About This Video
The CSE is excited to partner with MNP for our virtual event, ESG in the Capital Markets, on October 4-5, 2021.
ESG: A Journey to Strategic Advantage
The growing push towards great sustainability and accountability is resonating across all industries and sectors. For publicly-traded companies, executives face pressures from progressive customer bases, strict regulators and investors who want to minimize risk wherever possible. This means that companies must demonstrate unparalleled agility and innovation across the global business landscape.
Many companies are turning to environmental, social and governance (ESG) strategies to differentiate their companies among investors and consumers. But how best to implement these – and what are the most important factors to consider?
Join us on October 5, where we will provide key insights regarding ESG in the cannabis and mining spaces. Through this session, you’ll learn about selecting topics to focus on and who to consult to make the best decision for your organization in the cannabis or mining sector.
0:00 - Intro
1:38 - Introduction to ESG and the Mining Industry with Mary Larson and Edward Olson
15:37 - Mining: Overarching Trends
18:43 - Mining: Environmental, Social, & Governance Impacts/Considerations
36:45 - Mining: Standards & Frameworks
42:19 - Mining: Implementation & Next Steps
46:25 - Introduction to ESG and the Cannabis Industry with Mary Larson and Edward Olson
54:45 - Cannabis: History/Trends
58:53 - Cannabis: Environmental, Social, & Governance Impacts/Considerations
1:20:32 - Cannabis: Standards & Frameworks
1:24:42 - Cannabis: Implementation & Next Steps
1:28:23 - Wrap-Up
Subscribe for more great CSE insights and interviews here: https://go.thecse.com/CSETV-Subscribe
STAY CONNECTED WITH THE CSE
=============================
- PODCAST: https://blog.thecse.com/cse-podcasts/
- INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/canadianexchange/
- LINKEDIN: https://ca.linkedin.com/company/canadian-securities-exchange
- FACEBOOK: https://www.facebook.com/CanadianSecuritiesExchange/
- TWITTER: https://twitter.com/CSE_News
- BLOG: https://blog.thecse.com/
- WEBSITE: https://thecse.com/
Read the TranscriptAuto-generated by YouTube; names and terms may be misspelled.
welcome to esg in the capital markets a special presentation of the csc in partnership with mnp join us as we explore environmental social and governance strategies and their importance in the global business landscape the push towards sustainability is resonating across all industries and sectors many publicly traded companies are turning to esg to differentiate themselves among investors and consumers but how should these strategies be implemented and what are the most
important factors to consider we will explore esg fundamentals for publicly traded companies and include a special focus on cannabis and mining where education meets opportunity this is esg in the capital markets welcome to esg in the capital markets day two brought to you by the canadian securities exchange in partnership with mnp this two-day event will look at the subject of environmental social and governance strategies from a macro level
while today we will provide key insights regarding esg in cannabis and mining spaces through this session you'll learn about selecting topics to focus on and who to consult to make the best decision for your organization in the cannabis and mining sector mary larson partner at mnp and edward olsen leader environmental social and governance at mnp will lead you through this discussion thank you hi everyone welcome to this session of
esg for publicly traded companies a deep dive into the mining industry edu series if you've seen our first general presentation that's great if not i would highly recommend that you go back and look at some of the general concepts around esg that we presented there my name is edward olson i lead the sustainability practice here at mmp i'm also a regional leader of our enterprise risk services practice
my background in training is that i am a chartered accountant by trade and i've been involved in many different roles in business models regarding sustainability over the last 20 years this is this has covered everything from sustainability auditing to environmental management systems carbon credits including even being down to having the responsibility for running a company and setting its strategy and operations related to alternative energy i am a member of cpa canada
sustainability reporting advisory committee and sit on a global esg advisory committee with the institute of internal auditors this is going to be a great topic today and i'm so happy to be joining my colleague esteem colleague mary larson mary if you could introduce yourself that would really be great great yes thanks ed yes we're very excited to be giving this talk today to you and and sharing some some
insights around the mining sector and esg i am a partner with mnp and lead the national organizational renewal practice which includes strategy organization design esg strategy and deni among other service lines i have been involved with sustainability as an issue strategic issue with my clients for about 20 years i was one of the founding members of the finance and sustainability issue which was designed to help financial
executives and investors to become more knowledgeable about esg and we launched actually a certification program through concordia university about 18 years ago i've also been involved with several companies including the business development bank of canada helping them become b corps and have also led a number of efforts to help impact investment organizations develop their strategies so with that i think let's dive in the objectives of the session today are
to talk a little bit about the big esg trends that you in the mining industry are experiencing they're they're specific and they are big we're also going to identify esg issues as they relate to the mining industry and talk about some mitigation strategies things that we're seeing various players tackle to address these esg issues and then finally we're going to spend some time talking about regulations and standards
that are being used and how you can go about adopting and implementing some of these standards well if i could kick things off based on those objectives mary we're here to talk about esg so let's be clear on what esg really is esg is truly a means to evaluate factors and those factors are on how advanced companies are with regards to sustainability understanding these factors is essential
to mapping out how many non-financial factors really do have a financial impact so what are some of these well it's encompassed right now on screen between these three different pillars the environmental factors themselves include the contribution a company makes to climate change through greenhouse gas emissions along with waste management and energy efficiency given renewed efforts to combat global warming cutting emissions and decarbonizing is becoming more important social that whole social pillar includes
human rights labor standards in even the supply chain any exposure exposure to illegal child labor or modern day slavery and more routine issues like adherence to workplace health and safety the strength of your social strategy actually it's risky if your company is well integrated with the local community and therefore you have a social license to operate if you don't have that there's a risk in your esg strategy that
you have to consider and when you look at governance that far right pillar it refers to that set of rules or principles that define rights responsibilities and expectations between different stakeholders in the governance of companies like you attending today a well-defined corporate governance system can be used to balance or even align interest between stakeholders and can work as a tool to support a company's long-term strategy but
here's what i want you to think about these concepts themselves aren't new it's not new to say that we need to care about the environment and it's not new to say that we should treat people well both employees in the communities where we operate what is what is really new is the approach to and this whole embodiment of a change to adjust course and and this change of course
this is a reorientation of capital reprioritation prioritization of even efforts it's strategic alignment of partnerships so mary with what i've been talking about how did we even get here well it's been a long journey there's no doubt about that this this whole idea of corporate social responsibility started in the 1970s and i think it was to some extent a response to the single-minded focus on shareholders and that this notion that
companies only existed to benefit shareholders and people began to say well there's got to be something beyond that because companies do more than necessarily just enrich their their shareholders or are they out to after all they employ people there is some responsibility for the fact that the products that they produce ought to be safe and promote health and that working environments ought to to be ones that
promoted security and safety on the part of employees and so this led into beginnings of a discussion that led in 1994 to a radical idea which was that we actually want to measure a triple bottom line of a company's performance so yes there's the financial bottom line but there ought to be a people account and a planted account if you will and this idea was very slow to take to
take root in fact i think a lot of people thought it was kind of a silly idea until 2005 when the united nations began to get very active on this and pri was developed and the notion of who cares wins study by the un global contact compact which include concluded that better investment leads to more sustainable societies and there began to be a work done to demonstrate that a focus on
sustainability actually led to more favorable financial results and with that in 2015 the united nations sustainable development goals were defined and these were 17 sustainable goals around things ranging from health education access to health care the rights of women and a number of other things around safe water and safe air and safe working environments that were developed with a typically a 15-year goal horizon so that the the implementation
would actually start to be undertaken on a global basis and hopefully to be completed by 2030 with some goals extending far beyond that but the world began to take notice and i think what's happened significantly with kovid is that people have gotten very serious about some of these issues people have had time to think about this and of course the the whole issue of climate change has become now broadly
accepted and in fact we know that we're on the nasty side of all of that with a great sense of urgency to do something about it so that's the evolution of kind of the story and and do you want to talk a little bit about some of the things that are that are really putting pressure on esg yeah thanks thanks mary i would actually say to understand esg is to understand the
drivers that are influencing change and i'm only going to address a couple of these that you see on screen right now if i just pick the first one being banking and financial institutions let's talk about the principles for responsible banking it was created in 2019 by the united nations environment program finance initiative and the principles they're a unique framework for ensuring that signatory banks that their strategy and practices align
with the vision that society has set out for its future within what mary was talking about here the un sustainable development goals and the paris climate agreement just since inception in 2019 those signatories they number 229 banks that represent close to 2 billion customers worldwide that represent almost 60 trillion in global banking assets so the primary focus here is to drive change by the banking community
and that's through a a positive contribution to people on the planet that society expects so is anything happening well yes there is global adoption of net zero finance emissions and and those commitments come from most major global banks in fact if you take that lens and look at canada most if not all of our largest financial institutions here of canada have already committed to net zero finance emissions
which really means accessing capital will come with with more strings attached and expectations than has ever been experienced before and that this change will start heating up as banks seek to seek to meet those those global public commitments that they have made but if we switch gears a little bit here we can look at governments while there is much happening globally let's just take a look specifically at
canada in 2016 we had our approved strategy called the pan canadian framework on on clean growth and climate change we can then look at the canadian securities administrators in their staff known as notice 51-358 that addresses reporting on climate change-related risks and we know that earlier this year the ontario capital markets modernization task force well they're asking for more to be done more stringent climate related reporting than what was previously required
and how just this year the federal government passed bill c-12 and that bill is called the canadian net zero emissions accountability act so now this bill places into law canada's commitment to reaching that zero carbon emissions so governments and their public policy positions are really driving change if i switch gears just again human resources and workforce strategies are important for attracting retaining skilled resources if we dissect all age brackets and just
look at millennials a third of those millennials have already left their companies for a more inclusive one which highlights do you even have a robust diversity equity and inclusion strategy because if you don't you're running the risk of both attracting and retaining your human resources and skilled resources for your business just last comment if i could if we consider accounting standard setting bodies i'm keeping a close eye on the
international financial reporting standards foundation i said earlier that i sit on cpa canada's sustainability reporting advisory committee and we had the head of the ifrs foundation come to speak to us their focus is set this year in november in glasgow at the united nations climate change conference which is also known as cop 26. and this is when they are going to outline their roadmap for the creation of a sustainability standards board and
that this board will set expectations globally and what's going to be included in their standards while this will drive the need for a more formal approach to sustainability reporting that will eventually become mandatory so mary i just scratched at a few things there but i should probably pass it back to you right now right so here what we're going to do now is sort of switch gears and talk about
specifically the mining industry and as i said earlier we're going to talk about the trends that we're looking at the esg impacts and considerations and then go into this discussion of mitigation strategies to deal with the esg impacts that we're looking at and then talk about sas be considerations that are applicable to the mining industry is specifically and i just want to mention that we we use sasby throughout this document
partly because it deals with all three aspects of esg and also because there is a framework that is highly accessible and easy to use and it's a good place to start so there are other other standards that we might have delved into but we wanted to keep things relatively straightforward and comprehensible and if you don't know what those top global esg standards or frameworks are we addressed that in our first general
presentation so if you haven't seen it by all means please go in and watch that if we just look at overarching trends for years the focus of the extractive sector was really on lowest cost for maximum production output and that this focus turned i would say a blind eye to many environmental social and governance issues that impacted many different stakeholders a eternal regulation really did put a spotlight on the health and
safety of employees working in and and living near mining operations we can even look south of the border and see how the federal mines safety and health act in the latter part of the 70s it was created to enforce compliance with mandatory safety and health standards and it was meant to be a means to eliminate fatal accidents reduce the frequency and severity of non-fatal accidents to minimize health
hazards and really to promote improved safety and health conditions in regulated minds if if we look at canada we have the towards sustainable mining initiative that was launched in 2004 and this this initiative is a world recognized sustainable standard that is helping to build capacity within the global mining industry and participation in tsm is mandatory for members of the mining association of canada and it was established in an effort to
drive performance improvement in environmental and social issues and at present it is only mandatory within canada but many companies are voluntarily implementing these standards in their overseas operations and i don't need to say it again but i should just do this as a reminder there is a definitive link to attracting retaining employees to accessing capital to attracting investors and ensuring sound sustainability practices that i spoke of earlier in this presentation so mary
maybe you can lead us into some of the environmental impacts right and if we look at the next page in fact two pages i think you all are aware that and we certainly are not trying to to tell you something that you already don't know but there are different environmental impacts depending on the mining approach that's being taken so if you have open pit mining
a lot of the environmental impacts have to do with exposure of rock that releases radioactive elements and things that happen during the separation of the wars and also deforestation is a is a common issue if you're looking at underground mining there are a whole bunch of issues around the tailings mercury and other compounds can be used and it's facilitating ores and very often what happens is these get
released into the atmosphere and nearby water there are problems with sedimentation in rivers that may be near these mines through the use of hydraulic pumps and suction dredges and of course deforestation happens in these cases as well if we go to the next page in situ leech mines we'll have a sort of different kind of situation because the acids that are used to dissolve the ore bodies can dissolve
minerals and metals in the host rock and these fluids can create concentrations of metals and radioactive isotopes in water sources and then there's mining waste water that can result in the acidification of surrounding environments heap leaching can deal with can result in a number of other issues some is the release of toxic solutions into the surrounding ecosystem and leech ponds that directly affect wildlife and could cause mortality and then brine mining
extraction evaporation of brine solutions to remove elements and compounds can contaminate nearby bodies of water if the brine areas are not sufficiently protected so there are all sorts of things that can happen and so what we're seeing is these issues around throughout across the mining sector is you know basically high carbon output the mining industry is dependent on the use of fossil fuels primarily and these generate the energy for the
operations there are certainly as ed has mentioned some countries that are imposing regulations on admissions emissions including ourselves but a lot of companies in which mining companies operate don't have such regulations their issues around erosion and species endanger and i've talked a little bit about these in the past couple of slides it's invasive there's no doubt that this mining is invasive it can cause damage to landscapes
and this these damages could exceed the limits of the mine itself and so impacts do landscapes persist for many years and can result in the death of plants and animals and then there's high water use and wastewater almost all modern mining techniques use a large amount of water for extraction processing and waste disposal and a lot of situations involve wastewater from these processes not necessarily being dealt with in his is best way possible
so these are the kinds of things that were we're seeing associated with mining specifically related to the environment so what are companies doing about these kinds of situations well there are at least five things that we're seeing as mitigating strategies one is just reducing the use of water and this can happen through recycling of wastewater and reducing water demands for operations because we're using recycled water or because we found ways to
actually minimize the use of water in the process there are examples of using alternative energy sources particularly in places where solar or wind power are available and there are many mines that have made use of investments in wind and solar generation installing generators and batteries so that they can reduce greenhouse gas emissions proper waste disposal this is an issue that's been around for eons frankly but i think
that right now we're seeing increased investment in equipment that will turn waste into reusable materials and in finding circular economy models to enable the the disposal of these materials in a economically viable way and recycling is is another opportunity for mines certainly closing shutdown lines is critical so decommissioning the mines making sure that the egress and entry into the mine is controlled that the land has been has been dealt with in a way that
other things can be done with the mine and that all waste has been dealt with in a safe and responsible way and then finally replenishing the environment actually proactively reintroducing ecosystems plants animals etc to make sure that the land can be used in perpetuity in a in a in a productive way so we're seeing a lot of these kinds of activities and the more people hear about these and talk about them
the better obviously and the good news is that technology investment is technical investment technology is is going right along with this so and i think we'll talk a little bit you can talk a little bit about the social side of the mining sector thanks mary actually there are there are many topics to address within the social pillar of esg these are just a handful that we're gonna discuss
with you today if we look at involuntary resettlement large mining companies have been known to economically and and physically displaced communities as a result of mining projects this brings with the emotional and financial distress for communities and their residents communities where you operate are a key stakeholder when considering esg strategies and and this is why your sustainability strategy must specifically identify who are your internal and external stakeholders
if we look at indigenous land use indigenous communities have strong connections with the natural environment and the land base mining companies seeking to operate on traditional lands face really complex issues and often lack the knowledge required to address traditional rights and we also know that mining companies have been found even in consultation not to disclose indigenous opposition to projects and pushing forward regardless with projects even though they know that there is the
indigenous opposition to what's being carried out which really does highlight the need for a more robust strategy to address appropriately address i would even say indigenous communities and their interests and and health concerns minds are known to release harmful contaminants into the air and surrounding water sources and that these contaminants can be harmful to the health of communities living near these mines including having direct impact on employees at the
mine sites so the good thing is that companies are inventorying these concerns and impacts already today which shows a mature sustainability practice for the s pillar of esg let's think about some mitigation strategies of what we just discussed in working with indigenous communities this is actually about working with rights holders and to be clear they're even more than stakeholders this means going beyond just the traditional duty to consult it
includes inclusivity and collaboration as a as even aligned with the united nations declaration on the rights of indigenous peoples are commonly referred to as andhra i did a presentation presentation earlier this year and conducted some research on companies and and whether they had formal indigenous people's policies and i was actually surprised to learn disappointed really how few actually had taken this as an important initiative and created the
necessary policies you need a formally documented and well understood framework for your company to apply and engaging with indigenous communities at the end of last year bill c-15 was introduced with the intent to create a road map for government and indigenous peoples to work together this enactment provides that the government of canada must take all measures necessary to ensure that the laws of canada are consistent with undrip
and must prepare and implement an action plan to achieve the objectives of the declaration and this must be considered by companies looking to do business in addressing their esg strategies while ensuring indigenous stakeholders interests are are deeply embedded in the s pillar of esg and a final thought on the indigenous is companies need to also understand that one size doesn't fit all what may be successful with one
indigenous nation may not actually be successful with another and last here mary around the health and safety side there are already strict regulations on minor health and safety and it is necessary to ensure this continues to be monitored and disclosed and considering the health and safety of communities mining operations should continue making proactive efforts to reduce the risk of contaminants being released into the surrounding environment when you talk
about the environmental pillar so imperative for companies here to inventory and understand the significance of their impact on the environment including being clear as to those stakeholders who should be consulted such as employees communities indigenous peoples as well as considering biodiversity so mary enough on the social for right now can you take us through even some of those governance considerations right and to some extent the all of the
issues that we've talked about so far relate to governance in in some way shape or form all of the environmental and social issues and mitigating strategies that we've talked to have to be somehow tracked through a governance process and governance system and but let's talk specifically about four governance considerations that really are terribly important one of them is the mismanagement of third-party relationships and it's quite clear that many mining
companies have experienced some challenges with human rights issues associated with indirect labor and we saw a situation a couple of years ago with modern slavery basically in northern africa there were some issues discussed in in the globe and mail today in tigre mining taking place there and so how do you actually overseas control the work of contractors who are in fact you're hiring the people who work into
in the minds that that you're operating and one of the problems is is that it's very hard to build in oversight and to take actions in a way that will actually protect human rights of these indirect laborers and the treatment of citizens and vulnerable communities this takes dollars and people to do this and so historically this has been something where investment on the part of the mining companies has not necessarily
been focused the other issue that's very much related to this mismanagement of third-party relationships is some of the ethical challenges and these things kind of overlap and become a little murky but the notion of conflict minerals and these are often specified because they involve some level of human rights violations and we've seen this with the diamond industry and gold and other other minerals and i think one of the things that
happens here is that reporting very often has been at the corporate level rather than on an asset by asset basis and so governance bodies such as boards and senior executives don't necessarily have a line of sight into what is going on at the coal face to use expressions i guess is quite out given the industry that we're talking about lack of financial management and oversight this is a clear issue where
in a in a company where operations are taking place in countries that have weak legislation on the management of mining assets and the use of tax and royalty revenues and if that is you know the oversight doesn't exist then money can go awry and the money that is supposed to be being used to protect safety or to reclaim land or to invest in community development may go into other people's
hands and if you don't have the financial management oversight then you run the risk of these kinds of things happening and being basically guilty of corrupt practices and then finally reputational damage in general all of these things contribute to reputational damage and mining companies have been the subject of issues related to human rights corruption bribery environmental damage all the things that we've been talking about for the past
few minutes and in a more concrete way just beyond reputational damage liabilities and fines can be imposed that can be very very costly so in the context of this kind of situation what can a what can companies do what we see on the next page is a number of things implementation of policies processes and tools and so investment in clearly defining policies overseeing the governance structures locally and
creating tools that actually apply within the mining companies operation and across the entire supply chain so including the acquisition of labor and that's and and materials that are used in the mine and making sure that human rights controls are absolutely in place and being over overlooked and overseen sorry not overlooked asset level reporting i talked about this a few minutes ago so not just reporting at the corporate
level but actually investing time and energy into overseeing the operations on an asset by asset basis so the boards and senior executives can see what's going on on a local basis adherence to financial management and oversight so if there are international standards or deciding that even if you're operating in a country that doesn't have the strictest standards applying canadian or u.s or international standards to operations can promote financial transparency
make sure that you've got best practice governance and regarding the use of taxes and royalty revenues some companies have even set up independent foundations in vulnerable communities to help share the wealth and make sure that the money is going towards the uses that it was intended to go towards these things improve the livelihood of community members living in mining regions and this can go a long way to improving
the reputation of mining companies and then finally highlighting esg initiatives we found ed and i have found across a number of sectors a lot of companies are doing a lot of things and they don't talk about them and we're not quite sure why but if you are doing things that really are going to be helping either from an environmental social or governance standpoint then talk about those report on them
with data by the way so that you can prove that you've actually done these things and actually another thing that's very important is taking a look at esg and looking at it from the standpoint this can be a competitive advantage yes we might have to spend more money but over the long run we'll avoid fines we will be allowed to operate in communities it'll be much easier for us
to deal with communities and to win the rights to actually carry on business so those are some things that we are seeing and they're very very powerful i think we're going to turn our attention to standards and frameworks now and one of the things that we wanted to do is just talk a little bit about sasmi and sasby is a set of standards that can apply to the
mining industry and there is a materiality map that was that was used we used it for the purpose of this document in this this session because it does look at all three dimensions of esg as i mentioned and it actually provides examples of metrics not only for mining but across 70 plus industry types so it is a very very convenient and easy to use kind of user-friendly approach to looking at
at standards and so these metrics are things we're going to talk about really briefly on the following pages and if we look at environment some of the the general issues categories are gsg ghg emissions air quality energy management so for example total energy consumed percentage of grid electricity percentage of renewal water management there are numbers of incidents of non-compliance associated with water quality permits this gives you an idea of the kind of specificity
that for the environment for example sasby will lay out things that a mining company could do to measure or put in place to measure their performance along the environment and similarly if we looked at social capital and human rights and community relations some of the the metrics that are being discussed are percentage approved and provable reserves in our near areas of conflict percentage of provide of provided and probable
reserves in or near indigenous lands and so to the degree that these are reported on and discussed you can actually enhance social capital human capital percentage of active workforce covered under collective bargaining agreements for example and for leadership and governance business ethics a description of the management system for prevention corruption bribery throughout the value chain so sasmi is providing guide posts for companies like yourselves to begin to
tackle this very complex domain of esg if i could just step in here and talk about some additional standards mary if we look at those which are applicable to this industry there is continued effort to reduce risks associated with mining and the consumers of outputs and on a global to help fight the use of forced labor in the financing of armed conflict regulations put onus on sourcing standards
help break the link between conflict and the illegal exploitation of minerals and helps to put an end to the exploitation and abuse of local communities including mine workers and it's great to see that it supports local development as well if we just look at the responsible gold mining principles those principles cover each of the es and g pillars of sustainability linking ethical conduct to understanding impacts within your own business and
that of your supply chain to identifying and protecting the health and safety of your of your workforce and surrounding communities including all those that that you interact with to environmental stewardship and understanding impacts to biodiversity and natural resource consumption in both existing operations and you even brought up mary 2 the whole idea of closed sites those locations that are closed through your sustainable and responsible approach to site remediation and
reclamation and even if we take a look at the international council on mining and minerals ethical business activities are even built into decision-making processes and and actually should be how human rights are respected health and safety performance is insured operations continue with a lens on continual improvement so what is your approach to continual improvement including the treatment and protection of biodiversity again that keeps coming up each of these
additional standards provides guidance to help you on your esg journey creating solutions now to address esg topics that ensure long-term sustainable operations and outcomes just looking at and doing a general review of your environment take a brief look at the mining industry doing that could be a great exercise to benchmark your activities and assess where the industry is leading through commitments to sustainability and ensuring meaningful consultation
with key stakeholders both internal and external sustainability is not just for large mining companies it applies to everyone in the industry and it applies globally and and lastly how are you addressing waste do you have commitments where can you take meaningful steps to create real change these are just some things for our participants to keep in mind mary what else should they be thinking about well i think one of the things that we
believe in strongly is that the whole process of dealing with and addressing esg is a journey and it starts with a really understanding the nature of your business the footprint of your business if you will so where is business operating what are the primary sustainability concerns and how do your products and services affect sustainability and talking to stakeholders identifying the stakeholders first of all who are the stakeholders that are going to matter
the most and these can be internal and externals clearly communities in which you operate and having conversations with those people understanding your footprint allows you to identify the most critical esg topics that you need to address and what we encourage our clients to do is not try to address 15 of them typically there are four or five that are really going to make a difference to your business and to your stakeholders
and to assess the materiality how big are these is how big is the the impact potential of these topics to your business then understand what you're already doing about where do you stand to what degree are you already putting in for example safety statistics you may be well down the road of doing things around safety and health but maybe perhaps not so much around taking care of waste for example so you
have a sense of where to focus your attent time and attention and and money start to gather data and build management and governance systems so that you can actually begin to track progress and report on on the progress to the stakeholders that matter the most and then set up the capabilities that you can actually report effectively and to the extent that you need to obtain third party verification of what
you're reporting on so these are the very concrete things that we recommend that companies undertake so this was what we were hoping to do today is give you a sense of what's going on in the in the extraction extraction sector and the intersections with esg and so what's next what we would advise is evaluating where your company sits in sustainability adoption and to the degree that you do need it to get some
help because this is a we we've passed the tipping point on esg and across almost every sector and change is coming for sure and do you want to just talk a little bit about some of the things that that we might be able to do to help we know that this is a big undertaking for many organizations and it really does depend on where you're at in your
sustainability journey we help our clients everywhere from can you do a maturity assessment of what we have in place today through to can you identify stakeholders and help us with our consultation with the stakeholders or how do we take the large breadth of esg topics and understand which are most material to us that we should focus on that would then say how do we apply it through which global sustainable
framework that we want to embrace right down to help us create a report so we can communicate with those stakeholders that last culmination at the bottom right of your screen if and when you are required to have some type of third party verification like what mary said in terms of validating and verifying what you're reporting we can also help in that regard as well so there's many different
places we can be involved if you have questions we are definitely here our contact information will be shared and mary i have to tell you it's always exciting to address something like this with the group who are involved today and it's also great presenting with you too thank you for the opportunity it's been really nice to join with you today hello welcome to the second presentation this is going to be a deep dive into
the cannabis industry and i'm here my name is mary larson i'm here with my colleague edward olson ed thanks mary hi everyone my name is edward olson i am the leader of the sustainability practice here at mmp i'm also a regional leader of enterprise risk services and that covers all good topics around governance risk and compliance in my region i've been a chartered accountant by trade over the last 20 24 years
and i've been dealing with a lot of different elements of sustainability everything from auditing sustainability audits environmental management systems carbon credits and during this time as well i've been responsible for the strategy and operations really to running an alternative energy company i also sit as a member of cpa canada's sustainability reporting advisory committee and i'm a member of the global esg advisory committee with the institute of internal auditors so with
all of that being said i'm really happy i'm here to discuss esg with you today and i'll just introduce myself briefly i am a partner in the consulting practice of of mnp and i'm the national leader of our organizational renewal practice which includes strategy and scenario planning and organization design and most importantly the strategy esg strategy practice and ed and i work together very closely to provide full
services in the esg domain i've been involved in sustainability for about 20 years i was a co-founder of finance and sustainability initiative in montreal which was helping finance executives become more savvy and and an expert in in the whole area of esg and one of the things that we feel very strongly about and we'll talk about today is that there is a basically maturity curve that people are
going up and launching themselves into with respect to esg we're going to talk about cannabis specifically today thanks mary now that everybody has a good idea of who they're looking at on screen here's some of the objectives we want to cover with you today some of the many esg topics and and trends that are impacting the cannabis industry including how to respond to these topics and and simply mitigate any
potential exposures in your approach and your response to these topics with your stakeholders we we also want to take a look at some specific measures that you can consider in your own approach to esg reporting so mary maybe you can kick things off with a reminder of what esg is all about in case our viewers haven't seen our original presentation right so the environmental is that the area i think
that people are right now paying most attention to and these cover a whole range of indus of areas including energy efficiency the carbon footprint water usage which by the way is something that's very relevant to cannabis waste management packaging which would also be something that would be relevant to to many of you but the social governance issues are equally important and these include things like employee attraction retention the employee brand
diversity and inclusion which is something that is at the top of the list of business interests these days organizational culture is smack dab in the middle of social issues and then there are governance issues and these are things that senior executives and boards and employees need to be thinking about with respect to regulatory compliance on climate change for example cyber security responsible taxes and certainly reliable financial
disclosure so all of these things are relevant to esg and the cannabis and industry want to talk a little bit about just kind of how we got to here today yeah and it's interesting to watch because we don't have to go further back to 1970 where the whole idea of the reason a company exists is just purely for the benefit of the shareholder and in the early 70s
this whole idea of corporate social responsibility came out with the idea of social contract that no it's more than shareholders there's this idea of being a good corporate citizen so if we jump to the triple bottom line in the mid-90s that's where this evolution came from what is social contract well that social contract now includes bottom line people planet what was revolutionary is that it was the idea that those those three parts
are equal so the equality of bottom line people and planet and a new movement began to dominate this whole corporate landscape in 2005 and that's what we're here to talk to you about this is where esg expanded the three categories to enable businesses to really measure the real sustainable and societal impact of their outputs the difference now though is that esg well it's measured it's quantifiable and criteria-led and it allows businesses to
to better integrate the idea of esg strategies into their actual corporate environment their operating dna and mary's going to talk a little bit more about the united nations sustainable development goals later on in this presentation but what i'll mention is that these 17 goals are global goals that represent a universal call to action to end things like poverty and protect the planet and ensure that all people enjoy
peace and prosperity and they've even set a timeline for the unsdgs around setting it for 2030. mary there's a lot of drivers and this this is what what's interesting is we've reached a tipping point and and in fact on the other side of that tipping point i know that when when we started talking about responsible investment 20 years ago or impact investment it was you know the
the amount of money going into impact investment was in that you know point zero zero two percent or thereabouts but something has happened and there's been a confluence of factors that are driving esg and to some extent it covet is was was a contributor to this and certainly the discussion we've been having around climate change was a huge contributor if you think about all of the forces
government is is there and employees to some extent i think are are looking to work in safe environments and caring about whether their management teams are doing the right things regulators and investors however are are hugely important at this point the regulators are embedding sustainability measures into their regulatory decisions and approvals for new projects and investors have really gotten on board whether this is institutional investors or smaller investors
the the degree to which investment decisions are being made after scrutiny of sustainability strategies is is growing by leaps and bounds and to some extent customers certainly in the b2b arena customers are becoming more attentive securities commissions and and exchanges are beginning to take note as well we did some research recently in which we found i looked at 108 exchanges around the world about half of those
64 actually more than half have sme listing programs and of that 64 was really interesting one third of them require esg reporting as a listing rule and more than half of them have written guidance on what needs to go into esg reporting so these things are are moving again very very quickly do you want to talk a little bit more about the cannabis industry yeah and a really great thing to do for even some
of you who probably are aware of this is to get a bit of a history on how we got to where we're at in the cannabis industry in canada and i'll i'll begin by we don't need to go back further in 1923 but cannabis has officially been banning canada since 1923 and that's until medical cannabis in fact cannabis became illegal at a time when actually few canadians had even heard of
the substance police actually did not report seizing cannabis until 1932 and the first possession of fences did not occur until 1937. so in the years leading to legalization surveys actually showed that between 40 and 70 percent of canadians wanted recreational cannabis use made legal in in 2000 the ontario court of appeal they decided that cannabis prohibition was unconstitutional because it didn't make the exemption for medical use so health canada responded to that
ruling the following year when it regulated access to cannabis for licensed patients who were committed to grow their own cannabis and actually access it from licensed producers so in 2013 new federal regulations allowed for the production and distribution of medical cannabis creating a licensed commercial industry here in canada and in 2015 the supreme court of canada decided that it was unconstitutional to restrict medical patients to smoking just dried
canada so this ruling made it legal for licensed producers to make cannabis oils and other products made from cannabis extracts it also made it legal to add cannabis to foods and drinks so in 2016 the federal government created the task force on marijuana regulation and legalization which led to what you now know as bill c-45 the cannabis act in 2017 2018 introduced in 2017 and was legalized in
2018 after parliament passed the bill so that's the quick how did we get to where we're at here today mary there's a couple overarching trends we should keep in mind as we go throughout this can you address those so now that the market is legal there are other challenges that that you know better than we do but so the whole issue of management of supply the competitive branding making
sure that it's clear who you're selling to and certainly management of cost in the face of downward pricing pressure things that all of you i are dealing with in one way shape or form but with respect to esg there are really three things that we we want to talk about one of them is that there still is a stigma surrounding the industry and you know there this is probably going to be
with us for for quite a while there's a stigma around alcoholic beverages as well so this is something that that you know many industries need to deal with both with the public and with policy makers there is also a big desire to displace the illegal market federal government cares about this because of the legal market is a source of of tax income but certainly illegal illicit
markets are not seen as having control over environmentally or oriented issues and so that's a factor actually in favor of of those of you who are in the in the legal market but the bottom line is that and we feel quite strongly about this is that implementing esg practices will be a fabulous way to think about attracting non-traditional capital and will help satisfy consumer and employee expectations and those
things will go a long way to reducing the stigma that exists around the industry still so we're going to go more deeply into the environmental issues first and then the social governance ed thanks mary what i would say even before i start jumping into some of these topics is what's important to keep in mind is that each of these that we're going to discuss today they can be both risks as well as
opportunities for example energy consumption and product packaging yes they're material environmental risk but they also offer opportunities to reduce costs or increase revenues through the treatment or the use of that energy and the packaging so it's important to keep in mind the exposures as well as the opportunities to reduce impacts reduce costs even find innovative ways to produce which could result in opportunities to pivot and grow market share too so let's
look at a few of these topics that you'll see even outlined in your screen right now and i'll put my focus first on outdoor growing because figures provided by health canada just in april this year showed there's at least 110 outdoor marijuana cultivation licensees across the country that that's up from 42 a year ago so soil dependent upon your agricultural practices those practices could be destructive through soil erosion nutrient loss reduction in
organic carbon stored within the soil and and even increased acidity to mention just a few soil related considerations we know that cannabis plants are susceptible to pests and disease outdoors so you need to consider that the use of pesticides or even synthetic fertilizers can further destroy soil health well what about water contamination well outdoor farming practices can and do rely on water supply from from artificial irrigation and because of
this there is a naturally a runoff that can bring negative impacts and what are those negative impacts while we we're dealing with the wastewater can carry pesticides heavy metals excess nutrients and even pollutants so you want to be very cognizant around what what are we using for irrigation what are the potential runoffs how do we protect ourselves from polluting beyond our boundary of our organization if we look at indoor
farming practices they can put pressure on municipal water systems from the discharge of excess nutrients and industrial cleaners it's increasing stresses on wastewater treatment facilities in your community and also leading to increased carbon emissions as the water is treated so the actual emissions from the treatment of the water that came from your operation so understanding both water consumption as well as where your waste water goes is really important to evaluate your
company's environmental footprint and by mapping your footprint this exercise provides a really good idea what your impacts are in the life cycle of that water resource among many other natural resource considerations so okay let's look at indoor growing now we can't get away from discussing energy use of what mary referred to earlier so depending on the production methods you employ cannabis can be an energy intensive crop
and is and this intensity requires access to reliable sources of energy and those sources of energy come from many different generation types that have different what we call scope two greenhouse gas implications through indirect emissions being included in your carbon footprint footprint which need to be considered so applicable to both indoor and outdoor growing is even the idea of reduced air quality volatile organic compounds are the vocs
they're emitted from cannabis plants as they grow as well as during extraction through the use of solvents in the process so vocs they contribute to the formation of ground level ozone which also has a direct threat to public health in the environment so how you track control and and mitigate vocs is is really quite critical in your sustainability strategy and and last for this slide we should consider waste production the
primary source of waste generated by the cannabis industry is a result of single-use consumer packaging and product on products and we have to be aware that regulatory requirements are imposed on packaging types that makes it difficult to reduce waste because you're mandated i understand that but these difficulties cannot tie our hands it means we need to be innovative in our approach to reducing waste while still remaining compliant
with all laws and regulations so and what do we do well i spoke about some of the key risks and topics that we face but now look at some of the opportunities to mitigate these in your esg journey going back to soil degradation the adoption of regenerative agricultural practices and even land use planning needs to identify the short the medium and even the long-term impacts of planting decisions that can reduce the
risk of soil degradation soil testing can also inform decisions on how to optimize soil health so what is your approach to measure and mitigate impacts to soil if outdoor growing is applicable to you you're going to need a strategy if we look at preventing water contamination and reduced water use cannabis producers can focus on using the minimum required amount of water for cultivation and other uses this includes methods for automated
irrigation it includes capturing excess water for reuse that can reduce waste and with all agricultural practices one standard approach to water use and applications of fertilizers and pesticides is not necessarily the best practice understanding that use and application can change by geolocation on your land should be considered to meet that location's exact needs to grow your crop so continuous water treatment and quality testing really does reduce the
likelihood of discharging contaminated water into the environment how about reducing waste well cannabis manufacturers and retailers should be sharing best practices and looking at innovative ways together to work on reducing packaging waste this can include the ultimate consumer too through offering to them take back packaging programs as a potential option the question you need to answer is well ask an answer do you know what waste you create and
where it goes and knowing the answers to that there are options for the treatment of even biomass by turning it back into fertilizer for reintroducing into the growing cycle that can be considered for you a couple more thoughts on this slide for indoor growers and producers yes you want to be considering led lighting and hvac systems this should also consider optimizing space and scheduling the use of high
energy equipment around peak demand and understanding peak demand can help you reduce energy usage and energy costs to take advantage of lower energy rates what about alternative energy sources well have you factored in the idea of what alternative energy through wind and solar and biomass and other options versus traditional energy sources are you considering that how is it being implemented into your energy consumption last around the air quality
there are several technological innovations that can be leveraged to reduce emissions it's cold traps it's condensers there's a lot of different technology but the use of those systems and i just need to pause for a moment here they need to be balanced with the energy required for their use controlling air quality while driving up the energy use of energy it's actually mitigating one risk of air
quality while introducing another of of consuming more energy so this is about creating a comprehensive solution through looking at the interrelationship of environmental risks and choosing a course that achieves the best consolidated outcome so mary that's a lot about environment maybe you can take us through some of the social considerations in the s pillar of esg right thank you i should just mention we have a detailed presentation with the
the content that were we're delivering which we will be sending out as well so the detail that edges went through is will be included in the written document that we the document could be sent to anybody who's attended this so let's talk about social impacts and i this is a really interesting set of topics because the cannabis industry is unique within society and and has
some complex issues to deal with the criminalization history of of cannabis is one that is complex and so it's quite clear that many racialized communities minority communities have been disproportionately criminalized by by cannabis in the past and there is a concern over how these these groups will react to legalization and how the rest of society will react and so one of the things that has happened is that there has been
an increase in cannabis related offenses since the cannabis act has taken place and so this is a complex sort of social issue that i think a lot of people are spending a lot of time trying to to dig into and unravel the other thing that is problematic with respect to criminalization is that in some cases it is difficult to hire people in to senior levels who
have had criminal records in the past because there is a requirement for a security clearance and a criminal record check is is part of this so there are a whole bunch of complex societal issues around criminalization we talked about the societal stigma i think that this is the notion that that society has that we're on stereotypes that cannabis users are lazy or dangerous or somehow less
intelligent and and so this is is going to affect potential buyers in the industry safety concerns with usage are are definitely out there i think that people are looking for demonstrated proof from the health care sector from for researchers but some of the the things that have been talked about are how cannabis usage can impair a user's ability to drive safely or to operate equipment that the thc in cannabis actually
impairs coordination reaction time decision-making abilities and the ability to judge distances and that some of these concerns are higher related to to younger people and that there may be some longer-term health effects associated with use such as inability to concentrate your ability to to think and even lung issues and then shifting user demographics one of the things that as as user patterns shift to different age levels
or different income levels and geographies the reasons for use are fluctuating so a greater perhaps focus on medical applications health applications which could benefit the sector but there is a risk in accidentally targeting and attracting groups who shouldn't be using cannabis such as those under the age of 18. so in this sort of morass of complex social issues what are some of the things that that can't be done and
that are being done so there are ways to mitigate the effects of criminalization in some jurisdictions equity models have been deployed so that the industry is accessible to individuals who have been victimized by the war on drugs and so if they've been charged with a conviction or lived in the area with a disproportionately high rate of of cannabis arrests there are programs to ensure that these individuals are are
helped and that perhaps that there are opportunities for them to work ensuring that leadership teams within cannabis companies are diverse and representative of minority groups it can be a much more effective way to ensure that companies are seen as being responsive to societal issues just in terms of how to over the near term to reduce societal stigmas the effort that is underway to produce evidence that shows the benefits of using
cannabis will go a long way to reducing stigma there are other things that are being done to position cannabis as a societally ex socially acceptable product through advertising and making sure that store locations are in areas of a city that are on busy streets next to attractive other attractive retailers and engaging with the communities that you're producing the product in is another way to build positive social relationships
we've talked a little bit already about the idea of mitigating safety concerns with related to usage i think that drawing on research and talking about the the things that the positive effects of using cannabis and showing how safe safe deployment of cannabis can mitigate some of the risks that are being talked about is an important thing to do and i think probably perhaps most importantly it's ensuring that the
quality of the products that are being sold are as rigorous as possible so that if you can demonstrate that you're using very very high quality standards and checking standards to ensure product safety that will go a long way to mitigating concerns about about the safety of usage corporate health and safety programs for employees and for other users can also be a an attractive thing to do another important activity that that cannabis
producers can pursue is to make sure that their marketing campaigns their product development all of the the packaging anything that relates to communicating to the consumer needs to be carefully thought through and seen as being highly responsible particularly with with respect to not targeting youth and investing in research to identify consumer trends for example aging populations aging booming at the aging boom baby boomer population and how they might think about using
cannabis in a responsible way would be things that would be certainly attractive in trying to enhance the reputation of the industry so complex not necessarily clear and measurable things that could be done but certainly there are some that would be clear and measurable around safety packaging and communication so let's talk about governance ed thanks mary it seems like we're peeling this onion back we've covered the e and the s so
let's get into the g given the relatively new nature of the legal industry for for cannabis here in canada canada cannabis companies are or are perceived as less mature and often lack good corporate governance and that creates a lack of tolerance by investors for missing good governance cannabis companies are often led by founders with limited experience navigating growth and propelling startups into larger companies including seeking investors and being publicly listed
the topic of diversity equity and inclusion yes it is a social topic that ends up in the s pillar of esg and yet it's also a governance issue and that cannabis companies need to strategize on their current workforce strategy what is the make up the board down through the entire organization is there representation of the communities you work in as well as the customers you serve you need to consider your strategy to
take your company from a startup of like-minded leaders to a diverse environment of leaders that is inclusive of all types and good corporate governance is also good compliance the combination of high growth and high regulation associated with the industry creates a need for everybody its manufacturers distributors retailers to deal with a high volume of laws and regulations and not just to know the existence of those those laws
and regulations but also be aware when they change and the implication of those changes on your operating environment are you responding in time non-compliance can shut a business down so how good is your governance for overseeing compliance and ensuring compliance practices are and actually remain robust governance extends beyond compliance to looking at other risks such as theft and product tampering and resale on the black market companies that are seeking to be
publicly listed need to keep in mind the requirements of regulators for ensuring sufficient internal controls over financial reporting will your ceo and cfo be able to certify on the control environment for financial disclosures ensuring that those controls are designed and appropriately well are they operating effectively and and last for this slide let's remember it takes capital to operate a business and grow attracting investors is challenging within the cannabis industry due to a
large volume of new entrants into the market and i would even say investor uncertainty given the risk of investing in less mature companies but you need the skills to communicate clearly with investors and to create required disclosures and then the skilled team to back up and ensure that all is working as designed and communicated to investors and other stakeholders so what about mitigations in this arena well boards need to identify the skills and
experience they and the management team require and that's to enable success and growth both at the current and i would say the current state and future trajectory company founders may need to be replaced by leaders with more experience what is good as an entrepreneur is not always aligned with growing and maturing a company and don't forget the need of necessary skills of accounting and information technology and human
resources to manage those operational risks as a company i already spoke about diversity equity and inclusion look internally do you have any formal guidelines or policies addressing how boards should be comprised to include various ages races genders or other forms of diversity and if you don't have a formal approach you need to look at creating one the board should contain experience in risk management and compliance to ensure
the right questions of management are even asked and that the right evidence is received to back up management statements and opinions and dependent upon your size for larger organizations that's when you even start considering internal audit departments you should invest in compliance is there an employee employee group that is focused solely on compliance testing of compliance and reporting to the board as well as management and last but not least here
boards should implement disclosure practices and guidelines and i say that to ensure investors are provided with relevant timely and accurate information boards can only do this if management has the right processes in place so all of that being said i'm going to take you quickly if you were in attendance at our original presentation we talked about the six main global esg standards and frameworks we just want to focus on sasby the
sustainability accounting standards board because they have a materiality map and sasby is now part of the new merch value reporting foundation so if you hear those terms that's where sasby sits by selecting the industry in the materiality map called agricultural products we can review and assess those topics that may have direct correlation to the cannabis industry and some of those are displayed here on screen for you and i'll go through a couple more of
these over the next two slides you can see here we've already talked about greenhouse gas emissions energy management including water and and wastewater treatment earlier in this presentation the approach to understanding these impacts and how they are measured will help with ultimate sustainability practices and eventual disclosure if we look at part of the social government's governance pillars of esg that includes cyber security and data security as well
do you have policies and procedures defining your approach to protecting your technology infrastructure as well as the information contained within it or your your treatment of confidential information from customers and your employee personal information if you don't you need to and last but not least what is your approach to employee health and safety do you record incidents including near misses your approach to employee safety drives how you are viewed in the social pillar
of esg and this extends to the measures you implement to protect your customers beyond health and safety approaches and measurements is your supply chain what do you or who do you do business with what is your influence on the sustainability practices and have you evaluated the implications of their sustainable practices or lack thereof on your business model in understanding your carbon footprint you will eventually be required to
include what is called scope 3 emissions and that's indirect missions that come from your supply chain so it it's important to really understand who you're working with including your footprint to have a better more comprehensive overview of your business marry around additional standards right and and i think you all know that the campus act is is something that that you all need to comply with because it basically sets
the framework for legal access to cannabis to control and regulation of production distribution sale and all the regulatory requirements around production practices and sop standard operating procedures what's interesting is that many of the elements around sops actually relate to esg so that by adhering to the cannabis act you can go a long way down the road of of addressing esg topics such as the sanitation of the building's employee
hygiene it products the addition of fertilizers pest controls and harvesting sampling and quality testing packaging and labeling and storage so that is a good way to start with respect to the things you absolutely have to pay attention to they are esg related elements which is a helpful thing and there are some things already going on in the industry chiron has recently published an esg report which is showing lots of
serious commitment to sustainability rubicon recently released an esg report and now we're even seeing recommendations about which stocks to buy because they are ideal for esg investors so this is something that's definitely being taken on as a challenge by the the marketplace so now this is our chance to try and bring it all home because i i know we've given a lot to everybody attending today
to consider around esg topics for the industry we wanted to close of providing this slide as a brief overview of key considerations that you really should evaluate on your esg journey and your esg strategy creation i would say these are the building blocks to final external disclosures that will eventually become potentially mandated in canada if we take a view of your business to know where you operate
who is impacted by your business or what we call stakeholders what topics apply to your industry and we've been covering some of those today which are the most material to your business taking those most material and evaluating what is being done today by you and your organization to address those topics and if you aren't doing anything you should and ultimately the idea of building a robust management system to synthesize
and provide necessary data for reporting all of these things are required and should be a part of your esg journey so next steps we definitely appreciate your time today and and look at the information that we've asked and presented to you and ask yourself in your organization what are we doing are you identifying embracing and managing these esg topics if you haven't created a strategy i would say
don't wait the time to start is now and get third party help from organizations like mmp mary i know we'll chat just briefly here at the end around what are some of the things even organizations like us can do to help you on your journey right so yes and we there are other organizations that can can do these kinds of things but we've invested a great deal on building
our capabilities along several dimensions one is a baseline to maturity journey which is starting with an assessment of where you stand with respect to esg and identifying a desired state of maturity and laying out a strategic plan to achieve that level of maturity that you've chosen and training the board and management in in the area of esg we also do a lot of work with the stakeholders identifying the ones that you need to
really pay attention and understanding what what their concerns are through stakeholder consolidation and creating a stakeholder engagement framework that can be used over the long run so that you stay connected with these stakeholders we can also look at the impact of your current situation so materiality assessments linking esg topics to corporate value and risks and undertaking benchmarking to see where you stand with respect to disclosures and other players in the
marketplace we can help you select the frameworks that are most appropriate for you we used sasby today but it's not the only one that's out there and we we did cover that in our earlier presentation and then reporting reporting and making sure that there is a the way that you're reporting the information is useful and meets regulatory and legislative requirements and assurance finally doing the third party verification insurance of esg
reporting so pretty much along the gamut of issues that issuers such as yourselves might be might be facing so thank you so much we hope this is helpful and obviously if you have any questions concerns i think you've got our coordinates and we would be happy to to speak with you any point in time thank you thank you everyone thank you for joining us for today's presentation of esg in the capital
markets cannabis and mining as well i'd like to thank our valued partners mnp and their subject matter experts mary larson and edward olsen as well special thank you to richard carlton and mark faulkner for giving us their expertise on day one esg a macro overview if you like this content or you missed out on day one please visit us at www.thecsc.com as well as our youtube channel cse
underscore tv thank you and good night you



