in keeping with the theme here i guess it makes sense to stop talking about why and provide the how what and when
from our perspective i've touched on parts of it already existing disclosure policies and practices of the cse and iroc are to review for balanced disclosure or include review for balanced disclosure as esg related disclosure in periodic and timely disclosure documents expands we will maintain our focus on that balance but what about the standards the inconsistent or undefined scoring systems for funds for example we'll soon be publishing comprehensive
policy amendments that include a broad requirement with a very specific objective any issuer that holds out a security as being in compliance with specific non-exchange standards must disclose how compliance has been established and who was responsible for establishing that those requirements had been met we won't be setting the standards but consistent with our focus on disclosure we will require that investors have the information they need and the details they need to determine
whether their investment standards or objectives have been met by the companies or funds in which they invest thank you thank you barrington great introduction and we're really happy to be here today to talk to you in in this this virtual environment my name is mary larson and i am a partner at mmp i lead the national organizational renewal practice which is basically our strategy scenario planning
organization design esg strategy practice we also do culture transformation work i've been in the consulting world for a very long time 30 plus years and i've also had a number of positions in industry have been deeply involved in sustainability for about 20 years and excited about the fact that we are now at a time where esg is becoming more than just something on the fringes of the business world so ed over to you
thanks mary hi everybody my name is edward olson i'm a chartered accountant by trade i lead the sustainability practice here at mmp and work very closely with mary i'm also a regional leader of enterprise risk services addressing all manner of topics around governance risk and compliance my background around sustainability includes everything from sustainability audits to environmental management systems to carbon credits and even being responsible for the strategy
operations and running of an alternative energy company i sit on cpa canada sustainability reporting advisory committee and i'm also a member of the global esg advisory committee with the institute of internal auditors so mary i'm really happy to be joining you today today on this topic and look forward to the discussion with you if i could what i would like to do is quickly review with all you who are
attending what our objectives are going to be today we want to arm you with an understanding of what is esg we want you to walk away with being able to articulate what are the drivers that are impacting this new adoption in the and the upswing in the whole esg dynamic and paradigm to have a good understanding of the standards and frameworks that are globally accepted and are being
implemented and finally what are some of those principles to keep in mind around how are we going to implement esg so all that being said we're excited to bring this topic to you great so if we just start with with thinking about what esg is i think the fundamental thing that often is is not thought of initially is because people immediately go to issues of measures and and
regulations and standards but in fact the first place to start is with identifying who your stakeholders are and what they care about with respect to esg and when you do it that way then it is incredibly much easier in many ways to to actually get focused on on what it is that you need to do about esg so i think the bottom line is the issues are going
to be different for literally every single organization even organizations operating in within the same sector so if we just took an extraction business for example if you're operating in multiple jurisdictions then there will be multiple government bodies at various levels that you will need to pay attention to and the same thing is true with regulators and understanding which each of those entities are looking for what they care
about will be critical to your success getting in the heads of employees will also be a critical issue i've one of my i've been reading about a company recently who has been paying its employees extremely well there it's a sophisticated manufacturing entity and they've got a big plant in in north in south carolina and unfortunately for them many of their employees are literally walking down the road to other
jobs perhaps not as well playing but paying but where they feel that the employer cares more about their physical safety so they're marching with their feet so employees concerns will differ depending on the environment that you're in but finding out what they care about is crucial customers increasingly especially in the b2b sector are looking at the behaviors and standards of the output of their of the companies that they deal with
indigenous communities i think goes without saying they're going to be looking for things like responsible use of land and whether people from their community are being engaged or not and of course there might be special interest groups that will have other concerns the bottom line is you need to think about stakeholders and in fact that's going to be the bulk of what we talk about today just one last word the
financial sector by the way obviously is one that has gotten in ahead of the game on esg and of course they're placing greater pressure for disclosure and minimization of emissions of greenhouse gases because they are putting pressure on themselves and other people are putting pressure on them to ensure that their portfolios meet self-imposed co2 co2 targets and and and other other measures so you'll hear a lot from ed and myself
today about stakeholders so if we go to the next page in fact when we think about the whole journey of esg implementation which starts with you know defining your footprint identifying stakeholders this is where we're going to really focus today we will talk later in the presentation about identifying esg topics and how you go about thinking about materiality and figuring out what it is that you're already doing because there are a lot of
things going on in many businesses these days the data gathering and reporting and verification process but our discussion today is really going to be focused on this issue of stakeholder identification and response so ed do you want to just talk to us a little bit about you know what is esg yeah thanks mary i think it's the perfect place to start is the basics of what is it what are we trying to address
and and the way we describe this is that esg is that cluster of non-financial factors that really do have a financial impact it's plain and simple but getting to this solution is often more complicated than it appears if we just look at the environmental pillar environmental encompasses how an organization is exposed to and manages risks and opportunities and this is related to climate natural resource scarcity pollution waste management
biodiversity and in a host of other environmental factors if you look at the social pillar social considers an organization's values and business relationships which include labor and supply chain standards employee attraction and retention what mary was just speaking about employee health and safety including product quality and safety diversity and inclusion and social acceptability of projects there's a lot that's bundled within that s pillar and if we move to
the right and look at governance governance incorporates information on the structure and diversity of the board of directors this is also executive compensation critical event responsiveness corporate cyber security fits here including things like bribery and corruption so you can see what we provided here on screen are just some examples but the the esg paradigm is quite comprehensive so you might be sitting there wondering how did we get to where
we're at today this is going to be a brief overview starting in the 70s with milton frieda friedman who said shareholder primacy it's the only reason why companies exist and the immediate response from the world was no it's not just shareholders there's this idea of social contract that was proposed if we jump to 1994 the whole emergence of triple bottom line was to take that that idea of
social contract or that corporate social responsibility and what it did is it defined it further across three things it was bottom line it was people and planet but the unique part is that it said each one of those three distinct responsibilities are all equal but approaches largely remained i would say a marketing tool businesses made these gestures of what they were going to do and in worse cases
just were doing nothing at all and so the idea of this esg became a new movement that came out in 2005 and where esg different is that it measured it was quantifiable and criteria led and it allowed businesses to better integrate esg into their dna and mary's going to talk a little bit further about the united nations sustainable development goals later on in this presentation itself so can you think about the what's
driving esg why why is it suddenly why we gone past the tipping point there are a number of things that have that have happened and we will be talking about the regulatory environment in much greater depth in the next few slides i'm not going to talk a lot about that but regular sustainability measures are definitely very high on regulators list of issues to deal with in government
public policy has become a major major issue in canada we have bill c-97 federally we have an agreement on the need to price and control carbon emissions we have some requirements for crown corporations to limit their greenhouse gas emissions so the federal government is is is paying a lot of attention to this some provincial governments are paying more attention than others and around the world you see the the same thing and
this is just partly because voters care about this and partly because issues around climate change de i have risen to the surface employees as we've seen will you know can walk with their feet the story that i i just told you you already know about the banks the the pressure that has been placed since early in 2020 when blackrock one of the big big
financial institutions talked about social responsibility climate change sustainability and basically said if you don't get on board you're going to be left in the dust all of that has led to a ton of responses basically an acceleration of focus on the part of financial institutions to ensure that there is a link between esg accountability and access to capital and the cost of capital is is is a huge
issue especially for mid-sized companies securities commissions are globally driving change and in some cases in a way that we probably hadn't hadn't anticipated and exchanges by the way are doing some really interesting things that we were quite surprised about we did some research earlier this year and it turns out that the united nations has launched an initiative called the sustainable stock exchanges initiative and they're tracking how exchanges are
working to enhance esg performance around the world there are 108 exchanges that are tracked by the ssc and of these 64 are are similar to the cse in in the sense that they're focused on small and medium-sized listing programs within that 64 a third of them require esg reporting as a listing rule and more than half of them have written guidance on esg reporting so this is an important trend we'll see
what's going to be happening with it down the road i think with respect to customers it's a little bit hard for many companies especially smaller companies dealing in the btc sector any b2c sector to determine the degree to which its customers are reacting to whether or not esg is something that's on the on the on the on the playbook but in the b2b sector it definitely is
so all of these entities are creating pressure on organizations to respond to esg and do you want to talk a little bit about getting into more of the detail here yeah thanks mary if i could just delve a little bit deeper into accounting standard setting bodies and especially the international organization of securities commissions i said earlier that i sit on cpa canada's sustainability reporting advisory committee well just earlier
this year we had the head of the international financial reporting standards foundation come to speak to us about changes that are expected and what they're pushing through ifrs around sustainability the ifrs foundation has their focus on cop26 in glasgow for november of this year and this is when they're going to outline the roadmap for the creation of a global sustainability standards board and that this board will set
expectations globally for sustainability that would be it's going to be built into the ifrs standards themselves in a specific note iosco they put their support 100 behind the creation of this sustainability standards board and they said that they see the urgent need for globally consistent comparable and reliable sustainability disclosure standards and that these standards will truly provide the content that capital markets need so what i wanted to do here is to say
change is coming and we're actively looking towards november of this year and what's happening i think too is that when we think about all of these moving parts that are that are taking place one of the messages that i think is is coming out very clearly is a discussion around yes we want to be setting standards and we need to be clear about what they are but there is a lot of discussion about
the fact that any reporting any activities that a company undertakes need to be taken in the context of what it is that the company is all about what are its values what are its you know what are the views of its stakeholders what are the principles that the company operates on and so fundamentally talking about esg taking action on esg without putting in the context of the strategy and the business
operations and the the the culture of the company will make people on the outside make stakeholders far less comfortable with the quality of of the response that an organization is taking so we're just going to transition a little bit here into board expectations and then and as we keep delving into esg i wanted to refer to a quote from ralph smith it keeps coming to mind because his statement of if you think
good design is expensive you should look at the cost of bad design he was the ceo of jaguar land rover and he was responsible to lead the transformation of the company from this niche uk manufacturer to a global premium business and in fact he did lead jaguar to become the first premium automotive manufacturer to design and engineer an all-electric performance suv this needed foresight to see the changes
that were happening globally and if important to know canada will ban the sale of fuel-burning new cars and late-80 trucks from 2035 in an effort to reach our national net zero emissions across the country by 2050. so when you think of esg begin the design and implementation now having a strategy is going to pay dividends as compared with racing to play catch up at a future date transitioning
the world business council published a report last year and they focused on the board's role in ensuring business resilience and long-term value creation one of the highlights i was primarily interested in was this whole idea of linking value and sustainability but but more so was the finding that governance was actually failing and with failing governance came value erosion so two things were paramount here truly understanding value and being clear as to the material
sustainability issues impacting your business mary yeah and i think there's some importance in getting out ahead of of of your board so one of the things that is interesting i mean very powerful is that mackenzie did a the harvard business review recently reviewed revealed the results of a study that they did over 21 years and with about 2 000 u.s companies in which they found that
companies that improved literally took action not just talked about it but improved on material esg issues significantly outperformed their competitors so back to the comment that that that ed just made about ralph's death this took foresight they had to be thinking about this a long time ago to have been taking action and to show results in dealing with your board of directors i think it's fair to say that not all
directors are going to be as up on all of the issues as perhaps you will be and getting out ahead of your board of directors is not a bad idea and one of the things that that a recent conversation that i had with an insurance company a senior executive was in fact they're working on trying to identify the issues that were important to their company because the board had sort of
mentioned that they were concerned about it didn't really necessarily know where to start and so it's a responsibility of the senior leadership team to to exercise that foresight and to to help the board be more effective if we go to the next page that it's also true that some boards will be more proactive and so they will be asking questions for example what are the adopted frameworks that are
being used in your industry in our industry and what are the disclosure requirements that we're going to have to pay attention to if we want to access capital are there material risks and opportunities with respect to esg integrated into our strategy and again these aren't all environmental they could definitely have to do with the eni or modern slavery or other issues our material risks sufficiently integrated into your enterprise risk
management framework and is there any assurance that you're getting over the data that you're talking about or delivering to your stakeholders so do we do we actually believe in the numbers that we're putting out there so those are the kinds of questions that ford should be asking and again if you can get out ahead of the board that is a really powerful thing for your organization and for
adding value over a longer period of time if we look at the state of sustainability in canada i think it's interesting to watch and we just want to briefly take you from only 2015 what's been happening in canada what's the approach mary referred to a few things already this morning around crown corporations but let's let's get a little bit further into the detail in december 2015 canada and just about 200 other
countries reached what we all know today as the paris agreement and it's an ambitious agreement to fight climate change the agreement's long-term temperature goal is to keep the rise in mean glodium global temperature to well below two degrees above pre-industrial levels but with the preference of getting us to be around the one and a half degree mark so what's happened since then well since december of 2015 we can just
take a look here at 2016 following on the paris paris agreement canada outlined its own climate strategy in the document that you see here the pan canadian framework on clean growth and climate change this strategy provided it was an extensive description of executive mitigation and adaptation strategies for a clean economy that lean very heavily and still does on carbon pricing and if we look at what's going on now
well very recently june of 2019 bill c97 was passed and this is a very important message i think to business and canada that we have rejected milton friedman's point of view that the only reason for a corporation is to benefit shareholders the cbca basically codifies the need for directors and officers to consider the interests of a much broader set of stakeholders employees customers pensioners and others and what they basically said is that
these interests need to be included in strategy development and oversight and and the environment is now part of this as well and there is more recent legislation that specifies the importance of considering other stakeholders so this is going to only continue bottom line is there is a focus on the long term that is being dictated by our government and then there's the csa staff notice yeah and and this is interesting mary
when we look at the canadian securities administrators there was a demand for better reporting on climate change risks and opportunities by by investors in the public and it's been increasing over the years so that prompted the csa in 2017 to launch a climate change disclosure review which resulted in the csa staff notice 51-358 what that staff notice does is it it provides reporting issuers with guidance as to how they might approach preparing
disclosures of of material climate change related risks in the preparation of their mdnas and their annual information forms and it assists in identifying material climate related risks so what's good about it is it started but just earlier this year the ontario capital markets modernization task force they called for an absolute overhaul of canada's largest securities regulator with one of the requests being the need for more stringent climate related reporting
requirements in addition to what was already in the csa staff notice so if you are publicly listed the influences on minimum expectations will continue to grow for the whole idea of this integrated reporting of sustainability and financial information together oops now if if we just change lens a little bit again and we we look at all industries across canada ospi who's the office of superintendent of financial institutions
they're a federal regulator of banking in canada and their primary goal is to contribute to public confidence in the canadian financial system bank of canada is the nation's central bank and influences the whole monetary policy within the country in 2019 that was the first time ever the bank of canada released a report examining the threat that climate change posed to the country's financial system which following immediately after that in 2020
bank of canada and osfie announced plans for a pilot project to use climate change scenarios to better understand those risks of the financial system that is related to a a transition to a low-carbon economy and if we even just looked at this year in 2021 osp completed and published a study recognizing the risks of climate change and and linking those risks to the potential for material implications to
both assets and and profitability and so on the heels of that and i think it's pretty much gotten sort of hidden in in all of our discussions around the pandemic and other issues there is now a within the budget into 2021 a demand that crown corporations federal crime corporations with assets over a billion dollars have to adopt the tcfd disclosure standards as part of their corporate reporting
and this basically is recognizing the tcfd is now probably a very widely accepted set of standards and these entities are going to need to report on the degree to which they are adhering to them so this is becoming even more of a com a drum beat coming from the the canadian government and just to close out what's happening in june of this year bc 12 or bill c-12
it's also called the canadian net emissions accountability act and this enacted bill requires national targets for the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions in canada to be set with the objective of attaining net zero emissions by 2050 which is our our overall national commitment and it brings with it some more teeth for undertaking a formal reevaluation every five years and and the whole intent here is to drive accountability and transparency
in essence this bill places into law canada's commitment to reach net zero carbon emissions so where are we today well cn maple leaf food celestica brookfield all of these companies have announced new sustainability goals i would argue that that many of them are doing this because of the pressures that are being put on them by financial services organizations and government regulations and and other pressures the point here is and i think there was
an article just in the globe today that that pointed out that smaller organizations are doing this kind of thing less frequently than large companies and this has partly to do with the fact that large organizations have more resources to put to bear to to actually identify where they stand with respect to sustainability and and to determine what they're going to do about it so one of the things that we're seeing is
that however in two-thirds of tsx companies actually do provide information on esg emissions and so they are disclosing but there is going to be growing pressure on smaller organizations mid-sized companies to do the same thing and i think again that one of the things we that ed and i've been talking about i think consistently in this is that these sustainability goals need to be made in the context of your business with
respect to your stakeholders and by the way we are going to be speaking more specifically about extraction companies and cannabis the cannabis sector in some subsequent discussions we'll get into that a little bit more oops there's ambridge too
so let's kick off the esg standards and frameworks mary fun oh that's my most favorite topic that's the thing that everybody wants to know which standard should we be using because it's been alphabet soup for for quite a while so gri is is an interesting organization it is an international independent standards organization that is in existence to help business governments and other organizations to figure out what they need to do with
respect to other to reporting and to communicate their impact so they basically are there to to support companies not to impose standards then there's sasby and the integrated reporting council which basically are they fundamentally merged at this point and what they're trying to do is to provide a set of standards that can be used by organizations when they're trying to develop their reporting frameworks and it's interesting and sasby for example
has over 75 industry sectors so that you can go to one of their handbooks and get a sense of from their standpoint which are the esg factors that they consider to be most important it's a good way to start it's not it's not the be all and end all but it is an interesting way to start the tcfd has is talked about a lot it is something that was created by the
financial stability board and what they're basically trying to do is they're very focused on climate issues and they're developing climate related financial risk disclosures sasmi and and integrated reporting are much broader in their scope and then if we look at the next page we've got the cdp and cdsb which are there to they're an international consortium of business and environmental ngos and they're committed to advancing and
aligning global mainstream corporate reporting models and what they basically want to do is equate natural capital with financial capital so that they're trying to really put some value on on on on nature i guess is the way you put it i'm going to talk a little bit more about the united nations sustainable development goals but it's a very interesting set of of global goals that i think are really
designed to achieve a better future for the world and they're they're very broad in nature but they're also very powerful and in some ways moving and then the world economic forum is a set of government environmental social and governance metrics and disclosures that are basically supporting this notion of stakeholder capitalism and we're hearing more and more from the world economic forum these days so i'm going to go a little bit deeper
into these esg standards and the un sustainable development goals and as i said they're they're really thought of as global goals but they they link directly to esg so they're talking about things that the world needs you know no poverty or hunger health and well-being diversity and inclusion and equity quality education clean energy quality infrastructures sustainable cities responsible consumption climate action taking care of life before below the
water and on the land and peace and justice now you could make an argument that those are kind of pie in the sky issues but but businesses and organizations around the world in many cases touch many of those sustainable development goals and these are being if you look at many financial institutions many large companies they have decided to as much as possible take these global goals into account as
they're developing their strategies as they're thinking about esg and they're not going to go away they're they're being i think made increasingly more rich in part because a variety of tools have been developed that enable organizations to track what they're doing to visualize progress towards the goals that they're setting up and so what's happening is they're they're developing basically tools that enable companies to say here's where i sit with respect to these
sustainable development goals and as i said many financial institutions are adopting these thank you mary we're trying to cover the top six for you because there are other global frameworks and standards and these top six we wanted to bring your attention in 2020 what you see on screen the international business council of the world economic forum they created a report and title and and this is a
mouthful but it's it's the measuring stakeholder capitalism towards common metrics and consistent reporting of sustainable value creation let's just call it the world economic forum for right now at the heart of this framework our 21 core metrics that you see on on this slide these are generally quantitative and and most companies are already collecting this information the standards also include 34 expanded metrics which are less mainstream and have a wider
value chain scope the principles that that designate the four pillars that you see here are governance planet people and prosperity and they're actually derived from what mary was just talking about the whole un sustainable development goals and they facilitate integration of the standards into the mainstream periodic corporate filings of companies across all industries sectors and countries in fact the standards leverage many existing frameworks we're going to talk
about today and for instance that's the cdsb the gri sas be task force on climate related financial disclosures and many others the report intends for these stakeholder capitalism metrics to be adopted by international business council member companies and ideally the reason why it's being adopted it's going to create a domino effect of sustainability disclosure in the global marketplace with ibc member companies being the first to fall in line
so looking at this just a little bit further the intent of this slide is to show you the link between the top line pillars of the world economic forum standards that are covering in the middle of the material issues in the esg paradigm and how those link to the value reporting foundation's capitals that mary was talking about and again those capitals are the financial manufactured intellectual human social and
relationship and natural capital together they represent stores of value that are the basis of an organization's value creation and lastly this slide shows the linkage of of all of these into at the bottom the un's sustainable development goal goals so the good story is there is linkage between many of the frameworks and standards it's just not yet perfectly aligned globally if i could just add my dad one thing one of the things that
is interesting about the world economic forum and the un's sustainable development goals is they've they've really tried hard to develop a set of realistic targets that are tangible and described that the hope is that they'll be achieved by 2030 in some cases it's constant improvement but this stuff is not just a numbers game a lot of you know a lot of hard thought has been put into what would this really
look like and i think that it makes for some interesting interesting reading and thinking yeah great point mary thank you changing standards into the gri mary was talking about earlier this actually goes all the way back to being created in 1997 and it's it's it was the first and it's considered one of the most widely used frameworks its objectives are to provide companies with sustainability standard metrics so they
can show their responsible environmental practices and the gri standards they detail approaches to materiality to management reporting and disclosure for a comprehensive range of sustainability issues and their their metrics actually have evolved over the years to now be expanded and include human rights governance and social well-being the modular interrelated gri standards they're designed primarily to be used as a set to prepare a sustainability report focused on material topics so saying
that there are three universal standards the 101 102 and 103 that are used by every organization that reports under the gri framework so everybody reports using 101 102 103. an organization also chooses then from the topic specific standards to report on its material economic environmental and social topics which are further detailed in gri200 300 and 400 so if we just choose one social topic from the 400 standard we can pick out
gri411 and it's entitled the rights of indigenous peoples and it addresses the whole aspect of how well does your organization state the total number of identified incidents of violations involving the rights of indigenous peoples and it gets into the whole process of was it reviewed the incident by your organization are the remedial remediation plans in place are the results being monitored to change internal management processes so it's
really unique that it can get to that level of granularity but this is the high level overview in june of 2021 mary also referred to this the sustainability accounting standards board and the international integrated reporting council they announced their merger and now they're referred to as the value reporting foundation and you can see on this slide between these two comparative pictures there is alignment of the irs capitals that
we've spoken about earlier and actually sas b sustainability dimensions the vrf it's an esg guidance framework that sets standards for the disclosure of financially material sustainability information by companies to their investors the resources they provide include the integrated thinking principles the integrated reporting framework the sasby standards and mary you you referred to this a little bit earlier those sasmi standards track esg issues and performance across 77 industries
and and i'm very fascinated this whole framework is built to support companies in sharing their outward esg impacts through the language of investors debt holders and internal financial stakeholders if we move into the climate the tcfd that climate change it's a realization that it prevents it presents financial risk to the global economy and and financial markets need clear comprehensive high quality information on the impacts of climate change
this includes the recent opportunities presented by rising temperatures climate related policy emerging technologies in our world tcfd well actually the financial sustainability stability board part of me created the tcfd in 2015 and that whole intent was to increase reporting around climate-related financial information and it helps organization organizations across the globe articulate how esg performance is most likely to material impact future financial performance and value creation so as the earth's temperature
rises increasingly common natural disasters are are disrupting ecosystems and human health causing unanticipated business losses and threatening assets and infrastructure this response governments and private sector entities are considering this whole range of options for reducing global emissions which could result in disruptive change across economic sectors and regions in the near and long term so how does the tcfd work well it's broken into the four pillars that you
see here around metrics and targets and risk management strategy and governance this guidance identifies multiple climate related risks and opportunities to disclose and to give you a bit of an idea we've just thrown on screen here's two questions out of many does your company describe the boards or a board committee's oversight of climate-related risks or opportunities if your answer is no there's a lot of work to be done so
there's just guidance here that gives you some context around things that they would expect to see within your organization the carbon disclosure project it was actually formally known as carbon disclosure project and now it's referred to as cdp and the carbon disclosure standards board they offer a complete system for climate disclosure and and elements of environmental and natural capital disclosure so companies and investors they can disclose climate change and
elements of environmental information through the cdp platform and that provides the structure for data collection and the content for reporting so in essence cdp manages a global environmental disclosure system used by more than 8 400 companies and in fact they do claim to hold the world's most comprehensive collection of self-reported environmental data well companies disclose by completing any or all of three cdp questionnaires and the questionnaires include general and and
sector specific questions aimed at high impact sectors the scoring of those questionnaires while it's conducted by accredited scoring partners who are trained by the cdp and it's important to note that reporting is actually completed on annual basis the challenge is that the cdp has an 88-page document with over 200 questions so gathering the required data and responding to the cdp questionnaire it's no small undertaking so in summary
the cdsb framework has seven primary guiding principles and twelve reporting work requirements but it gives you a little idea of the details so mary i'll hand it over to you yeah and so we're gonna go right back to this question about stakeholders because lots of ways for an organization to decide what kind of sustainability framework they ought to be using and how they should going about reporting and just to build on what ed just said
cdp is very appropriate for a company perhaps in the oil and gas sector where greenhouse gas emissions or some aspects of agriculture for example or greenhouse gas emissions are going to be very very important and where investors buyers and other stakeholders are going to be paying a lot of attention to this sasby is is something the investment world is looking at it's kind of what the default for
the investor investor world is sasby reporting it's straightforward it's it's prescriptive it covers all of the esg factors tcfd again is more focused on environmental and governance issues and gr gri is perhaps the most well-balanced one but depending on who your stakeholders are what you want to accomplish and what you want to disclose and work on there's their choices to be made fundamentally
so hopefully here mary they're starting to talk the same language or work together can you address that yes and i think that the one of the things that's going on with the corporate reporting dialogue is that the dialogue is is there basically to set up communications around the direction content and ongoing developments of all the stuff that we've just been talking about so reporting frameworks standards and related
requirements it's been a little bit like the wild west for the past couple of years and i think we've just talked through a lot of aspects and and and and dimensions and if you're not confused then you're a genius and this organization or this dialogue is trying to to make some some sense out of it what they're trying to do is identify practical ways and means by which the
respective framework standards and related requirements can be explained and aligned and what they're trying to do as well is avoid conflict inconsistency and duplication between them and get a common voice on on what what really needs to be talked about on areas of mutual interest where as possible and to get all of the parties around the table including regulators so some sense could be made on this
the the participants are pretty broad-based and there's a lot of experience around the table and and i'm not sure when that when that the output of that is going to be do you do you notice that evolution right now and i think we're going to have ebbs and dribbles coming out but cop 26 in november is going to be a big defining moment of who's on board with
sustainability who isn't and what is going to be the global participation moving forward through a global approach to sustainability so we're we're laser focused on november to see what comes from that right okay good and what has happened i think is is with all this focus on on standards and reporting what we believe at m p is that companies and senior leadership need to step back and say okay there is a journey here we
need to start on this journey we need to start fairly quickly and there are principles around operations so a compliance focus through sustainability making that a core part of the culture at least starting to talk to your stakeholders so that and building to ongoing engagement so that there is a constant dialogue going on as with respect to what you're doing about esg issues governance at the beginning there's
minimal discussion about these issues but growing into far more sophisticated approaches on the port of part of the board and and management to address esg integrating strategy esg into your strategy and at the beginning limited reporting through all the way through to integrated reporting and and even the whole issue of making sure that your measures are in some place same way shape or form audited so those are just some things to think
about that this does these issues cut across operations stakeholders governance strategy and reporting it's not just a reporting issue
so and i think over to you no me sorry still me sorry i'm i'm what i alluded this to this a little bit earlier that there is this journey and the last slide just talked about that which is that you start you gotta start somewhere and it is not necessary for every organization to get to the ultimate goal of level four that we talked
about in the in the maturity model that that we the kind of highlight of that that we just showed in the last slide what we see as the whole journey being is is a pretty interesting one and it can take a little bit of time but increasingly i think people are developing a set of urgency around this which is the first thing is to understand what what is your what is
your footprint and this is you know where does the business operate what is the extent of our scope one scope tubes go three emissions just for example and how do our products and services affect sustainability then there's this whole issue of identifying stakeholders figuring out what they care about what's going to be important to them and very importantly figuring out which esg topics are going to be
financially material to your organization because they're important to your stakeholders whether internally or externally assessing the materiality of these so that you're focused on the ones that make the most difference building a sense of what is already being done and i think in many cases organizations are surprised sometimes of the things that are already being done for example safety statistics may already be being gathered reported on de i initiatives may have already
started in your organization so inside your business what are you doing what are you not doing and and then basically gathering data from other companies what are they doing what are the implications for your own business and developing a strategic management approach and the governance systems to to enable you to not just talk about esg but to actually tackle make progress demonstrate the progress that you're making and and ensure
all the stakeholders that the right things are being done and then finally this notion of reporting and verification so those are all the steps that are required to to to accomplish esg and yes i know it's daunting and do you want to talk a little bit about this business footprint issue because it's fascinating yeah and then mary what we're going to do is of those seven steps we're just
going to do a little dip below the surface to give everybody here an idea when we talk about the whole idea before any esg topics can be identified it's so important to understand and conduct what we call this baseline assessment and really what we're doing is we're just mapping out what's your organization's operational footprint it's it's a way to know what you do where you do it including the products
and services that you offer and in essence it's like outlining the field for a football game it's hard to play the game of esg if you don't know where field is it also helps to know where your responsibility extends as we embrace the whole idea of of the many esg and sustainability topics and laser focus on those that are most material so that's that's business footprint and understanding boundaries how about
stakeholders again well the stakeholders i think i went on fairly extensively at the beginning but it's you know it's takes taking stock of all of these stakeholders engaging in initial conversations with all of them to ensure that you're clear about what expectations are and that you know there's no point running off madly in all directions on issues that people don't care about or that entities don't care about or that
they're not tracking but it is critical to get these conversations going quickly and to make sure that these conversations are being done in a way that is disciplined and and comprehensive so that things aren't being missed and identifying those topics mary i mean there seems to be a lot of what do we do what do we do so what one of the things that we do is depending on the
the level of concern on the part of different stakeholders is digging into figuring out which of the the topics that you need to focus on which reporting standards you need to think about and and basically making sure that you're not missing anything i did want to mention on the lower right hand side here what you see is this notion i was talking about with respect to stakeholder
conversations direct interviews are fine with some cases surveys are are fine working group discussions focus groups public information assessment and requests for comment there are lots of ways to engage with stakeholders and and the the way to engage with the stakeholders will differ by the type of stakeholder by the type of information that you're gathering and and doing a good job of this at the beginning is is will stand you in good
stead and we've got an example here of sasby is just a way to start sometimes with their clients it is a good way to start your healthcare delivery sector what are the things that people care about if you're in another sector you know getting a good start on that could be a way to to drive your stakeholder discussions at the very outset so once you get and what we're trying to
do is create this big funnel taking all esg topics and in materiality now becomes important because you can't deal with everything at once so you're trying to understand well which are material and materiality for esg is like financial materiality both are focused on information that would change the minds of stakeholders using that information but the approach is two-dimensional here for esg and not strictly quantitative on the one side the degree to which esg
topics will have a a bearing on the success of your organization's products people and services and the other is the importance of these esg topics to stakeholders the power of mapping the topics on this grid this approach if you know the idea of a picture says a thousand words well now you can see which topics are most important to you that significance of the top right is where you want to start now creating an
esg strategy to address each of those topics and address them meaningfully
and this is oops sorry and this is the whole point about figuring out what you're you're doing already in terms of health and safety i mentioned earlier that you may already be gathering statistics you may be have undertaking initiatives that very likely that health and safety is is something that's further along than it might otherwise be indigenous issues what kinds of initiatives are you undertaking with respect to communities
with whom you you are involved and in the topic of communities i think historically what's happened is that organizations have have relied on donations volunteering and that sort of thing but i think in here also is the whole issue of de and i and donations volunteering but taking this a step further to be really truly a part of communities i think is more what people are looking for these days
the environment we spend a lot of time talking about this but this is deciding on the standards deciding what you're going to be doing with respect to resource consumption and and employee behaviors and employees so d e i is a big aspect here or developing a workforce strategy in and of itself developing an employee brand so taking stock is a really good idea
because you may find yourself further along than you otherwise might have thought you were looking at the whole idea of data management and governance systems ultimately your organization will need to be setting targets measuring performance against those topics and reporting to external stakeholders this means your underlying management systems your control environment and data integrity is absolutely essential and with stakeholders like investors relying on this publicly disclosed information
reputation and attraction of capital is going to be key the emphasis on high quality verifiable and consistent data will become increasingly important and really should be a critical part of your esg strategy for building out your business model and this is the last step it's it's your step i think because you're the reporting and verification oh sure we end up at reporting and verification this is where you get to tell the good
news story what have we done if we have communicated targets how well are we achieving against those targets where should we be moving forward we're not quite hitting the targets we'd expected reporting is one part but there's going to be a growing movement and we're seeing it already today that just like your financial statements will be audited your sustainability information will also need to be verified so that the users like
investors and financial institutions can actually rely on it to make decisions about the long-term sustainability of your organization how can we help mary or how we can help basically mnp and you can tell that that ed and i are both quite passionate about this but we as a firm can can work with organizations to help them along this journey and so first of all there's this notion of
moving from the baseline to maturity and is this this idea of of strategically and and consistently in an organized discipline manner thinking through you know your initial assessment where you are in the maturity continuum and defining your desired state of maturity and then developing a business case for esg adoption and maturity and and so this is more of a strategic look at at esg and also involves
potentially training boards and management we do spend a lot of our time with stakeholder assessments identifying the the stakeholders conducting stakeholder consolidation and compiling inventories of topics for input and then also developing stakeholder engagement frameworks over the long run the impact side of things is to actually inventory esg topics conduct materiality assessments at linking eft topics specifically to corporate value and your strategic priorities and doing competitive benchmarking to ensure
that the targets that are being set and the ways that you're going about measuring esg factors is the ways are are up to our best best practice frameworks we can help our clients select the relevant and most appropriate esg frameworks and assist in setting targets and evaluate evaluating the data integrity for each of these topics and reporting we have helped our clients with designing report
formats templates developing integrated reporting approach approaches and ensuring that the quality quantity and quality of the information is correct and then finally there's the whole verification so third-party verifications assurance of esg reporting and testing and validation of the management systems so is the not so much the data itself but are the management systems themselves that are just that are generating the information integrated and appropriate so
pretty much along the continuum are things that that we can do to help our clients in this in this area so where does that leave us this is where we're gonna have to wrap up i would say we've hit the group with a lot to digest mary there's a lot in terms of the frameworks and the standards a lot in terms of the approach what we want to do
next out of this is we're going to do that deeper dive into some of the issues and topics around the cannabis and the extractive industries what should we be looking at how do we want to approach what are some of the commonly disclosed topics we're going to deal with that and have two separate sessions i would say today if you could take that internal look and ask yourself
where does my company sit on adopting sustainability if we look at that idea of maturity how mature would we be and if we know we need help get help that is the fundamental is this isn't something that's going to be going away it is fundamentally transforming how businesses operate today including all the drivers that mary talked about at the beginning of this so thank you this has been informative i
hope for everybody and we remain committed to answering any questions that come from it if there's anything else otherwise we'll see you in the individual presentations that will be following up to this general session thank you very much on behalf of the canadian securities exchange i'd like to thank you for joining us for esg in the capital markets and specifically i'd like to thank richard carlton mark faulkner mary
larson and edward olsen for their insights for their time their expertise and their knowledge on the subject of esg please make sure to join us tomorrow for a specific presentation on esg in cannabis and esg with regards to mining i've been your host barrington miller if you like this content and others please make sure to click subscribe or like on the various social media platforms thank you very much and we'll see you at the next
episode you



