About This Video
Operating a business is fraught with risks that can sidetrack a company's success and growth if not adequately mitigated or planned for. Operating a publicly traded company adds additional layers of risk in the form of compliance and disclosure obligations that increase the level of diligence required by executives of public issuers.
To help public public company CEOs navigate business risk in 2024 we have gathered an expert legal, audit, and insurance panel to highlight the strategies needed by public SMEs to identify and manage risks. Join CSE's Melissa Robertson as she is joined by Chuck Higgins, Maruf Raza, Mert Guler, and Rob Hanson as they touch on a variety of pertinent risk issues including First Nations relations, cryptocurrency, ESG, Bill S-211, auditor availability, cyber security, investor relations, 43-101 disclosure, and other risk-trends for 2024!
Read the TranscriptAuto-generated by YouTube; names and terms may be misspelled.
hello my name is Melissa Robertson with the Canadian Securities Exchange and I'm here to welcome you to this special presentation on business risk management for public companies brought to you by special guests from MMP peris Redmond and pilot law over the course of this webinar we'll be covering areas of risk for audit Insurance legal and much much more if you have feedback or comments there will be Links at the end and of
course if you like this video please feel free to share it first up I'd like to introduce Chuck Higgins managing principle at Pilot law providing Council on Commercial and financial matters he predominantly advises National investment dealers and international Mining and energy companies check his considerable experience joint ventures acquisitions and capital and debt transactions involving resource business thanks Melissa my name's as Melissa mentioned I'm Chuck Higgins and
my practice focuses on mining and energy companies so these these comments will reflect that Focus so we're talking about legal risks for for Mining and energy companies and I used to always tell clients that the legal risk was very small compared to the risk that they have in their businesses that have geological risks Capital Market risks commodity prices natural disasters Wars and Insurrection so don't worry so much
about legal risk we'll we'll manage that side but it's not not a big thing to focus on go go back and get your get your business running but that's changed and there's three areas of risk that I'd like to focus on right now the first one is for anybody who's operating in Canada virtually every project you're going to have is is going to involve dealing with First
Nations and the the risk that accompanies that there's the duty cons consultant virtually every step of developing a project and in many cases it amounts to an effective veto so how do you how do you how do you deal with that risk well my in our firm my colleague Howard Hampton the former minister of natural resources from Ontario who's from Fort
Francis has been very effective at dealing this and dealing with the First Nations and an example of this is a project that was up right off the Trans Canada Highway a gold project that had been stalled for 20 years through the problems with the with the the two relevant first stations and and the company that was operating now some new operators came along and and
Howard was able to meet with the First Nations determine you know who was in favor of development and ensure that they they that their voices were heard within the First Nations and to break this Log Jam and this company's been quite successful and has actually now started developing these projects but people always ask me wasn't that such a problem in Canada having to deal with First Nations everywhere well I I'd say
that they're all there're all some benefits now because if your Project's going to be be dealing with First Nations they're going to have the labor force that's close enough your project to help them H in addition and more recently the First Nations have access to Capital that you may not which is the first first nation's infrastructure fund among other various government initiatives to provide Capital to First Nations involved in projects and perhaps
the most important thing is that if you have a First Nations involved as a partner in a project environmental groups will find it very difficult to raise funds to fighting at First Nations but the secondary of risk which is which is developing is anybody who is operating outside can in the US you're likely working in a civil law system very different than the the legal
system we're used to here I always say that it's form over substance and paperwork rules and many jurisdictions that you operate on have requirements for local Partners managers directors and and shareholders so you can set these things up but then the question is what happens if things go bad and there is a risk of doing that your local manager goes Rogue so there are there are various ways to minimize that risk
from a legal perspective and then to build some protections into your employment Consulting contracts H looking at your corporate structure to set up you know holding corporations in jurisdictions that have more familiar legal systems but the other thing is is to also put in place all the documents you need to unwind everything you've done you know before you start off on the Venture so that would be undated
resignations RR transfers of shares tations of Powers of Attorney Etc the third area of risk is it litigation risk and there's two developments in in the area of litigation that affects companies and that have been that are relatively recent and that is contingency fees where lawyers can only share a share of the the proceeds of the of The Spoils of the litigation and
so companies don't have to you know pay legal fees up front and they only pay if they're successful the other thing is class actions which Prov which provide for you know a numerous P PLS that may have smaller cases to come together and see you successfully and both M both of these make it easier to sue companies and to sue their directors and there's a couple of suggestions
so directors when you're trying to avoid liability always seek advice from relevant experts geological legal accounting where you need them you you you won't get second guess for decisions where you don't agree with the advice you're getting but you will be second guessed if you don't get that advice and the other thing I would say which which will tie into our other presentations is get directors and officers Insurance even
if the chance of litigation successful litigation against you is low you still have the benefit of having the insurer defend the action and minimize the cost and the management time there also D insurance will clearly let you attract a wider pool of directors and officers than would otherwise be the case so those those are the three areas of legal risk that I'd i' highlights
for our group thanks M Lista back to you thanks so much chat next I'd like to introduce Maru frazza senior vice president assurance and national leader public companies at M&P Maru serves as an advisor to public companies and private companies planning on going public through direct initial public offerings or reverse mergers regarded as a thought leader on International Financial Accounting Standards IFRS where of has conducted technical research on IFRS and US Accounting
Standards including being a part of the CPA Canada's IFRS discussion group and various Committees of the Ontario Securities Commission thanks Melissa I'm here to talk about a little bit of the the risk side as it relates to the the audit world as well as the financial reporting World particularly as we see it from our perview as as Auditors to to many public compeny so one area we wanted to
highlight that we're increasingly seeing a lot of regulator activity is sort of around the e-commerce digital and and crypto space historic we would have generally looked at you know the fact that cash is Ki and when we you know when a company receives the cash that generally provides really good support for a transaction being you know validated and complete where directionally things are going now is
because of this significant Reliance that that is being placed on thirdparty service providers Regulators are increasingly expecting much more detailed governance and controls around that interface with with those third party providers so if you look at an example like a company that you know for example sells via Amazon so you know fulfilled by Amazon in many cases that company may not take you know delivery of its inventory it
might all be through Amazon all the reporting comes from Amazon U all the data comes from Amazon including the fact that they've made certain sales so when we look at it from an auditor perspective again as we said historically we would have looked at you know was the cash received and that's generally a good idea what Regulators are now requesting us as Auditors and management teams to do is to look
through those service providers so when you think about typical service providers like Shopify or if you're you know in the restaurant business you know using third party providers like Uber Eats all of these are our thirdparty providers that we now have to assess you know whether or not their information is reliable so in many cases you know these thirdparty providers would have what we would call sock reports or system
reports where a thirdparty auditor has come in and validated that yes it fact the controls at this third party are working but that's not always the case and and so you know when we look at things like cryptocurrency which are very obvious that there's such a heavy Reliance on on on digital Platforms in the crypto industry and and less obvious ones you know where a company
has a simple e-commerce website all of those are relying on these thirdparty service providers and so there's a risk from the perspective of these companies of these third party providers that they may not have the adequate documentation to provide to to you as public companies and so that could create challenges from a governance perspective so it's it's increasingly important to have these conversations upfront with your third-party service providers to
understand what they have so that when it's time for whether it's an audit from people like ourselves or from a regulated question that it that you have that ability to to support that moving on to another theme obviously lot of discussion you know in in current society and certainly in the capital markets around around ESG you know so that's relating to climate change and governance and we know that it is
that ESG reporting is on the horizon so when you look at Europe it is already there and so a lot of the ESG reporting framework we're already seeing coming in and we know that on in Canada it is on the horizon so the reporting standards have been released what we understand is that for now most of that disclosure will be driven towards the mdna versus the financial statements and
that's potentially a good thing because once it starts feeding into the statements then of course you're going to need assurance and audit on on on on on that data and so today we're obviously not quite there yet in terms of in terms of in terms of those disclosures even though we know they're coming but what we have to watch for right now and what certainly what the security commissions are watching for in
both the statements and in the mdna that we're not being overly promotional so you know they've provided examples where you know companies are saying well we're going to be net neutral by 2030 or we're going to have a carbon footprint of X by 2027 a lot of those items are not yet substantiated and so in continuous disclosure reviews you can expect that if you put out certain types of
disclosures that that align with that that the that Securities commissions are going to ask you to validate how in fact that's going to happen between now in 20 20 2030 so what we are seeing certainly with the larger companies they're actually softening some of those disclosures now when we typically look at many of our our Venture type companies we're you know I I think that we're not as exposed because we've
limited the amount of disclosure what we what we are seeing is that security these commissions are expecting some type of disclosure at this point is relatively high level certainly certain industries if you're in energy of course or mining there is a there's a greater drive to having more advanced disclosures now but at this point it's obviously not required we should we should point out that when we look at ESG one of the
big considerations is going to be lending considerations so when when we when we've when we SP spoken to lenders like the banks they are certainly going to consider ESG policies in their lending decision whether that's a l no l or it is it is you know relating to what your interest rates might be all of that will be factored in into those discussions the other beast that's
that's you know also being forgotten is that in many cases the the footprint from an ESG perspective of a particular issue or company maybe more or less limited but you also have to look at where the company fits in the in the supply chain so for example if you're selling into Walmart and Walmart has you know the need to disclose certain elements from their ESG oring they may
look you know Downstream at at at at some of their suppliers and say hey we need some of this information and if you are going to supply into Walmart there's a bunch of data elements that need to com so the big piece of course with ESG is going to be data and how you capture the data that's necessary so while we do have some time in in terms of getting
there it isn't too early to start start to start thinking about to start thinking about that so one thing that is more immediate that is it's not directly ESG but it it it is related there's a bill called s211 that was passed by the Canadian government and and this is an anti- anti-slavery and and child labor bill that that's been sponsored by the government
and the key item to take away is that there is a report that all public companies need to file by May 31 of 2024 so that's that's just you know five months away that actually goes through and and provides disclosure me around the the public company's policies around these matters and this includes the supply chain so as an example if you're a if you're a Canadian public
company and you are you know manufacturing or Distributing products any elements along the supply chain both Canadian and foreign you have to basically disclose what you've done to Val validate that your suppliers are not engaging it in these in these in these practices so if you think about a Canadian company that is importing goods from a foreign country those suppliers are captured and so at this point they're not necessarily saying you need
to go and audit those suppliers and make sure everything's are right but they are asking what is your policy you know in terms of the suppliers you're using and so this is a fairly critical item that is coming up and as I said it is mandatory for every public company and non-compliance or in terms of filing the report it's a it's a $250,000 pedal so there is some substance here in terms of
getting this done so it it's something you know if your service providers haven't spoken to you either your Auditors or your or or or your law firms it is something you want to bring up immediately as there is some effort needed in terms of devel developing and delivering this report finally I'll you know I'll I'll I'll me mention you know one area that I think you know it's not
necessarily A a direct risk from a from a company's operational perspective except for the fact that you know it is it is heavily tied in with the compliance of the company so as as we know all public companies are required to file you know annual audit financial statements in some cases there are requirements during the year for interim reviews depending on you know whether you're you're doing prospectus offerings
and of course in order to go public you have to provide audited financial statements generally that's that's very much an accepted element you know there hasn't really been any issues in the past what we're finding in the last couple of years for for a number of reasons some of it is capacity some of it was was covid and some of it is relatively new where we are seeing you
know increased regulator actions on firms as well as firm withdrawals as a result and and for for other reasons as well all of that combined has led to I think for the first time in in probably you know 25 years an inability to always find an auditor and so we do see issuers struggling sometimes and in some cases it's industry specific like when we talked
about crypto earlier very few Auditors right now are are touching crypto because of some of the regulatory hurdles that are associated with it and in other cases it's just capacity so we do see firms you know restricting how many clients they can take combine that all together certainly if you're doing a a new go public deal it is you know it is quite critical to ass certain
that you do have auditor availability I think usually that discussion may have happened further down the line I think it's one of those discussions that you want to have right up front and certainly if you're in the process of changing Auditors for you know whatever reason it's important to understand what is available out there from an RFB perspective because I think some companies have gotten a little bit stuck
you know you know in that regard with that I'll I'll I'll end my end my present ation certainly happy to answer any questions but with that Melissa I'll turn it back to you thank you Maru please welcome both mert guler partner Capital marit to peris Redmond and Rob Hansen Easter region D leader at pervis Redmond W's focus is developing prl's relationships within the Canadian
Capital markets ecosystem including CSE and its issuers Securities and m&a lawyers Auditors broker dealers and other regulated financial service providers he is actively involved in providing risk advice and due diligence for companies looking to go public raise capital and expand their businesses he also works with many Real Estate Investors and developers with risk assessment and insurance and advice Rob is an insurance specialist based in Toronto Ontario responsible for the
direct oversight of the financial lines portfolio in Eastern Canada Rob has over 15 years of experience in the financial and executive Risk insurance space well thanks so much Melissa I really appreciate it for for our firm this conversation started in the summer with members of the csse just sort of talking about how maybe we could help csse issuers think about risk assessment risk identification risk management and those types of things not
not in terms of hey we're multi-billion dollar Global conglomerates we're New York Stock Exchange no rather for mediumsized businesses in Canada publicly traded on the Canadian Securities Exchange so we started thinking about about how to present some very direct and simple advice to Executives of CSC issuers one of the first things we thought about was sort of an analogy with kind of driving risk and a risk
assessment and risk management as relates to driving a car risk is inherent in everything we do we want to drive safely and carefully and insurance is just a sort of safety net a back stop in the event of in the event of something bad happening but we don't rely on insurance first and foremost so with with that kind of analogy this this is sort of a heat map that we use
extensively in the insurance sector and the risk management sector I've been involved in some very large projects where where this this type of risk assessment tool has been used and it's it's kind of self-explanatory would be around a board or Executives sitting around and brainstorming and doing tabletop exercises and talking about what are the kind of things that could possibly affect their business and throughout my
career in s 24 years in insurance we help our customers identify and prioritize key risks and then manage them this this slide here this heat map is talking about of course identifying first identifying andent sort of prioritizing critical risks most of which are probably outside of your control in you know in the world of cures this could be risks around cannabis legislation and legalization in cannabis legislation or a lack of
decisions and legislation by governments it could be around big economic things that affect everybody from covid or interest rates or anything like that the the the very tough situation in the crypto winter and with FTX and things like that have really hurt a lot of business businesses in the digital assets sector these are some things that that can be predicted some of them cannot be but thinking about what could
go wrong and starting to think about how to plan out scenarios is what a good risk adviser could help you do my partner Rob Hansen is going to talk about how how Executives focus on decisions and then I'll continue with some of the things that you can do in your own business awesome well thanks Mark taking a bit of a step back I mean really the key risk for public issuers
before 2005 was primarily fraud if you think of edron and Brix or really complete financial mismanagement and in the Canadian context think of Nell not to get too legally here but in 200 2005 Bill 198 came so what Bill 198 does it amends the Ontario securance act and its statutory Provisions that govern public companies here and really where a much higher standard of disclosure obligations now must be met
by Canadian directors and officers and where the avenue to to prosecute public companies under this act has become far more open since and with these new rules there became a much larger gray area I'll call it gray area for PL of firms and shareholders to bring legal action against public companies here more specifically since the ACT discusses things like acting in good faith or proper due diligence or reporting
material changes or taking appropriate action on an issue this gave plaintiffs and shareholders really the ability to challenge firms on these potential grounds so what is proper due diligence to one may not actually be proper due diligence to another what is a material change to one might not actually be a material change to another and so on I mean what's what's an appropriate action taken by the D's and
O's over an issue may be appropriate to one may not be appropriate to another and so despite really the good intent of this act to to protect shareholders or really any stakeholder through a higher level of public company disclosure standards it really has opened the door for a lot more subjective H you really should have done this type of lawsuits versus objective you actually did this type of lawsuits
and as for tips for I guess good corporate governance it was mentioned by you know one of my colleagues before I'm really the advice is to is to show your work I was speaking with a very respected defense attorney once where where I was hoping to get some good Intel on really what the be best offense is for a public company who's challenged on their disclosures
you know for having misrepresented the street and she she said to me and really not to over over said Li but it's the same advice that she gets her 12-year-old doing the school project or writing a test show your work show your work show your work if you can show your process and really all the due diligence that went into I'll say your final answer in school but really your public
disclosure for what we're talking about here here even if the end answer isn't perfect you know if you can show your process that you sought you know the right kind of advice along the way that you really did do your diligence even if that final answer disclosure is not actually correct where the grade 12 student can get part marks I mean the damages for a public company
can be far far less in a legal situation if you can actually show your work and you know prove that you acting in good faith and really sought the right you know Financial legal experts you know to help you get to the point where you made that representation to the street what what comes to my mind is in terms of governance is sort of including risks in the decision-making process the the
wide array of risks when when Executives make decisions for the company and just to use a couple of examples I'm thinking about the very last box here there's a lot of things that that a company can do just a little bit differently to really reduce risks that might that might include using contracts like one of the best things we we see to to reduce company's risks are using
contracts maybe the mineral exploration field it's using contracts with your contractors in in the technology sector it's using contracts with your customers and suppliers for example that's that's one thing that's a that's always recommended in in in in Mineral exploration which is a big big area for csse we see it's really important to consider the health safety of your employees and and expats who may
be traveling in different countries maybe more hazardous regions simple things like that ensuring everybody has workers Cal coverage simple things like that that could really reduce a company's risk so that's what we talk about that's an example of embedding risk management related thinking in your decision-making yeah I'll just kind of wrap up with a couple case studies I mean Mt and I have spent a lot of our
careers in the risk management space and at the end of the day for a public issuer which is why we're here today one of the most me I guess really catastrophic type of events is that there is a catastrophe that may cause bodily injury property damage and also where there is a mega stock drop that ensues because of this big event even where companies who do have the
best red management procedures and not to give the insurance pluged but really Insurance should be a part of this discussion you're managing the risk and then options to potentially transfer the risk in in these you know Mega worst case scenario situations so just a couple of examples here for what we see as the most common for public issuers case number one is really the the overpromise under deliver I guess
allegation that we're seeing really it's when a public company says they're going to do X they didn't do x stock suffered and investor suit for misrepresentation this is really the most prevalent with smaller startups and and brand new issuers I think Maru was mentioning this for as well you know tapering what you're saying you're going to do is is extremely important as risk mitigation strategy not shooting for the
moon you know it's very very important you know to to keep that in mind and and we've got the picture of the tight rope here because essentially you're walking that tight you want to attract investors you want to sell the story you want to get you know people to invest invest in you but you know you don't also do not want to overshoot or overpromise what you you know feel
like you actually are going to achieve and and statistics actually show that brand new issuers kind of year one post whether it's an RTO or an IPO but year one of being a public issuer we see more times than not companies getting hot water in that first year sort of post are just becoming public it kind of tapers off as you go but pler firms are really kind of focusing on you
I'd say in in the first year or two after you know becoming public so if we move on to the second one call this event driven litigation I mean long are the pre-2005 days that I mentioned before where it's really just the bankruptcies and and we're seeing what we call event driven litigation and better put this is really one an unpredict completely unpredictable event happens and the stock takes a big hit
and then allegations emerge you know that the dzos should have done something or should have better disclosed this potential risk to the streak before this mega event actually happened and a few of the best examples that we do see are one a big environmental related issue we've seen for example a mine you know tailing Dam collapse or a significant stop drop happens after that we've seen
a big safety Rel we've seen a lot of safety related issues and the best public example we'd like to give is Boeing I'm sure everyone here has heard of Boeing and the 737 Max in that one there were allegations that you know the dies know actually misled the street about the safety features of the aircraft so when the tra actually happened and then the stock
Dred while you know it was Mega hundreds of million of dollars for you know that went into actually the death of the individuals in the craft there was about another 150 million that investors were actually able to claim you know in in a dno superious class action lawsuit I'm going into the third case this is this kind of does fit in the aventur and bucket but I do feel
like cyber warrants its own separate comment in that sort of worst case scenario that again this is where a company suffers a mega cyber breach you know which which can in and of itself can potentially be financially crippling from a business Interruption standpoint you're taking down the cost to notify anyone whose personal information in your system may have been compromised because of the breach and
then you kind of go down the road gets out the public that that has happen you suffer a mega stop drop and then investor sue you as well I know Maru mentioned before there there's not necessarily hard and fast rules on Cyber disclosure in Canada yet just like on the ESG front which I know we spent a little bit of time on but they they are
coming the SEC has very strict guidelines about how to disclose your cyber risks what to do in the event of an actual breach there are General guidelines in Canada not necessarily carbon fast rules but we know it's coming and and again from a risk management standpoint it's you know be in lock step with your with your trusted advisers and have a Playbook on what to
do in the events you know you know this this does happen terrific summary Rob and I think these are great cases and examples of litigation and what could go wrong for public Executives and some great risk management advice thanks very much Melissa and over to you thanks so much for those presentations everybody we're gonna do a Q&A Now with James Black VP listings development and myself
Melissa Robertson so we're going to start with you Mt and Rob we talk about the type mope or a fine line of attracting investors but not over promising and underd delivering so what would you recommend especially to newer issuers trying to find this balance now thanks Melissa an excellent question and and really what we'd recommend here is a very buttoned up investor relations strategy where a
CEO and a CFO are in complete lock step where we've seen isers get into trouble if you almost think of the Angel and the devil more times than not the CEO is the promoter they are the one trying to attract the investment you know they're they're the ones talking to the streets and then you have the CFO on the other end as well and for a new issuer you
know comes with all these disclosure obligations Etc that we talked about before so especially for new issuers it's really having a buttoned up investor relation strategy and where the CEO or the person who is promoting the stock you know and you know speaking to institutional or retail investors on a day-to-day basis to make sure that they're a complete walk step with you know the CFO and the finance team who
was ultimately working with our friend Maru and and you know actually you know involved in you know creating the financials that then go up to the street as well so bit of a simple answer to you know just half a good investor relation strategy but more times and not we do see for a new issue where is that angel in the devil you got the promoter
and you got the finance person and they really got to be on the same page with everything that's you know not not necessarily that they're just publishing in in print but also saying you know to the street when they're when they're doing Road Show for example so hope that answers the question and thanks for that I've actually got a question for Chuck sort of dovet tals
off the mineral exploration disclosure in the world of talking about 4311 so what are some common risks that you see entered into when people make disclosure statements around 43 101 backed disclosure so I thinking about the mineral exploration CEO talking about mineral property is there anything from a risk perspective that you want to caution the cosos from entering into whether it's being
too technical with the information or Pro possibly not being technical enough when saying certain things things that I see come up that U that people are a bit surprised with you're an exploration company and you usually have a couple of properties and it really is important to step back and say what's material and what isn't because if you got a property that's material you've got 4311 obligations if it's not Material you can
say that isn't you can't take the position that a property is not material and then have endless promotional things on your website about it we've just gone through that with a client that's had to redo a 4311 on a property that was completely inaccessible had to fly in people by helicopter it hadn't had a 4311 in 20 years only because they kept on talking about the benefits of the
great benefits of this project on their website the other the other issue that I always tell people is if you can if you can find a way to move your operations from BC to Ontario you'll find much more reasonable Regulators well that's a very popular thing to say but we have moved a number of our clients from BC to Ontario and and the other thing is
when you when you go your QPS make sure the QPS have expertise on what they're talking about because if you get an advanced project you've got Metallurgy and all kinds of other things that someone who's a QP that did just does exploration would be totally unqualified to speak about and The Regulators are looking for that they're looking for the qualification specific not that just they were a QP generally with a QP for
the fa that they're actually cating on so that's that's sort of a to start with things thanks so much anyone have any thoughts on you know things that you see in the metal metal space Metals disclosure space that gives you a a point of caution or pause when advising clients what thing if I could throw out there James is I'm not
necessarily specific to Mineral exploration but in general further to what Chuck and Rob was saying it's probably a good idea to have your legal counsel to have Chuck or your other legal advisers take a look at ke disclosures your investor presentation and for the executives to agree on that tight rope on what you're promising without guaranteeing anything but what what are we going to
promise is probably good to have your your legal council and your internal board all on the same page there that's those are some key risks that I've learned about today Sage advice no good point I think in the in the mining space specifically and if we're talking Securities class action theal for prob is underd delivery it's it's timeline to production and companies that just really really miss because
usually there's a big stock run runup leading to commercial production and when they're when companies are way off with the timing actually bring a site online and or is the economics end up being way off it ends up costing you much more than you disclose like that's that's your easy overpromise underd deliver right there you you missed you missed the time to bring it to production and the and the economics are
not what you said they were going to be one other areas the the the grade of or itself I know there's a lot of people typically involved on the GE geology side making sure and verifying that the grade that you say you are getting over the ground is true but you know we have seen some situations where you know the third party verification firms aren't I don't not want to necessarily use the
term honest but may have cut a few corners and where eventually what dis got disclosed to the street you know wasn't really and truly the grade that was to be expected that this company was going to be pulling over the ground for the next 10 years so grade and time to production and missing the economics wouldn't do you know site do come online is how I would answer specifically to
mining Rob let me let me put something positive in here where seem to be the the Bo everywhere there's risks everywhere and stuff one thing about 4311 if you can get things into 431 like production forecasts and those things those things you can lift right off in your disclosure and they're generally exempt from free faux feed rules the for forward oriented financial information that the yors and everybody
all this Frets over so so get that stuff in your 4311 get it right and then you can use it you don't have to worry about your are telling no you can't do that we're not verifying it and it's not going on so that's H just something positive I would throw out there thanks chck I have a I have a question for Maru I think this is especially relevant
right now but what are the potential risk impacts of current market conditions such as lack of financings on reporting and audits yeah I think the I think that the the primary sort of pervasive one that that sort of is is important and it ties into risks and legal you know elements is whether or not you know you you have sufficient you know funding or or resources to to make it through the
next 12 months and so typically if you don't there's there's a a bunch of required disclosure almost a buyer beware that goes into the mdnn financial statement so it's it's incredibly important to to warn investors in some cases it's fairly obvious in other cases it isn't and so it's it's important you know particularly now because as we know most most of our you know Venture type
companies they they do go financing to financing they're in many cases pre- Revenue and so once you turn off the the sort of the financing element or you slow it down based on market conditions that you know there is no new funding that comes in and and it can lead to to challenges right and we know obviously op the operational challenges but but from an investor perspective it is one
relevant and two required to actually highlight that you know what I may not have enough resources to finish the year now we not that doesn't necessarily mean that you know the company's done and and the way you go it just means you you are just saying that hey there's there's a chance and there's a risk and we're talking about we're talking about risks here that's probably the most pervasive
risk you could have is the ability to continue as a company so I think you know we expect to see more of that this year you know than than we've had in in the last few and that's typical I don't think anybody's going to be surprised you know when when they see some of these disclosures and again it's it it helps protect the company it
helps protect the investors as well as the directors so it it is it is a good disclosure there I think when you go a little bit more finite say more into a more financial statement element naturally when you run out of money there is a discussion that comes out are you able to finish your projects so if you're a mining company are do you have resources to continue to fund the
development and that's the same if you're in R&D or if you're in software and very well you might already be in Revenue it's still a conversation that comes up and the key there is all of that boils into do are are the are the values that you're reporting are they still correct so if you're a mining property and and you know you have this value on your balance sheet well perhaps
it's no longer recoverable and it might be recoverable again in the future once market conditions turn but today it isn't and so there is an expectations that you would see more write Downs more impairments and investors would be looking for that so if you are overstating you know what you have you you you you're you're pushing the company into a risk position from an investor perspective because someone's
going to unduly rely on what you've put out there as being overly optimistic and so it ties into some of the other the earlier conversations you know from from Charles and M Rob so I'll stop there awesome thanks M and okay so from the purview of a Canadian listed company me these companies are just operating in Canada we've talked a lot about domestic risk considerations but operating
internationally like many of these mining companies you mentioned or if you're in tech software we' even seen in the Cannabis space those who have reached out into different foreign markets obviously your risk profile changes when you start operating outside your own borders perhaps Chuck you can just start off with this one but when you start going outside Canada what are some of the things you advise
clients on to First really be aware from a risk perspective I know it's a broad question but I think you can probably just narrow down the first things you just really got to think about when you start getting on those planes and going to a foreign country and start operating well the first thing I would do is tell people don't do it don't go internationally there's lots of land in
North America that's underexplored to go there but if you insist on doing it look at every step first of all talk to your Council your Canadian or us Council and get hooked up with Council that really know what they're doing in the local jurisdictions it's we've got we've got a bar here with some you know great lawyers and some questionable lawyers and people who don't know what
they're doing in in various spaces out and internationally it's the same if not more so so try and get try and get some good legal advice before you do it and think about everything you're doing and think about how you could undo it if things go wrong here you can undo things pretty easily overseas it's going to be difficult I don't prove you got a local company to proove well you got to have a
loc you got to have one local shareholder one sharehold by local people and if that shareholder goes a bit Rogue they can stop you from having shareholders meeting stop you from making Chang ches stopping doing things you got to have a way to undo undo things when when they go in there and also you're going to have a a local partner it's it pays to do a bit of
due Diles and check the boat and see what their previous track records been with other people and I some clients speak about that from bitter experience they didn't check out obviously there was information available they could have seen this this local partner has never had a lot of lot of success operating with the with foreign companies and yeah so i' you know keep keep your eyes open it's it's the
risk reward I mean there's a there's there there's there are clearly you know bigger rewards in in some of these places and what's the consumate bigger risk and you got to work a little harder to minimize that risk yes and hire the requisite professionals locally to help you manage and navigate that over to you Melissa for today's Final panel question yeah thank you so much for all of your
perspectives today that we' believe it with risk trends for 2024 so if anyone wants to speak to their thoughts on what's coming up what what these companies should be focused on Melissa I'm happy to start I mean you know I think it was it was partly you know I I was touching on it but I think you know in times when you know markets are are
getting a bit drier the the appetite for overly promotional disclosure increases not decreases and look we understand the Venture markets we understand there's a there's a fine line between you know being Market Savvy and pushing forward the company's agenda in a correct way and and then going a bit offside and I think now as people maybe perhaps in some companies you know they get a bit more
desperate you know for financing whatever you know there is an element of of of that so I think there's some of it which we normally see and and expect you know we we understand mining we understand you pre-revenue companies I I think what we're beginning to see is things like Securities commissions really are holding in in their continuous disclosure reviews on some of that type of disclosure I mean they're
always looking but I think now it's it's it's it's it's difficult to be overly optimistic when you do see the macroeconomic conditions that are in front of us so I think that obviously all the good things that are being done should be promoted and promoted well we just need to be careful that we're not as an ecosystem putting forward an image that you know everything is is
fantastic right and in some and in some cases it is right but in other cases we we we do need to recognize some of some of those elements because because everybody is paying attention and we we need to all collectively protect ourselves as well as the people that we that we work with and that we invest with yeah I'd like to again again try say something positive for 2024 and that
is really since the interest rates started to rise it's been very difficult for junior companies to get get capital and a lot of them have merged or Fallen by the wayside and I like to think that the ones that survived and been able to keep the lights on or keep doing things are have a lot of opportunities going forward I'm thinking of company companies that are
doing copper the price of gold is cooperating those things so I'm I'm I'm cautiously optimistic for 2024 we may have Peak with our interest rates we may have money starting to come back into the risk market and the companies that are left are the survivors of a very difficult couple of years maybe if I could throw some thoughts in as well is like like
Chuck maybe to to put a little bit of some some positive hopes for next year we've we've been approached by maybe four or five companies just in the last sort of 45 days who are thinking about going public thinking about an RTO typically on the CSE Rob and I have been chatting with several particularly in Tech life science some sort of new emerging Technologies as well as a slew
of slew of exploration and Mining sector and hopefully there's some positive sort of silver lightings in the IPO and RT RTO markets for next year but what Rob and I are are are very kind of careful about is when talking to these leaders is helping them budget think think a little bit about how the the costs as a public company will start to go up Insurance we're insurance
advisers insurance will start to go up and especially if you think about any us any any us activity that's when costs go up much faster so that's just also something to be cognizant of and talk to all the good advisers that you already know all right well thanks everyone and thanks everyone for dissipating



