About This Video
"Catch our replay of “How the World of ESG is Affecting Disclosure” panel, moderated by the CSE’s Anna Serin, which featured Bill Gilliland, Partner, Corporate, Securities, M&A, Governance, Power Industry, Sustainable Finance at Dentons; Seth Forman, President of ESG at Socialsuite; and Edward Olson, Partner, Enterprise Risk Services & Leader, Environmental, Social & Governance at MNP. This compelling session kicked off with rapid-fire presentations and key insights into recent reporting and disclosure developments, standards and frameworks, and the benefits of ESG and ESG reporting, followed by a Q&A panel session covering a wide range of topics, including opinions on mandated disclosure, ESG in the fossil fuel industry, and greenwashing and “green hushing.”
The CSE’s Summit on Responsible Investment on June 27, 2023, in Kelowna, BC was designed to empower investors and entrepreneurs with the latest insights into socially responsible investing (SRI) and environmental, social, and governance (ESG) trends, regulations, and best practices. The full-day event featured an exciting agenda packed with expert panel discussions, presentations from industry leaders, company spotlights, and networking opportunities."
Subscribe for more great CSE insights and interviews here: https://go.thecse.com/CSETV-Subscribe
STAY CONNECTED WITH THE CSE
=============================
- NEWSLETTER: https://go.thecse.com/CSE-Mailing-List-Subscribe
- PODCAST: https://blog.thecse.com/cse-podcasts/
- INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/canadianexchange/
- LINKEDIN: https://ca.linkedin.com/company/canadian-securities-exchange
- FACEBOOK: https://www.facebook.com/CanadianSecuritiesExchange/
- TWITTER: https://twitter.com/CSE_News
- BLOG: https://blog.thecse.com/
- WEBSITE: https://thecse.com/
- MAGAZINE: https://issuu.com/thecse/docs
Read the TranscriptAuto-generated by YouTube; names and terms may be misspelled.
thank you if you're a seasoned investor or new to the game this is going to be a great session to help you and build your due diligence practices there's a lot of information that public companies especially but private companies as well need to disclose and there's places where they have to report information luckily we have three experts here today who are going to help us figure out what
those are and where to find them so our panel discussion today is how ESG is affecting the world of disclosure there's a lot of new information that is coming to market around ESG practices and mandates so I'd like to welcome Bill Gilliland partner corporate Securities M A governance power industries sustainable Finance with Dentons is that on your business card that whole title is a fold out card perfect
so Bill he is a lawyer with Dentons and he is based out of Calgary he came all the way out here thank you very much for traveling out Bill we're then going to move to Edward Olsen Edward is partner Enterprise risk services and leader environmental social and governance with MMP again does that fit on your business card all right thank you Edward Edward runs the ESG
practice with MMP and he is based out of Kelowna so he is a local thank you very much Edward and then Seth Foreman he's president of ESG with social suite and he joined us from New York he almost didn't make it and he has a smaller business card but thank you very much Seth for joining us today so they're each going to do a presentation and then I'm going to bring
them all up here and we will have a panel discussion thank you again
thank you okay
oh okay foreign okay so we can go to the purple slide that I think is up next yeah there you are I only have one slide so thanks for having me here really appreciate the opportunity I run Denton's Canada's ESG practice in Canada which we call the ESG igniter group the main focus is not to wrap our arm our groups arms around all ESG work
because it's just a massive area but we're really trying to be an all disciplinary practice to push ESG knowledge and and really the ability to provide practical advice in the space to all of our lawyers so I bring that perspective I'm also on the board of a pension fund in our pension plan in Canada so I actually bring a bit of an investor hat perspective to this as well
so they've asked us just to sort of sort of make a few key points in our brief introduction here and so I've got one slide that you can see and I think we're going to talk about all these things in more detail but the first one is I often say ESG means a lot but it can also mean basically nothing right and that really leads us into the concept of
green washing but social washing as well but the other equally relevant thing for public companies because you're trying to get your message out there the uncertainty around greenwashing and so on can lead to green hushing or social hushing so companies that are afraid to to make statements and comments around what they're doing in the area because they're concerned about regulatory or litigation risk okay great news yesterday the international
sustainability Standards Board the issb which is part of the IFRS organization that all public companies in the room will be familiar with released its first to sustainability standards S1 and S2 the first is a general sustainability disclosure standard that that captures really all areas of sustainability but the more immediately relevant one that companies would be free to adopt for 2024 would be their S2 so climate related disclosure standards so this is pretty
significant not because the issb standards are themselves mandatory they're still voluntary but they really reflect a coalescence of the multiplicity of acronyms and voluntary standards that we're probably familiar with you know within that one issb framework and I think we can expect in Canada our Canadian Securities Regulators to have a real serious hard look at what the issb disclosure standards require when they I think come up with their
next version of the national instrument 51-107 climate change disclosure proposals that they issued frankly before anyone else in North America did but they've stated that they really want to support what the issb has done as a global Baseline standard for disclosure so I think those issb rules are are ones that that folks should have a look at Bill s 211 which is colloquially known as the child you know child labor slave
labor legislation that's going to be very relevant I think for all public companies starting in 2024 regardless of size we'll need to make just closure about their supply chain and the due diligence they're doing to ensure there's no child labor or unfair labor practices and so on built into their supply chain so that's those are those are important and these are all things that are going to help companies get
more comfortable you know in terms of making disclosure and avoiding green washing and help with get over the green the green hushing the social hushing issue but the last point is is a you know an osvia office of superintendent of financial institutions which is a federal organization issued a guideline which is really targeted at our big commercial Banks all of the big Banks telling them that starting in 2024 they
are going to have to make climate risk related Financial disclosure so all of the things that the tcfd has required all the things that the issb has kind of modeled and just the key message from my perspective is that in that influence is going to come from the finance financial sector investors is going to require that anyone dealing with them is going to have to provide the disclosure those Banks need in order
to make their own disclosure so whether you're a private company a large public company a small public company any kind of organization that may deal with a bank and there are other organizations that deal with similar similar concepts for institutional investors they're going to be driving the the required disclosure that I think all companies are going to make so with that I'll just turn it over to Ed Olson
thanks Bill and good morning everybody it's really great to be here I I felt a little bit sobered when Tanya threw up the date 1973 and said what's important about a tenant that's my birth year as well so you must be extremely young like I am which is really great so thank you I I sit on CPA Canada's sustainability reporting advisory committee I'm the co-chair of the praxney alliance Global
ESG committee I also sit on ISO greenhouse gas guidance globally and you know there's three things that come to mind that we're trying to achieve with a sustainability reporting the first is consistency the next is comparability and the third is transparency those principles are absolutely fundamental to the information that investors are going to need and why is that a problem right now well you can just open up and Google search ESG
standard or framework and you have a plethora of about everything under the sun and while there has been some consolidation and consistency which is a good thing I actually do celebrate what bill just brought up right now the international sustainability Standards Board their two sustainability related standards IFRS S1 and S2 why because it's going to be setting a global Baseline now does that mean it's all going to apply in Canada likely not but
what I'm working with the chair of the Canadian sustainability Standards Board on is we need something that does not vary Canada too far globally because we need to go back to the consistency and the comparability that a company in Germany can be compared to that of a company in Canada and we can understand what is your sustainability positioning because at the end of the day as investors and as companies you need to
know business resilience are you going to be here for the long term and the long term includes many different environmental and social issues that need to be wrapped around the right governance framework and to me those are the challenges in the wild west that we're trying to bring consistency to because ultimately when I and I might be a little bit of a sustainability nerd right now when I jump on flights I pull up
sustainability reports and I read them here's the caution I give to you as consumers or even developers or reports volume is not value and I see too many voluminous reports that if you're an old okay this is going back to 1973 10 years for you're watching Fred Flintstone right the terrorist or the what was the burger they throw on the side of his car and it flips over that's the sustainability
reports of today and I don't like it the Brontosaurus Berker thank you Richard seed wise advice from the front I love it we're getting the Brontosaurus Burger sustainability reports and they don't add value one of our four biggest banks in Canada just asked me here before the holidays last year can you take a quick look at what we've done for our sustainability reporting not a problem all I did was here's what your CEO
committed you to this is what the Net Zero Finance Alliance looks like here's what your sustainability report says and here's what your tcfd report says here's all the inconsistencies here's everything that you missed here's at the end of the day what looked good but you didn't provide value and here's one example we've doubled our financing of electric vehicles did you add a value do you have a Target
no we have over 26 million registered motor vehicles in Canada and I couldn't care less if you doubled from 2 000 to 4 000 vehicles this is about value and disclosures for stakeholders around those things that are most material some that are industry agnostic and others that are particular to Industries alone what I'm challenging is we need to be specific as companies for disclosures and we need to be
Discerning as users of that information not just to say here's Ed walking through a canola field with his child well that looks really nice they must be a sustainable company it's got to go a little bit further than that I know I'm coming down on my timing here's one last story I'll share with you Tanya you brought up again sorry to keep pointing at you right now but you just you're in
my line of sight this is about balancing goals as well I'm working with a utility down in the Caribbean and one of the goals is we want to be a hundred percent green energy well that is a great and Noble exercise to have a Target here's the problem the U.N sustainable development goals also says we need to have Equitable and affordable energy for all I could retrofit the entire Island today
with clean energy but that infrastructure cost is going to drive up energy cost to the point where your local community can't even afford electricity I want to also challenge you do not isolate and go after one topic alone this is about raising the entire boat and I'm hoping that we can talk about that in some of our panel discussion today thank you that's my five minutes I think I'm going to be
pulled off stage Seth
hello all right everybody my name is Seth Foreman I'm the president that's social Suite great to be here today as Anna said I almost didn't make it on Sunday night there were a lot of storms in the New York area a lot of flight delays I got on the I was the last seat on the last flight out to get to Toronto and make it out here or else it wouldn't have made it
the gods of Kelowna were with us and and here we are and thanks to CSC thanks Richard and Nan and everybody for putting this event together it's it's really fantastic to be here so I'm gonna I'm only gonna spend a few minutes I'll do a quick intro about social Suite but I'm going to really focus my neck my time here on the why why ESG is important why ESU
reporting is important in what we're seeing in the market so if we go to the next slide please so a little bit about social Suite oh I have the clicker oh great perfect so a little bit about social Suite so social Suite is a eshee technology platform we designed our entire platform specifically built for mainly microcap and small cap companies to be simple easy to use and cost effective to help
companies in particular get started on this EEG Journey given how complex and overwhelming it can be for these types of companies we today we've raised a series a about a year ago and we now have 95 public companies on board across multiple different sectors from resources biotech technology and software I'm going to skip through because we've already taken care of what is he is she so why is ESG important
three main factors that we focus on at Social Suite what we're seeing in the market mainly it's about Capital customers and then compliance on the capital side we've talked a lot about this today there's somewhere around 10 trillion dollars of ESU driven capital in the market in the markets today globally mainly driven by funds that look at and evaluate issue driven metrics as part of that evaluation
process in terms of where they're going to invest that Capital so why is that important for companies to have at ESG information on their websites and disclose is because the funds that are out there require and need this ESG information to make those decisions so if you don't have ESU metrics and you haven't started that ESU Journey as a public company you potentially could get screened out from a lot of these
investors and so what that does by ESG reporting is that it widens your net of of potential Capital it potentially can lower your cost of capital so there's a lot of benefits around that at the institutional level and then there's also a lot of research at the retail level where there's particularly younger retail investors look highly across companies that are on that sustainability and ESG track so the
investor side is really important the second Factor here is around customers what we're referring to here is a lot of multinational companies are starting to look at their supply chains and really putting in place mandates and strongly encouraging their suppliers to have and start tracking ESG information this goes for the tassels of the world the GMS the Fords big companies that are really starting this and it goes all the way
down supplier level down into the actual exploration level where they're really starting to ask for information about emissions certain social requests around things like diversity and really trying to push their suppliers to be more sustainable given the pressures that they're under to enhance and improve their reporting so if you're even an early stage company and you're looking to establish off-take agreements or even if you're trying to sell your
product up into a larger company having that even just Baseline reporting about your plans around sustainability and ESG is really really important again another reason to get started and then the third area that my my peers just addressed around compliance it's coming out of the United States the SEC is expected to Pat to finalize their climate disclosure ruling this October which is expected to be the final action where they're going to be
requiring first large public companies and on down to smaller public companies to have certain aspects of their climate disclosures things like their emissions and certain analysis that will be required and we're seeing this globally out of Europe it's already required for certain size companies and then also in Canada and Australia there's certain proposals in place that's expected to be finalized relatively soon another reason to get started to educate and begin that
Journey I got 50 seconds I'm just go to one other point here now ESU reporting is not only important for certain stakeholders but it's also shown to be and and have really positive business results for companies not only to help with lowering your cost of capital Better Business performance but from an investor side as well a significant proportion of investors are looking at ESU reporting as again an important part
of that evaluation process and there's a lot of data points here to really prove that point out as to why it's so important to get started and again I think this this deck will be provided after the fact and last slide is really around that that journey and starting point and social Suite has spent a lot of time phasing out programs for different size companies helping smaller companies get
started on that journey through really that initiate and align phase and then companies that are a little bit farther along in that Journey helping them continue to progress continue to provide information and report on multiple different Frameworks that are out in the market that investors are asking for that customers are asking for and so on and so forth so looking forward to our panel right now so we can
dive into this topic even further so thanks everybody gentlemen that was great actually I like that rapid fire so so we do have some can questions some topics we want to talk about but definitely encourage anyone to raise their hand if they want to ask a question to any of these folks we do have some microphones floating around so if you do have a question feel free to
raise your hand any start off or is it my turn all right Nicole a microphone's coming your way quickly or you can come up and use one of these yeah there you go this may be a tough one to start off with but a Kelly schul I think shoe at the Yale School of Management did a study on ESG investing focusing on a sustainability and her hypothesis was
that and by the way I I was in CSR at Disney for 10 years so I it's not like I'm anti any of this but she hypothesized that actually if we were to invest into ESG investments in big oil companies for example like they did wedding was impact one out of San Francisco put money into exxon's sustainability fund so they could develop you know proper ways of doing things for the
environment that that would actually have a greater impact than if we were to invest in companies that are what we think of as as green companies and that that would be profoundly bigger impact on the environment so anyhow starting off with a very controversial topic bold bold what are your thoughts on that well thanks for tenderizing us for this panel right now I I'll put a little asterisk next to
my head right now so if this is being taped it may not necessarily be that of MMP but that of Edward the reason why I can still land in Calgary and not have a face of you if you see him put him back on a plane and send them home is because I'm not necessarily the all or none turn off all fossil fuels I think there was a
missed opportunity in terms of fossil fuels around what could have and should have been done and now it's a speed let's get back up to where we should have been that could have been done 20 years ago so there's a tremendous opportunity and I think there's a great opportunity because I used to run an alternative energy company I could always get through central heating cooling domestic hot water maybe 80
percent of the energy needs for a building unfortunately that last 20 percent I would go to electricity and natural gas some a big hashtag energy that it's an energy mix requirement and there's still a definitive role to be played but there's Innovation to be done that can help us in transitioning to a lower carbon economy so I'm still a believer in the roles but not a what we've always
done will always work I think there's a change in the value in the expectations and we need to change accordingly so that's just a first thought on my end yeah I I'm with you Edward and I think that it's look we're we're going through a transition this is not a hey and and I've there's a lot of and hey let's stop funding fossil fuel I mean if you if you
cut off fossil fuels today you know the the world it goes into Anarchy like you can't have that right there there's this is a 20 to 30 year transition and it's going to take time to get there and there needs to be tremendous investment into cleantech and clean Technologies and moving towards the sustainable future and I think that even the Exxon mobils of the world they are doing a lot
to try to work through that transition and you know at the end of the day Exxon Mobil they do have an expertise and extraction we have a massive mining problem where we're trying to there's a there's a tremendous amount of demand that we need and there's not enough Supply so there's companies like that like the Exxon mobils of the world that can really help with that extraction make us move faster on that on on trying
to catch up on the on the extraction point because we need a lot of critical minerals and such that's out there so I I think that again it goes back to that transition and and pushing forward on that way but it needs to be pragmatic in that approach that we take foreign as the Calgary guy I need to say something on this and I'm going to first
of all start by thanking Ed and Seth for for making what I think is really the main comment or the the major response to that question but I'm going to maybe provide a slightly different perspective because there's an angle to that question that is a really live debate right now going on in Canada in the sustainable Finance space so I do a lot of work with the international Capital markets
Association helping them design a set of principles that can apply to labeled Finance products so if you wanted to label a bond or a loan as green or sustainable or sustainability linked there's a set of principles that you can follow in order to apply that label and in Canada given our extractive economy fossil fuel based we've done a lot of work around the appropriate use of the transition
label on that kind of financial tool and there is actually a sort of a taxonomy a transition Finance taxonomy road map I think is what it's called that's out there in front of the that's been developed by a federally appointed panel of experts so you can understand the way it probably leans right in terms of how that works but the suggestion you know the debate is the extent to which
National Gas producers should be able to for example or consumers use that transition label right and the risk is that if you believe that the use of these tools is a way to drive Capital towards a transition or towards a Greener sustainable future that you end up restricting the use of these labels such that companies Brown you know Brown industries that actually really need to do the transition and a lot of these
companies are are committed to transitioning they're not going to be able to use those tools right and which is not going to be helpful in driving this transition right so that's just another just another approach but thank you for making the the main Alberta response to that so appreciate that yeah have any other questions questions oh one over here
you go representing the left side of the room
s about your thoughts should publicly listed
so for those who couldn't hear the primary question was should it be mandated for Capital Market participants or every company public companies okay that's a question just so everybody could hear it let me go first so yeah it's it's a very important question I think in general so one is that we're already moving on that that road map so it's coming and you know as I mentioned
earlier the SEC at the U.S is going to likely it's supposed to pass in October Canada Australia other markets Europe's already on that track so yeah personally I think it's important that it is mandated I think the questions the implementation of it do I think that a Fortune 100 company should have the exact same mandates around disclosure as a as an as a Explorer on the CSE that's just getting
going so that that is a big no I think that there really needs to be and and I don't think the regulatory The Regulators have done enough spend enough time thinking this through because it's really not fair to a smaller public company they have the same disclosures as a Fortune 100 that has a chief sustainability officer that has a team of 100 ESG experts versus a company that doesn't have any ESG or
chief sustainability officer so that is the I think that's the big question and that's a big gap right now that that I'm hoping The Regulators as they think through these mandates can can address because it really needs to be simple and cost effective for the smaller companies but they should report on information it's just a matter of what and what does that look like and I would just add very briefly that
when you look at the deployment of capital it's about protecting Capital as well so if we don't see what the disclosure the transition the target the performance then even financed emissions right now as a bank or as a credit union or other you're going to be saying is there underlying collateral value erosion is there an inability to Debt Service will I be able to recoup on the
capital that I've invested this is about business resilience so for me as an investor I'd be saying I need to consume this information where are you and we do need to have the accommodation because it's not a one-size-fit-all so I really appreciate that there needs to be disclosures but it has to be in the right transition for the small and mid-size entities in Canada and it has to be aligned with expectations to
understand that business resilience linked back to Capital so it's a almost an indirect but direct way of saying yes we need it but it's not a one-size-fits-all so thank you and look I would agree with everything that's been said here but what I would add is that you know sadly Canada is somewhat late to the game in this whole Space right in terms of making disclosure proposals and certainly anything
around mandating climate related disclosures Canadian Capital markets are Global right we Capital Moves In and Out of Canada if we want by my personal view is if we want to remain a credible Capital Market in Canada we do need to have a level of mandated disclosure around climate climate risk we know that when the CSA put out its proposals it's one of one of his proposal was well you
don't need to disclose any of your emissions but if you don't you should just explain why right which presumably could have include while it's hard right so but the CSA got seriously criticized for that because investors are Global and they're not you know that I think they their the message was you know you're going to lose credibility as a capital market for for deployment of capital unless you have some level of
disclosure that's required so Tanya I think we have a mic over there you can bring you
really recruitment or retention and I wonder if you can unpack the connection between ESG the communication piece and that attraction and attention of retention of talent within organizations a little bit because I think that was a really interesting step that we don't talk enough about in terms of the talent that's so necessary for each one of our organizations did you mean it for Seth that's okay the other the other sorry
the other end yeah no yeah Tony it's good good question yeah I think that another really important piece of this is the employees and so you know we do have research that shows that again this is particularly for your your employees that are either just coming out of college or just starting out in their careers particularly for the the younger generation that you know at the end of
the day sustainability is so important for them because this is the world that they're going to live in and they're seeing what's happening with climate change and they they want to work for a company that's having real impact that cares deeply and is transparent about all these different types of sustainability and ESG issues and so for them for the companies that are starting to report and are transparent about
their plans across these different ESG factors it does show that from a recruitment and from a retainment standpoint it's it's a big boost to those efforts and at the end of the day we are people organizations and so to attract that talent that you need having that information having that that ESG steps is a is is important so one thing I want to ask before we move along we might have time for one more
question but I think one thing that comes up a lot is this idea of green washing so I just want to touch on that for a moment it's a pretty scary idea but where in disclosure and Reporting as an investor could you investigate that or have some idea that that's what you're buying into maybe maybe start off by explaining properly what green washing is sure well I'll start I'll start on
this one I mean green washing actually does not have any sort of specific meaning but generally I think what people mean by it is either unsubstantiated disclosure around environmental matters so climate risk for example but it can also be social washing so around social social issues like d and I and supply chain issues so it means that or it means disclosure about any of those things that misrepresents
you know the State of the State of play within an organization so the best example is a large oil and gas company advertising how you know it's its development of a wind farm somewhere right but without the context of that investment comprising sort of one percent of its capex in one year versus 99 going towards oil and gas you know exploring new oil and gas it's somewhat
misrepresents sort of the true approach of that company so that's kind of what green washing is and and where would you go to Source out if if you were if a company was screen washing well and it's interesting to bring that up because as we see the evolution of mandatory disclosures globally you typically see the mandatory Assurance requirements following suit and so when you look at disclosures right now there's
disclosures publicly by a company but there's also the business the business disclosures that are going to come with a requirement related to if Seth is capital markets and I'm private Enterprise he has to comply for disclosures I'm in his Supply Chain by essence of you being mandated to I also will because I'm in that supply chain he needs to trust my disclosure and I can't be well Ed seems like a good guy I'm
going to trust it there's going to be a cascading order of assurance that will be required and it will be needed otherwise we won't get to that point to having Comfort around is this truly greenwashing that you're overstating something or you're understating your actual exposure to try and protect the Optics in order to secure Capital so to me there is a risk that risk has to be addressed through Assurance but
Assurance standards have to change that's why we're working through a lot of different assurance and the auditing Insurance Standards Board for Canada right now and isn't part of the process with the modern slavery act right is that it's it's in the chain and you have to have assurances that that's not happening in a country where something might be manufactured I was just going to say yes and now the
hard part is how far will companies be pressed in order to prove it I was just using I think it was with you last night bill I was talking about the import of coffee beans into Canada and when I asked the company where do you Source your beans oh it's from a good wholesaler in the U.S well how did you prove that they have ensured that it did
not come from and they said we don't know the we don't know is not going to carry any type of weight moving forward it's now the I need to be able to answer that question and if you can't that responsibility is now on you and in turn that country would have to abide by those standards as well right go ahead Seth no I was just gonna go back to the from a green washing
standpoint I mean we look at the end of the day it's really if you're gonna say it and say things as it relates to your sustainability efforts you need to do it and there needs to be action and so that's that's really what it what it comes down to I think that part of you know why green washing has been a lot of Front Page News recently and
there's been a lot of companies that are being called out and funds being called out for this is part of it is that there's been such a lack of clarity around the standards and rules and what is what is good what is not good what is sustainability there's a lot of cleanup that's happening right now it's going to continue to happen I think it'll improve drastically now that you have
regulations coming there's a bit more clarity around like what is good and who's doing things well and that ultimately will come around to it but but I think or someone mentioned green hushing the flip side of that is that now with a lot of companies being called out for green washing you're now see seeing this a lot of companies being really cautious around how they communicate what they're doing around
sustainability and that's where the green hushing turn comes in because companies are now continuing to have action around what they're doing from a sustainability standpoint but they're being a little bit more careful around how they're communicating it publicly so that they're not you know obviously they don't want to get called out for the green washing side of things so it's a real it's a lot of balance and a lot of tricky dance
that companies are playing right now but most importantly they're all continuing on that Journey amazing thank you we do have to move along but do you have a quick question okay quick answers gentlemen decide further on the flip side which is you're also particularly in the United States right now a huge pressure to basically go after ESG in its entire world right don't you know we're the Alabama State Pension
Fund we're taking everything anybody says ESG we're pulling out of that Florida saying blah blah blah so how do you and your Rel in your prospective professions counter the critical nature of the pushback that is coming well-funded pushback among a small and very vocal and very powerful segment of society I'll make it really quick for me we're trying first of all to disconnect politics from sustainability and unfortunately that's linked right now so
we're trying to separate that as my first barrier the second barrier is when I say to the I've been working with many boards oh so it's okay you would like to have children under the age of 12 working for you well no well okay so you're not against a social issue I would like to take the waste oil that we have and go dump it in the lake
that's close by that's okay right well no we're not going to do that so all of this is prudent business practice that they would not do unfortunately we have that first barrier politics involved I'm going back to the essentials how do we create value how do we preserve value how does sustainability drive that now how do we disclose that story because if you don't write it somebody's writing it
about you too yeah look our firm we we have we're in the U.S as well our firm has received a letter from the senate committee on antitrust right essentially that 50 law firms in the U.S received essentially threatening the law firm over antitrust investigation around our participation or potential participation and encouraging non-competitive Behavior through and anti-competitive Behavior through you know promotion of ESG right
and so we you know we've had to take we've had to really have us have a thorough look at that and assess what we would do but at the end of the day we've got our overwhelming volume of clients that want advice in the space and and so you know we we provide that advice so yeah yeah I mean I think you know I'm also
based in the U.S it's of course being in the ESG business you're seeing a lot of controversial action around this I think at the end of the day words are coming from you have certain aspects on the anti-issue movement they just believe that company any investor should be only looking at the financial side of the company and that's part of it you have aspects of lobbyists involved you have
aspects of a lot of confusion ESG is relatively new for most of the average person out there and so it's easily manipulated into like this is really bad but I think people don't really understand what it is so a lot of it there needs to be a lot more education a lot more action on the pro ESG and sustainability side of all the benefits around this there's a lot it's it's it's
it's a quite a deep topic but I think from a PLA and it's become politicized as well so at the end of the day a I think that you know they're as long as there's a force out there that's really stating the overall benefits and the positive action around sustainability and ESG then you know it's because we have we don't have a choice you know it's really
you know if if we if the global if everybody globally doesn't do anything around this then you know where where are we in 50 years so this absolutely has to happen and you know it's it's it's really around action thank you so much listen gentlemen thank you so much I was thinking this would be the start of a good joke right a lawyer an auditor and and an ESG reporter walk onto a stage
they will be around on and off throughout the day and I know there's more questions but they will be around so and I can make sure that I introduce you so if you reach out to me I can make introductions gentlemen thank you so much thank you thank you



