About This Video
Updates to CSE's Listing Policies were made effective on April 3rd, 2023 and we had the pleasure of hosting a virtual session for professional service providers to answer any questions about these amendments.
Recorded on September 13, 2023, CSE’s Mark Faulkner, Senior VP of Listings & Regulation, and Rob Cook, Senior VP of Market Development provided updates on recent amendments to CSE's listing policies, followed by a Q&A period.
Specific policies addressed in this presentation include:
- The creation of a tier for non-venture issuers (NV issuers);
- Amended requirements for distributions;
- Revised and alternate listing requirements for mineral exploration companies; and,
- Changes to the CSE Form 2A Listing Statement.
Supporting Policy Notices here:
Notice 2023-005 - Amendments To CSE Listing Policies - Summary Of Comments And Notice Of Approval: https://thecse.com/en/about/publications/notices/notice-2023-005-amendments-to-cse-listing-policies-summary-of-comments
Notice 2023-007 - Amendments to CSE Form 2A Listing Statement - Notice of Approval: https://thecse.com/en/about/publications/notices/notice-2023-007-amendments-to-cse-form-2a-listing-statement-notice-of
Subscribe for more great CSE insights and interviews here: https://go.thecse.com/CSETV-Subscribe
STAY CONNECTED WITH THE CSE
=============================
- NEWSLETTER: https://go.thecse.com/CSE-Mailing-List-Subscribe
- PODCAST: https://blog.thecse.com/cse-podcasts/
- INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/canadianexchange/
- LINKEDIN: https://ca.linkedin.com/company/canadian-securities-exchange
- FACEBOOK: https://www.facebook.com/CanadianSecuritiesExchange/
- TWITTER: https://twitter.com/CSE_News
- BLOG: https://blog.thecse.com/
- WEBSITE: https://thecse.com/
- MAGAZINE: https://issuu.com/thecse/docs
Read the TranscriptAuto-generated by YouTube; names and terms may be misspelled.
without further Ado I'm going to introduce today's presenters Mark Faulkner and Rob cook to walk you through what's new with CSC policies and rules at the Canadian Securities Exchange
okay thank you James I'm Rob cook and you can I think everybody can see more right beside me Thanks James for the introduction James has a voice for radio and I have a face for radio and I will do some introductory slides and then I'll turn over the majority of the presentation tomorrow and if we can move the slides up here so the Canadian Securities Exchange you're all familiar with it our mission
is really not changed we wanted to reduce the cost of capital for emerging companies and make sure that they had you know access to Capital at a reasonable cost so while we were founded in 2003 we only started with three companies listed and we were recognized as a stock exchange by the Ontario Securities Commission in 2004 in May I believe it was since then we have grown tremendously
and we're now over 800 listings the market cap peaked at over 30 billion but it's currently hovering around 20 billion and many of our issuers are able to access Capital when we find that that they that they cannot raise Capital it's generally speaking because of overall market conditions so systemic problems not CSE problems and now here's the growth in our listings over our whole lifetime so you can
see we have over 800 security companies listed or approximately 800 companies listed in over 800 Securities listed most of the differences so it warrants okay we've been characterized as the Canadian or the Cannabis Stock Exchange on too many occasions Life Sciences is still a significant part of our stock list the slide here really only shows a difference of four months from the end of December 31 2022
through April 30th but the only real difference is that the only sector that was not growing is the life sciences sector all of the other sectors have been growing on on the CSC this year so we have a number of things to explain introduce talk to you both today there are many changes to our requirements some of the changes that are really just providing transparency
that we want to make sure that that our rules are clear and sometimes our rules were not embedded in our rulebook for instance something like normal course issuer bids but we now have a policy that's it's it's actually in the rule book so there's a number of areas that we're going to talk about we're also going to introduce you to our senior tier also known as our non-venture issuer
tier or abbreviated to envy issuers Mark is going to give you the detail on most of these changes so I'll turn it over to him thanks Rob we originally published these back in December several years I've lost track of the years that that we actually published these but they were published for comment they were out for a long time an extended period for comment and then it we knew there were still some
outstanding issues we were discussing with The Regulators when we published them so it it took until April of this year that we ironed out all those things and for those of you that followed closely you'll see that there were some amendments that were made subsequent to the publication and the reason we were able to do those without republishing is because we raised many of the issues in the
specific questions that we asked when we published for comment so this was one of those topics the public floating distribution we didn't propose any changes when we published the proposed amendments but subsequent to that we took the feedback from the the questions the in the request for comments and some outstanding concerns that we shared with the osc and bcsc staff and so we did introduce some
requirements when we introduced the policies in or implemented policies in in April this year so we did increase the public flow from 10 to 20 percent and the number of shares and but the number of public holders some of you may remember there wasn't pressure for it to for by The Regulators for us to increase the number of public Boulders and for a long time we've
actually been considering whether the 150 was an appropriate number or whether we could increase other requirements and actually reduce the number maybe down to a hundred there wasn't much of an appetite for reducing the number at the at the regulatory level but we also wanted to hold fast to the 150 and look at where the real problems were in distributions and it wasn't necessarily the number of public
holders but it was more how many shares were held by the public or how the public holders got those shares so we held fast at 150 and we did propose a higher number for the NV issuers the the irony in this is that just as we confirmed that we were ready to publish Neo published proposed changes to their policy of their requirement and they reduced it from 300 to 150 and the
stated rationale was that other exchanges have lower requirements so they should too so there hasn't been any subsequent pressure on us to increase our number because the the Neo change was approved we did agree that we would publish some guidance if we kept the the requirements as is with the 150 that we would also publish publish some guidance shortly after implementation which we did in April and that guidance is really
about the things that we will look at when we're looking to see that the floating distribution are adequate and and that we're satisfied that there there could be a public market for the Securities that's really what we're looking for price Discovery liquidity and a real market for the Securities so those things are all included the things we looked at below they were included in that guidance notice and
we look at those things with every listing it doesn't mean that it's always going to be a specific threshold but and and it will depend on several factors related to the company and the management and the objectives but those are sort of the basic things we look at below there we did introduce shareholder approval requirements people if that have worked with us for a long time will know that the the
only explicit requirement for shareholder approval in our policies was for a fundamental change and that wasn't even just a hundred percent issuance of the outstanding shares it was something that was actually going to be treated as a fundamental change by the by this the exchange under the policy so we did introduce these additional requirements similar to other exchanges the thresholds are slightly different so but this does we've always said
that disclosure is Paramount and that the shareholders should make the decisions not the exchange so all we've really done is identified a few more situations where the shareholders should get a voice and the issuance of greater than 50 percent or issuance of over with a control change of control or over 100 percent absolute a lot of people believed that that hundred percent threshold was there anyway because so
often with 100 it's also a fundamental change anyway but now it's explicit that it's just a hundred percent of the outstanding for the NV issuers and we'll talk more in detail but just as a a reminder the Envy issuers are basically companies that would meet the requirements for for Neo or the TSX rather than the Venture exchange and would not be Venture issuers if they
were to list there so that was the theory behind the the senior tier so that Threshold at 25 percent is the same in Tia as TSX and Neo because we wanted to treat those issuers the same way we did also introduce the concept of a transaction that could materially affect control now that can be subjective it does give a little bit of discretion to us but what we included in the
requirement is that it could be at the exchanges decision or the issuers analysis that it does material effect control and we added a a fairly lengthy definition of material what would materially affect control a new control position for certain but that doesn't mean that someone coming up to 19.9 nine percent doesn't affect control so we could require the shareholder vote for that as well it's been tested a couple of times
already and I it seems to be working as it was intended okay sorry so but disposition of assets again this is something that was not subject to approval before to sharehold approval and we did we looked for a threshold and then and I think we published one threshold but we ended up settling on just the standard that's already accepted in Securities Law ending
corporate law that it's all or substantially all that the issuers assets or business and that would be would require shareholder approval one of the things that we wanted to ensure though was that the in in getting that voter and seeking that from shareholders that they got disclosure not only of how it would affect the company but how it would affect the listing because if an issuer has disposed of all of its assets
or undertakings the issuer will be designated as an inactive issuer and there are certain restrictions on financing or Acquisitions after that so we will make sure that that's included in the disclosure when a company is looking for approval to dispose of its business this was one of the things that got generated a significant amount of comment on the on publication and we and we have had to remind
we've had several requests for exemptions to this requirement I'll get into a bit but the what we've had to remind people is that we introduced this requirement so that we wouldn't be introducing a review and approval process a company still does not need exchange approval to close financing but what we've done by introducing this public notice requirement they have to announce the intention to do a financing
and it's not intended to be a five-day waiting period so we don't expect that the company will have everything lined up Penn poised to sign and then announce it and sit on it for five days that that would still be compliant but that's not the intention we've seen very often companies seek confidential price protection and then not really treated as confidential and simply issue a news release the next day announcing the
financing well that's ideal public disclosure to do the financing is ideal it also establishes the price it locks in a bunch of things if a company doesn't want to disclose it in advance and and usually that's you know they don't want to send the wrong message we don't want an issue we're saying we're going to reach X number of dollars not be able to raise anywhere near that and then be concerned about
the negative messaging there then we can still do the confidential price protection and at some point when it becomes material then the issuer can put out the news release that say they intend to close the financing wrap the rest of it up and and close five days later it's working fairly well in most circumstances we are going to consider certain circumstances or conditions under which we would not require that
five-day notice currently most of the arguments that we've been getting in the request for exemptions are that it's not it's not necessary because it's not Material or it's not necessary because it won't provide any additional meaningful disclosure to the to investors and that's where we remind people that this is instead of our review and approval if the public notice is made we don't have any questions there's nothing to hold it
up and our our approval is not necessary we have granted one exemption to date and it wasn't an exemption to the notice requirement it was an exemption to the specific five days of notice so in this case the company still provided public notice of the intent to close the financing but they had to tighten it up to two or three days because there was there was a pending
seized trade order and they needed the financing to pay the Auditors if they had waited they wouldn't have been permitted to close the financing because of the cease trade order so that one that one made sense and that's the only exemption we've granted so far there are several new forms there were a couple changes to existing forms specifically the annual listing statement and I think we'll mention that
later but the one of the requirements we've had for 20 years has been a requirement for the issuer to file an annually updated listing statement it's an onerous task with and we acknowledge that the the it's got limited use to investors it's it's just not it's not practical it's expensive and it's not really helpful so we have reduced the size of That So based on the original quarterly
listening statement we've turned that into an annual listing statement and it's really more of a summary than a full listing statement and that'll replace the the requirement for an annual two-way in separate amendments we've also changed the 2A but we'll get to that after and then each of the the other forms there from 14 to 18 those are all new forms for new requirements and these are requirements
as Rob mentioned in the introduction that they may not have been clear they may not have been included like normal course issuer bids shareholder rights plans we did not have explicit policies on those things before so none of these are necessarily new ways to approach these items they're all very similar to existing requirements on other exchanges they're simply disclosure requirements or approval requirements that are the same as as others and they again these are
things that require our explicit approval they may require shareholder approval but primarily they just required a specific disclosure and that's what these storms are for so as I mentioned the annual filings we repealed the the requirement for the annual 2A but we still have a requirement for an annual filing in addition to the financial statements and it's much shorter the 5A annual listing statement listed companies May file instead of
filing one of our forms they may file an aif and there are definitely more benefits to a venture issue or filing an aif than simply filing one of the the CSE forms the senior tier the NV issuers will be required to file an aif
we introduced the Rob do you want to talk about restricted Securities well I could briefly restricted Securities are usually Securities where there's a bottle of voting privileges for one class and and inferior voting privileges or subordinate voting privileges for the majority of the shareholders we have always imposed requirements similar to other exchanges there's also you know a national rule on restricted Securities
we just had not Incorporated one into the body of of our our policy so essentially you know that the policy requires that that the the shares that are trading have an appropriate designation I.E they should not be called Comet shares and that there'd be told tail protection for those shareholders in the event of the Takeover bit and they're they're if if the capital structure is
changing there would be requirements for share voter approval some of these requirements do not apply to what's become known as proportionate voting share structures where the reason for the the share structure is is in order for the company to maintain foreign private issuer status for the SEC and those those those companies also could designate the Lesser voting shares as common shares provided they get an exemption from one of the
Securities regulators don't think there's more to say on that is no there's not a lot we had this as Rob said we we've been applying these principles for several years we actually had a placeholder in the policy that we we finally just changed that from a placeholder to an actual policy so policy six there were there were several changes this included the five-day notice and and some of the
other things so I'll talk a bit about the application of and and the practical way that that these things work with respect to price reservations Security based compensation arrangements so we were the policies were silent on a lot of the requirements other than just pricing for option so we've added a whole section in there now and We've added a little bit more detail on convertible Securities as well
so for a price reservation and and this is what I think people are most familiar with on the other exchanges it's it's there's price reservation or it's a price reservation form we've always referred to it as simply price protection a reminder we don't review and approve of financing but we will look at the onset the company requests the price confidentially we'll confirm that price this is the market price this is the
allowable discount and and that's your threshold so they can price it anywhere above that of course it's not a pre-approval of the financing or of the terms of the financing it's an acknowledgment that we've got enough information to confirm that that's a reserved price or protected price and now the company can work on the the financing if it's done confidentially that's fine we would prefer of course as I mentioned
earlier public disclosure right at the onset so if the if a news release goes out identifies the the intention to do a financing a form 9 gets posted with basically the terms that are already known we recognize that at that point all the detail isn't there and that's the way the form 9 is always work a preliminary form 9 as soon as there's public disclosure about the financing and then
a final form nine with all of the the fields all of the data supplied at the time of closing and 6.25a discusses that intention and the five-day period and that once we get to the if we're looking at it confidentially we will ask for a few things we'll confirm that price what we've found it's it's not explicit in the policies and we will introduce it
if it's necessary but we have been reminding people confidential price protection is intended to give some certainty or to provide some certainty against market movement market conditions General market conditions that are outside the company's control it's not appropriate in our view to request a confidential price protection so that only that the company is aware of this price and then launch a promotional campaign or a series of material announcements to that will
have a an impact on the market price so we've been reminding people that and this is to protect against market movement outside the company's control not market movement that's that may be affected or influenced by the company's actions so we do have the right to to go back and either amend the price or revoke the price protection or require immediate public disclosure to establish that price that's not nearly as much of a concern
of course if the intent to finance and the price was disclosed publicly and then the material news came out because the market can react to all of the news together we previously granted exemptions to prior to prices sorry to the minimum nickel restriction and we did that by granting the exemption on the condition that the issuer used the 20-day volume weighted average price as the minimum price
we've now Incorporated that into the policy so that's no longer an exemption but the price still has to come from us so when we get a request to do a financing below five cents we'll calculate the volume weighted average price provide it in the confirmation that this is the minimum price that can be used and then there are some certain restrictions on the how the proceeds are used or to whom the shares may be issued
and for what purpose those again were always the conditions that we imposed on that exemption and they've simply been codified into the policy
as I said earlier we we only the the policies on any kind of Securities based compensation were really restricted just to the pricing for options so we've added in an entire policy that that should cover all all plans and all the issuances different types of Securities Security based compensation it's very similar to the other exchanges the again the point with this was to have a more detailed policy and a point
of reference for the issuers and Council it wasn't intended to reinvent the approach to security space compensation if you look at this you'll find that it is very similar to at least one of the other exchanges and it wasn't intended to be any different so consider the application of that to be consistent to the extent that we can ensure that it's consistent with the other exchanges approach
we've had a lot of questions about convertible Securities not necessarily warrants options but more specifically convertible debentures the their policies have been changed with the nickel minimum and the combination there can't be a discount to the the market price and the whether it's the the exercise price and an issue price it can't be less than the market so no discount on convertibles but what we
found is is a lot of creative approaches to get discounts to get additional shares up front the time of signing an agreement or interest payments interest paid in advance or a lot of creative ways for a lender to get additional shares we've tried to be fairly consistent in our objections but the you know they can be more and more creative the principle Remains the Same that
they shouldn't be able to get any more coverage than they would at the the nickel minimum whether it's warrants or shares or it shouldn't that the terms shouldn't result in a discount that wouldn't otherwise they wouldn't have otherwise been entitled to so we are working on a guidance notice we did add into the policies that they could be priced at the time of issuance or the
price could be determined by a preset formula but could be determined at a later date based on the market price at the time and the application of that means that the market price at the time of issuance will always be the minimum price so if the market price at the time of issuance is 10 cents then the conversion price can be 10 cents or some price that's determined by market conditions later
if the shares are trading at 30 cents then it can be a v-wop it can be at the time of issuance it could be whatever as long as it's not below what it could have been at the time of issuance and as long as that calculation has been determined at the time of issuance and of course I mentioned there's a restriction on the coverage and the
five-year term is unchanged Rob's going to talk about the changes to Mineral exploration yes certainly so we meet a number of changes which have had some impact we've increased the thresholds for prior expenditures and for the expiration budget significantly in percentage-wise terms but we don't think necessarily that significantly in terms of the dollars and they we introduced some exceptions as well so I will get into that
expressly so for qualifying expenditures we've increased the requirement for that's the expenditures prior to listing from seventy five thousand dollars to a hundred and fifty thousand dollars we have kept the similar requirement that they they have title to a property perspective for minerals Etc however we are also now requiring that the qualifying ex prior expenditures have been spent by the company that is the applicant for
listening and so we did this for for two reasons firstly because we felt that the thresholds were outdated they they were 20 years old at least 20 years with with the CSE and didn't really reflect the actual costs of what we would consider to be significant expiration activity we also believe that by increasing these these thresholds we would reduce the probability that a company listed as
a mineral exploration company would become a a public shell within 12 months of listing we also increased the requirement for the dollars to be spent on the first phase of the budget as recommended in the 43-101 report we increased it from a hundred thousand dollars to two hundred and fifty thousand dollars for the same reasons that we increased the prior expenditure requirement if but we have also retained the
the prior requirements of 75 000 dollars and a hundred thousand dollars for the budget four companies that a fully intend to only pursue business as a mineral expiration company and B are willing to accept more stringent escort requirements firstly all Builder shares that have been issued by the company will be subject to Escrow regardless of the holder otherwise it's Builder shares you
know held by insiders that are subject escrow we're also deferring or delaying the first escrow releases until the the company's completed phase one of its program and they've provided acceptable disclosure the results of the program and we're also going to be restricting or not permitting transfers within escrow so and I guess I should explain the last one is is that if the company does
propose to change its business and it qualifies as a fundamental change in the opinion of the exchange then the shares remaining in escrow would be subject to cancellation all of this is meant to discourage the creation of shells so that's that's being in place since since April we've had several companies that have been listed using either the new requirements or or the old thresholds
with the con commitment and commitment to expiration and I think Mark can explain the rest of here yep I just want to add a couple of things to the yeah those restrictions and and Rob's reference there are two things we do still have some companies that are that are coming in that have been working on the projects or working on the listing and we're already working on those structuring the companies
getting the projects and and we can see from the history those are already well underway before April 3rd when these policies were implemented for those at our discretion we may treat them under the old policies with the 75 100 000 budget as if they had applied before April 3rd so in that case these extra restrictions aren't are applicable however for a new company a new application that would wants to meet
these lower thresholds all of these escrow requirements we realize these are these are very restrictive escrow requirements and I think if we were to put it into the simplest terms possible and and how we tend to look at it internally if this looks like it's going to be used as a CPC we're going to treat it as a CPC we don't have a program we're not
introducing a CPC program but these escort requirements are intended to tie everyone to the company until they pursue the objectives that they said they were going to pursue so one of the questions that we've got frequently is about the the final one that Rob mentioned about cancellation and and fundamental changes we have always looked at a significant acquisitions by companies that are in the mineral exploration space if all the disclosure is appropriate
and it really is just a major acquisition that happens to be over a hundred percent of the outstanding it may not need to be treated as a fundamental change it it is still in if it's still in Mineral acceleration so if you just get another project a bigger project then it may not be treated as a fundamental change and of course all of these things wouldn't be triggered or
that cancellation wouldn't be triggered but again that's the acquisition of a project not the acquisition of another not an RTO so there is there is some discretion there and again these policy requirements were introduced to stop very specific practice that we're trying to address not to prevent the acquisition of better and bigger projects so I also mentioned earlier when we talked about the 5A and the and the the
2A I mentioned that we had changed the listing statement as well the the listing statement has always been a very prescriptive form but it was intended to follow the the requirements of the 41 101 F1 information required in a prospectus we've changed it rather than try to keep up to date with all the requirements or ensure that all the language was exactly the same we have changed it now to
Simply say that the information required analystic statement is the information required in a prospectus it's not an offering it's not a prospectus but the information required in a prospectus is what's required in the listing statement so it's no longer a prescriptive form it's a couple pages with instructions and because it does change based on the circumstances of the issuer so we can foreign I found the typo I'm sorry everyone that
issuers July somebody did a search and replace it should say issuers may rely on a recent prospectus or information circular and so what we've done there for an issuer that's already an existing reporting issuer or a company that's switching from another exchange without a fundamental change without an RTO or without a change of business if the existing disclosure record is accurate and up to date it can
be used in the listing statement and it can be incorporated by reference which is a great a great savings and time effort and cost of preparing a listing statement we've started to get the first few in that are being prepared that way and I think everybody's finding it there's a little bit of experimentation there but I think we'll we'll find in the long run that it will be much easier for
companies to make the move from one exchange to us from another exchange to us so that wasn't done at the same time or it wasn't effective at the same time as all the other amendments but it was done very shortly after so it's in place now we got a lot of questions on the senior tier and I think a lot of concerns about whether this would be an option for the issuers
and our initial approach was that it was not going to be an option it was intended to impose additional requirements on companies that were large enough and the risk was greater and so we intended to treat them as issuers on the TSX or Neo or on a non-venture Exchange ultimately when we got to the end of this process staff at the commissions agreed that we would be moving forward with a change to
the definition of venture issuer in 51102 and so we now have a definition even though we we created this as more of a designation than a specific tier we've now added a definition of senior tier to include all of the envy issuers and the definition in 51102 will now say that a venture issuer is an issuer that does not have its Securities listed on and then whatever the list is TSX Neo
the CSE senior tier will be included in there with the with the with the others so the definition has been drafted it's being circulated internally with all the CSA members that will be published for comment of course but our envy issuers that meet those additional requirements and get designated by us will be treated in Securities Law as non-venture issuers so until that definition is amended we have
undertakings and forms of consent for the issuers to sign basically to to undertake to follow the policies or the rules as if they were not Venture issuers and comply with Securities Law that way and a consent to be regulated as non-venture issuers so with that with that that new that shift which occurred much more quickly than we thought it was going to to making these issuers non-venture
issuers we introduced an optionality for the issuers so we won't designate issuers without their consent it really will be a choice we'll identify them we will communicate to the issuers that based on all of these thresholds it meets the the company meets the qualification requirements to be an Envy issuer we'll outline some of the benefits and some of the additional requirements and then the issuer will
have the choice and we'll set an effective date so that it's that they have time to get in place any of the procedures they need the processes they need to meet the filing of the deadlines that kind of thing one of the original objectives of this project are creating the senior tier was to obtain margin eligibility for certain security so we had Securities that were in a dollar
range value per share where they would be marginal if the Securities were listed on another exchange and this has been something that we we've battled with IROC for our entire existence and we finally got to a point where we said if we propose something like this and have very specific requirements for these issuers would IROC confirm margin eligibility and we we got to the the stage where
they agreed that would be the case we proposed a tier and after the the policies were approved we went back to Iraq we had that I was Zero by then and then we had the the discussions about this and it became a little bit more clear that that there was finally some recognition that it was time to look at the lists for margin eligibility in more detail and as a result of
that review at xero we now have oh sorry I did Skip ahead too we now have margin eligibility for all Securities so any any Securities on an exchange in Canada except I believe for those listed on the that have been moved to the next Board of the Venture exchange and those that are designated as inactive by the CSC those were the dot X and they may be
but it's not likely they would be eligible by Price anyway all Securities are treated the same way if they're on an exchanging candidate so that was a great step forward for us and so now that's not really one of the the specific benefits that we thought would only extend to the NV issuers it applies to all so we are looking at that there are very few things for the excuse me I'll just go
back there are very few things where the Envy issuers have a specific advantage or something that isn't required of them that would be required of other issuers they don't have to file a monthly progress report but they do have to file an AIS we're going to add things as we find them to be relevant to issuers when we go through transactions with like the five-day notice there may be certain
things where we do apply a different standard or introduce a different requirement for that senior tier and we'll see how those go what kind of feedback we get as we add more we currently only have one senior tier issuer and that was a slam dunk because it's also listed on the TSE so it was not a venture issuer to begin with for any others that we designate we'll do
them at the time of listing if we if we determine that they meet the requirements we'll ask the issuer if they want to be listed as an issuer or an NV issuer and if they choose the Envy issuer we'll of course get that undertaking and consent filed with us and filed on cdar and they will then be treated as an NV issuer going forward so that's how that's going to apply I think
that the big question for everyone was how it was going to work and whether or not the issuer was going to have a choice and we can confirm now absolutely the issuer will have a choice and it would be highly unlikely that we would designate an issuer as a senior tier as an Envy issuer unless the the issuer consented to it and I think that was it the margin
eligibility was the last bit of good news that's right that's right and what may be news too a few of you if you might have detected from Mark referring to the Toronto Stock Exchange it's the TSE he and I and our CEO Richard Carlton often do that because we used to work there when it was the TSC but now it's known as the TSX right and as I
recall it was changed so that there wasn't confusion with the Tokyo Stock Exchange that was also using TSE I remember how many logos we went through when we were there right I think we beat it here right so we're open we're open for questions if or comments if anyone has it
we didn't give any to James just to oh going once well done if you don't ask questions you'll get 10 more 10 more minutes of Rob's humor no no no I'm done
David oh thanks David I presume everyone can see that we're looking at prior expenditures outside the 36 months we have to recognize what we have for this for the past few years we have to recognize that there were significant restrictions on anybody getting to a property or being able to to reach the threshold we're more concerned with with the expenditures themselves and who made
them then then the specific 36 months but also what's happened in the 36 months in the last 36 months so if somebody did a bunch of work and then and it was a property they could have had access to and just and it was just left sitting there and now this property is just going to use to get a another vehicle listed that's different so we'll look at the circumstances but
we want to see why the work hasn't been done but we've been very accommodating we've exercised a lot of discretion with respect to the specific timing right and we certainly did that before yeah but pretty much it was exemptions were based on the level of past expenditure and how far Advanced the property was so that the more the larger the prior expenditures were and some
were in the several millions of dollars and the more advanced the property was the more likely that that we would accept expenditures that that were further back than 36 months some some of that you know would have been you know just due to cyclicality of the particular mineral in question and we'll consider the budget as well you know if the company comes in and and none of the expenditures are have met
the the requirement and the first phase budget barely meets the requirements that's you know that that takes a little bit more analysis but expenditures far exceeding the minimum but just outside the 36 months and then a great first phase budget that's much easier to to exercise that discretion and accept it and you're welcome thank you dip want to change their listing oh you can let's get this let's get this a little
bit more specific James for you mean for the dozens and dozens of companies that want to move to the CSH from another exchange I presume because of those changes to the to the listing statement and specifically to allow incorporation by reference for an existing listed company the the process is fairly straightforward because it's an application there's still a review process but when there's no concurrent
fundamental change RTO transaction or even a major acquisition if the company's just moving over as a listed company to switch exchanges the listing statement is really intended to just pull the information together that's already there so investors have a single point of reference if it's if it's all if the previous disclosure is all Incorporated by reference it's more of just a road map of where to find that disclosure and
that came about from discussions with the with commission staff who really believe that we should still have a single document to sort of identify that that move from one exchange to the other we're still looking at whether that's really necessary or not in our view the switch should be like switching cell phone providers nothing has happened you take your number with you you and in this case you take your symbol with you
your continuous disclosure record is unchanged and you know a comprehensive news release should be enough so we're going to continue to look at that for the the switches for a company an active company in good standing simply moving from One exchange to the other and and try and reduce it even more but right now the biggest change of course is just that it's it's not a full-on listing
statement it's not a effectively a prospectus on its own it's really just a document that summarizes everything pulls it together existing disclosure together so we're looking at from the time we get it from a completed document we're looking at weeks rather than months to get it listed
and there you go listings at the cse.com you usually get a faster reply than if you try to phone or if you sent something to me or Rob ready this this goes to a lot of people when they go to listings they're not going through a filter or going to one person who's going to you know then search for a lot of people get those
and that way as soon as the the right person sees that and knows that they're the one to respond you should get a fairly quick response with that email thanks everyone



