About This Video
CSE's Phillip Shum is joined by Julie Abouchar, Partner at Willms & Shier Environmental Lawyers LLP to discuss her experience negotiating and drafting resource agreements for industry and First Nations clients over the past 20 years, including impact benefit, participation and exploration agreements. She provides advice about Aboriginal consultation and facilitates dispute resolution in the mining, infrastructure and energy sectors. Here are the highlights of the discussion:
0:00 - Introducing Julie Abouchar
1:36 - The duty to consult with indigenous peoples
6:56 - Drafting an impact benefit agreements (IBA) in NWT and Nunavat
11:07 - Measuring the efficacy of the IBA
13:00 - The differences between ESG and CSR
15:00 - Advice for a successful IBA
18:05 - Setting metrics and having them assessed independently
20:36 - The impact of not engaging indigenous support
23:05 - Willms & Shier Environmental Lawyers LLP - a science backed law firm
25:57 - The ultimate benefits of positive Aboriginal relations
Julie Abouchar is a recognized expert in environmental, Aboriginal and energy and natural resources law. She also advocates before tribunals and is a trained mediator. Julie is called to the bar in Ontario, New Brunswick, Nunavut and Northwest Territories.
Related link
https://www.ccab.com/
Subscribe for more great CSE insights and interviews here: https://bit.ly/CSETVSubscribe
STAY CONNECTED WITH THE CSE
=============================
- PODCAST: https://blog.thecse.com/pe-podcasts/
- INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/canadianexchange/
- LINKEDIN: https://ca.linkedin.com/company/canadian-securities-exchange
- FACEBOOK: https://www.facebook.com/CanadianSecuritiesExchange/
- TWITTER: https://twitter.com/CSE_News
- BLOG: https://blog.thecse.com/
- WEBSITE: https://thecse.com/
MB016ZPOWZWFCBF
Read the TranscriptAuto-generated by YouTube; names and terms may be misspelled.
welcome to mining over canada join the canadian securities exchange and our partners in a first-hand look into our country's vast mining landscape hi it's philip shum i'm the listing development director here with the csc in toronto canada i am here today and very excited to talk with julie abu abushar who is with wilms and shire which are environmental lawyers headquartered here in toronto with offices in ottawa
calgary and yellowknife welcome julie thank you phil today we're going to talk about because this is this is mining over canada a mining over canada special obviously we want to be able to talk about different types of interesting topics today we are talking about csr corporate social responsibility and indigenous rights so do us a favor and maybe walk us through a bit about yourself and tell us why
your talk is the most important talk that is here okay phil well i think this is the most important talk because major projects really can't go ahead in canada these days unless they have good positive relations with indigenous people okay and so maybe walk us through a bit about what you do as an environmental lawyer and then more importantly like like why is it important sure
i'm an environmental lawyer certified by the law society of ontario but i'm also i'm certified as an expert in both environmental law and indigenous rights governance and corporate legal issues so i work right at the intersection of these two areas at the risk of oversimplifying what i do the starting point for my work is the 1982 amendment of the canadian constitution in 1982 they added section 35
which recognizes and affirms aboriginal and treaty rights of indigenous people over the decades following 1982 canadian courts have considered what section 35 means in practice it's all very well to have this recognition but how what does it mean on your day-to-day work so the supreme court of canada developed a legal obligation through a series of cases and the obligation is called the duty to consult the significance of the duty to consult
is that every time the government issues a permit or is considering issuing a permit safe for mining or mineral exploration projects and the project is on indigenous people's traditional territory and if there's a potential for it to impact indigenous rights the government must consult with the indigenous people about the impacts on their rights and how to mitigate or accommodate for the impacts and this really affects mining industry in canada as across canada and
nearly 1200 indigenous communities live near mines the government is and the government is permitted to and typically does delegate the consultation procedures to the mining company seeking the permit so it's very important for a mine in their early planning and stages planning and permitting stages of the project to engage with indigenous people on whose territorial lands the project is is operating or hopes to operate so what is what type of agreement
usually would come out of that i mean like when so when you are you have this duty to consult first of all walk us through that process what is what does that look like and maybe if you could address it from both sides if you could right so i mean what it is what it looks like on the ground are discussions between about the
potential impact between the mining company or the exploration company and the indigenous community it's a series of meetings and conversations about the potential impact on the environment on lands on exercise of indigenous rights on the socio-economic fabric of the community on cultural and spiritual practices all of that is is considered and sometimes it means that the the company will have to support support financially support that review
so provide funding for the indigenous community to review reports review the scientific tech reports and understand what what the impacts mean for them and you know potentially do further studies themselves to look at how their land is being used and what the impacts could be but it doesn't stop at the assessment mining companies also then together with the communities would assess how these impacts can be lessened
or accommodated for and so through the discussion oh sorry i mean you asked about both sides it's really a conversation together you know the mining company and the indigenous community are seeking to learn about each other and learn about how you know whether there are so every every situation is different every mining company or exploration company has a different a different a different project and a
different financial situation and every first nation or indigenous community has different goals and aspirations and it's really a conversation to understand each other's interests and concerns and how you know what the what a successful mind could look like to both of them so it's a lot of discussions it's a lot of listening to each other and then together identifying how to lessen impacts of the mind and how to benefit
the indigenous people and then once you have the discussions all of this is written into an agreement and so this is where i come in the agreements are commonly called impact benefit agreements but they have other names like community or participation agreements and they've become best practice throughout canada and although they're only legally required for projects in the northwest territories and none of them okay what this this facet of
northwest territories so so it's legally required because it's embedded within the constitution or is it more of a provincial mandate so it's a territorial mandate and it's in the land claim settlement agreements the land the nunavut agreement which is the land claim settlement for the inuit in nunavut and for in in for similar agreements in the northwest territories oh interesting so when you talk about
the impact benefit agreement i guess the acronym is iba i suspect right so for this these ibas how long do these negotiations typically take and you know what are maybe some of the best practices that you would advise to your client on how to approach it sure ibas can take you know they think they take a while usually but they're usually started at the permitting phase so while you're
going through the permitting process which could take you know a year to a year and a half in canada or more in some cases depending on what issues issues the government may may have or you know what studies may be done but it's during that permitting phase so the length of the permitting phase you know and and perhaps starting a bit before so that you finish
at the same time that you get your permits is about the length of time for typical impact benefit agreement negotiations and so you know what i tell clients clients ask what are they what's in them and you know they've they've been around for a number of years now so there's a number of things that are typically in these agreements the the key for the the mining company is
that they solidify the support of the indigenous communities for the project so that's key because it brings regulatory certainty to the mining company but then all the other things that has are are largely benefits for the mining for the indigenous community but are also a win-win for the mining company so they provide training opportunities for indigenous people to become part of the local mine workforce they
have provisions that promote business opportunities and set asides for indigenous businesses they provide for ongoing monitoring and permit review and this is going to be a legal requirement anyway that the mine continue to engage and consult with the indigenous communities who are potentially impacted so the agreement sets out a process for doing that the agreement set up a funding arrangement for the life of the mine so
to provide capacity to the indigenous community to play their role in the agreement the the agreement set up a dispute resolution mechanism and they provide sharing of the profits from the resources with the indigenous people ibas are binding contracts they're like commercial contracts they're binding they have obligations on both sides both for the mining company and for the indigenous people and and philip some people ask us well
we're just doing exploration do we have to enter one of these agreements mining exploration does have potential for impact on indigenous rights and use of land in the ground the government does ask at mining exploration companies to consult with indigenous communities there is a process that is more in legislation for that process and so there are time frames that are set out but nonetheless there is still the
requirement to engage and these discussions take place and many times the company and the first nation get into an exploration agreement these are not nowhere near as of all involved as the ibas but they do include environmental monitoring they may include some financial a financial side to them and a commitment to negotiate an iba if the exploration results in a mine okay so on the assumption that both sides have managed to meet an
iba or to sign an iba and it's of course binding as you mentioned how does one measure the efficacy of the of the iba so from a metric standpoint how do you how do you identify whether it's working or not right well you would want to know whether the obligations are being met so it's i can only speak about in generalities if there are provisions for for procurement for instance then you
would want to measure the annual supply chain spend on indigenous communities for the the for the company if the iba has a target for employment then you want to measure to see whether the number of indigenous employees meets the target you know the the iba may have a commitment to accelerate indigenous employees through to into management so you might have a metric of how many are in management positions
the iba may have some training programs so then you'd want to measure how how's the training going how many training programs have been set up how many digits people participated how many indigenous people completed the training and get hired or advanced so those you you sort of measure the metrics that are set out in the agreement so the more specific the agreement is the better it is really if you're
looking from a csr lens the more you'll be able to measure the performance of the company to see if you've met if you've met the the obligations under the agreement okay now you had mentioned the word csr so csr stands for corporate social responsibility right and so these are those esg and csr are two very well-known and very prominent terms in today's world specifically for mining so please
tell it our viewers the difference between esg and csr if there is sun so esg stands for environmental social and governance and and my understanding is that esg is more focused on having metrics and criteria to assess a company's performance whereas csr is more of an aspirational approach so if there are metrics through an esg approach it makes it much easier for investors to assess a company
and it makes it easier for a company to assess and improve its on its performance so whether or not you have an impact an impact benefit agreement could be a mechanism to help you meet your esg metrics right so an esg metrics could be metric could be what is your annual supply chain spend on indigenous businesses and if that is one of your metrics if your impact benefit agreement you
know says that your you has a whole section on procurement and how to help indigenous businesses understand procurement and be successful in procurement then your iba is lining up with your metrics your esg metrics so you know in my view anything that is clear and measurable would help a company to show its value and show that it is addressing any social risk that there may be
okay so you and i understand you've worked with on or rather on multiple ibas in the past so tell tell our viewers about where you think most mining companies usually get tripped up with the iba or either before the iba is signed or after the iba is actually as it's getting rolled out type of thing right well okay so before an iba is signed
you know the conversations are difficult conversations between during the the negotiations and it just takes for both parties a lot of patience and a desire to learn about the other and especially for mining companies to learn about indigenous culture and history and i think the companies that are most open to to learning about indigenous culture and on history and and listening to their
concerns are most you know likely going to complete their negotiations quicker so and i think you know just from where we come in as lawyers why would you want to get us involved it's to make sure that the agreements are clear i think you know you don't want it to be you want to focus on the relationship and and the the respect that's being developed
between the parties but it's very important that when the agreements are drafted they are clear we have seen agreements that have been drafted and then we come in you know in the implementation phase and we the agreement may be unclear there may not be a dispute settlement mechanism so the parties don't really have this as a tool to help them resolve their issues they may have different views about the agreement and
about important you know commitments so clarity of the agreement and also a simpler agreement there are certain things that you need to have but i think you don't want it to be put in a drawer and forgotten about you want it to be something that everybody is proud of and is working towards implementing yeah and i suspected that the best mining companies have this for the most part embedded
into the senior management viewpoints and i suspect right at the at the very board level right and as an investor if you were concerned about social risk there's a few questions that i would ask and they really go to the question of is this a corporate board level commitment to learning about indigenous rights and to continuing improving relations and so there you
know you would look to see whether the company has a board committee that's focused on social performance and in particular on a company's performance on indigenous employment and supply chain economics you know does the company have a board member who is experienced and has a positive social performance track record who has worked with indigenous people before does a company have an indigenous person on its board you know and finally one of the key
things to look for is whether is the company working with an independent external body to advise or evaluate their social performance and there's a couple that might be interesting for the listener a couple of these external bodies one is the canadian council for aboriginal business or ccab the ccab has a program called progressive aboriginal relations and here's another acronym par p-a-r a company can work with the ccab
to measure up against their par metrics and once they they do they become par certified so they're recognized as having progressive aboriginal relations you know another program is the mining association mac the max program towards sustainable mining and this is a tool that has a specific social indicators in its indigenous and community relations protocol that protocol encourages mining companies to work with indigenous communities to jointly develop track and
review metrics so there is that feedback loop of setting your metrics and then assessing to see how you're doing and i mean interesting about that towards sustainable mining program is that encourages mining companies to obtain free prior informed consent from potentially impacted indigenous people for any new project expansion and this free prior informed consent is a big issue it's a big thing people talk about indigenous people are really
interested in because it comes from an international document the un declaration on the rights of indigenous people yeah and this is not this is a document that canada has is is behind and canada has said they will implement and bc is starting to implement it but it's not law in ontario the un declaration reduces people or free prior informed consent but so this is where csr comes in this is
where you know the legal requirements and and corporate social responsibility or esg can can can come in even if it's not yet law but it is something that indigenous people are asking for and so the mac the map towards sustainable mining does incorporate it and does encourage it as best practices for their for the for the mines okay so you've talked a bit a lot about ibas
and you've talked about indigenous rights and stuff like this but ultimately when it comes down to it like a mining company has to want to engage in this so tell us why a mining company should engage in it like what are some of the pros and cons attached with you know doing this right well i said off the top that you know projects just don't really go
ahead don't get their permitting unless they have indigenous support in canada and you know a case what what can happen is you know if the mining company is not consulting and engaging with indigenous people their permit may be delayed or not be granted and this costs the bottom line considerably one exploration company in ontario that did not engage with indigenous people expected the crown to do it and the
crown didn't didn't do it either because they were looking to the company to do it suffered a hundred million dollars of additional project costs wow right so i do overrun right exactly no one wants to you know report to the board about that well and and obviously that's going to infect and rather affect investors as well so with overruns you know like you're you're either going to need to
spend revenue that could have actually gone back to the investors in some sort sort of dividend or in terms of retained earnings but ultimately it's it's not a good it's not a good thing to be to be doing well in fact we've seen investors who look for agreements they want to know does the company have agreements with indigenous communities and those are what we're talking about
the impact benefit agreements exploration agreements because they give the investor the the comfort that there's some regulatory certainty there is some measure of support and while there's always bumps on the road and there's you know going to be further challenges to implement the agreements at least they're starting from a point where the company has got the support or the consent of the indigenous communities to get started
okay and so williamson shire talk to us talk to us a bit about the firm how large is the firm and how how long has it been around so we have 18 lawyers and we've been around for 40 years we've been around since the environmental protection act was introduced in ontario it was started by two lawyers john wilms and donna shire donna donna is still practicing
environmental at the firm one of the partners and we you know all of our lawyers have scientific backgrounds we find that having a science background helps us to help our clients so for instance i went to the university of waterloo and i have a geology degree and so that helps that's great yeah it helps me and i enjoy it it allows me to stay a little bit current with the field
and and and still working in it to to some extent and how did you get into environmental law like what was your your your your your bright light decision on why you wanted to get into it well it goes back actually to when i was in high school and one of my one of the students in my class did a presentation on lake erie and
and talked about the problem of algal blooms in lake erie and at the time it was i mean we have other problems now in the great lakes but at the time it was identified as phosphates in detergents and so while lake erie in the 70s was declared dead with scientific work to identify that phosphates were the cause and then with binational cooperation between all the states bordering the
great lakes and ontario and quebec they managed to introduce policy and laws to remove to ban phosphates this was really probably one of the easier environmental problems to tackle certainly compared to climate change but what it what it inspired in me was an interest in science and policy and law and and the combination of all of them and how they work together so i started you know i started at
waterloo with the geology degree and then i graduated actually into a recession so jobs weren't that plentiful as you know what happens in with this in a cyclical industry so that just confirmed for me that i should go to law school and continue to work towards practicing environmental law okay and and then the whole connection with you know indigenous people on duty consult that only came around as i was
you know making my way through law school and afterwards when the supreme court enunciated the duty to consult so that wasn't really even an opportunity when i first went first thought about law school that happened more recently okay great so is there anything that else that you would like to to mention to our listeners well i just i think it's very fulfilling
and and companies and first nations who have good relations really get a lot out of it and it's worth it's worth the effort and to to learn about you'll learn about different cultures and and you know work towards having a good relationship it's it's good for the bottom line it's good for your you know for your your corporate morale and and just having good relations with
your neighbors really so it's it's rewarding if not a a difficult task at times for sure oh i agree it's 100 rewarding but i want to thank you for your time today i'm here today with just to recap with julie abushar who is with wilms and shire who are environmental lawyers based in toronto with offices in calgary yellowknife and ottawa as well
and what is the company website address wilmshire.com wilmshires.com okay so you can you can get get a hold of julie there and once again thank you my name is philip shum from the csc and we are reporting here during mining over canada and thank you very much thanks for listening thank you and thanks everybody thank you
you
More Mining Over Canada
Frank Holmes on the Millennial Impact on Mining SpeculationCSE Presents Mining Over CanadaDec 11, 2020
The Investment Opportunity in Mining w/ Frank Holmes, Rick Rule, and Adrian DayMining Over CanadaDec 2, 2020
