Canadian Securities ExchangeThe Daily Bell

Canada’s $300B ETF Question with Eli Yufest

November 7, 2026

About This Video

🇨🇦🇺🇸 Canada’s $300B ETF Question: What happens when the tsunami hits?

Canada’s ETF industry is growing rapidly—but how can it maintain that momentum as competition from the U.S. accelerates?

On this episode of the CSE Podcast, host James Black welcomes Eli Yufest, Executive Director of the Canadian ETF Association (CETFA), to explore the opportunities and challenges shaping the industry’s next chapter.

With Canadians holding approximately $300 billion in U.S.-listed ETFs, according to Yufest, the conversation examines what it will take to keep investment activity here at home.

“All we’re asking for is to level the playing field with the American system.”

- Eli Yufest, Executive Director, Canadian ETF Association (CETFA)

In this episode:

The coming wave of U.S. ETF share classes and what it could mean for Canada’s ETF industry.

The tax and regulatory changes CETFA is advocating for to strengthen Canadian competitiveness.

The proposed Maple Investment TFSA and how it could encourage Canadians to invest more at home.

Watch the full episode for a closer look at the forces shaping Canada’s ETF market and the ideas that could help it thrive.

For more information about the Canadian ETF Association, visit www.cetfa.ca.

Read the TranscriptAuto-generated by YouTube; names and terms may be misspelled.

Welcome back to another episode of the Canadian Securities Exchange podcast. And today, I am joined by Ellie UFest, the executive director at CEFA, the Canadian ETF Association. Ellie, we got a lot to talk about today, but thanks for joining me. >> Thanks for having me. >> No, my pleasure. And I think just to start today's discussion, let's just table set. What what are you doing at CEFA? And what is the mission there?

What what is your your grand role there? >> Well, in a nutshell, the mandate, the objective of the Canadian ETF Association is to promote the adoption and sustainability of the Canadian ETF industry. I'll take a step back and I'll give you a bit of context about what the association is, who our members are. We represent all aspects of the ecosystem. So everything from the fund managers to custodians,

the exchanges like you guys, even the service providers, the lawyers and auditors that help support the business. All in, we represent approximately 96% of the almost $1 trillion in ETF assets under management here in Canada. >> Yeah, and you just said 1 trillion, which is a it's a big number. That was a recent high watermark reached by the industry. You know, the ETF industry in its own right has sort of surpassed the the

single stock or the equities business that is kind of the bread and butter here at CSE, but we've just moved into the ETF industry with our first two ETF listings this past summer. Thank Long time coming. But I I want to ask, you know, it's an industry that seems to be growing in leaps and bounds. There's certainly more ETFs being listed than there are single stocks, but you know, you've talked recently in some

of your position papers about some of these threats to the industry in Canada in particular. You've warned about a tsunami coming from the US as ETF share classes launch there. So what is this threat that you've alluded to and and maybe just put more detail around what we're up against with US ETFs influx. >> Sure. So, before I get into that, maybe I'll just sort of say that the industry

is growing to your point, James, 15 20 25 30% month over month, year over year. The fund managers are doing a great job by meeting investors with products and services that they're looking for. The capital markets groups are coming to the table by by producing the actual units of of of the of the funds. The custodians, everyone in the industry is coming together to meet, you know,

consumer demand. And I'll give a bit of context about what that means. You know, the industry is launching about one to two ETFs every single day in Canada. we've got over 2,000 ETFs. Just to juxtapose it cuz I know we're going to be talking about the US ETF share class, to juxtapose that, the US has about 5,000 ETFs. >> Right. >> And so if we're looking at, you know,

the the the typical 10 to 1 ratio that Canadians often compare themselves to when they compare themselves to the US, you know, the US should have in theory 20,000 ETFs, right? So, we're at 2,000, the US would have 20,000, but they've only got about five. And so I guess my point is that Canadians are very very well served by the products available to them, by the ETF products available to

them. Canada is well over indexed in terms of products, asset classes compared to the US. and so we have to as an industry figure out, okay, how do we maintain this momentum? How do we keep the momentum going? you know, and I'll I'll say actually one more thing. One in four Canadians actually now own an ETF. So, 24% of Canadians, according to our research,

own an ETF. Earlier this year, that number was 20%. So, just ETF ownership in the the course of 2026 has grown 20%, right? from from 20 to 24%. So, I I guess I guess the point I'm making in all that is we have a tremendous amount to be you know, when when we look at the industry, we have a lot to be thankful for. We have a

lot to be grateful for. The industry is doing a great meeting investor needs. However, there's a tremendous amount of headwinds, and now I'll go back to your your question about the ETF. >> The tsunami, yeah. >> There there is a tremendous headwinds that the association is trying to curtail, trying to to to fix before it actually becomes an issue. And I'll I'll tell you what I mean. So I just said

that there's almost a trillion dollars in assets under management here in Canada. In addition to that, the Canadian investor holds approximately 300 billion with a B, 300 billion in US listed ETFs. So about 30 cents of every dollar that a Canadian owns in an ETF is held outside of our ecosystem. Okay, and so when that happens and you know, this is this is what I tell every stakeholder that I meet, when that

happens, no one in the Canadian industry is a beneficiary of that. No exchange, no custodian, no capital markets group, no fund manager, no government revenue, no jobs. It's all held outside of our ecosystem. And so we're already seeing 30 cents of every dollar invested outside of our ecosystem. And so if you sort of forecast that trend in 15 or 20 years, if we don't fix the structural issues

that are plaguing the Canadian marketplace, we could see a hollowing out of our industry. >> Yeah, not not unlike what's already happened with equities to some degree on the high end. You know, Canada is well protected from a policy and cost perspective [snorts] on the lower tier, you know, I could say small cap and small to medium enterprise type companies, right? But as you get bigger, certainly the US has this pole, you

know, the big US national exchanges, Nasdaq, Nyse. Now we see Texas and they're not they're not trying to cater to small companies either. So we we can definitely feel that and see that. Well, okay, so let's talk about just some of the matters at hand then with with what can make Canada more competitive. And you called out for a few things, but one of them is a removal

of GST and HST on management fees. And I mean, again, taxes can get in the way of a lot of good things, but in this case, and then we don't have to get too technical about it, but what is it about the tax system in Canada versus what's being applied in the US that puts us at a disadvantage? >> So the association has made public by

way of pre-budget consultations and submissions that we've made to the federal government around some of the tax and regular regulatory changes that we'd like to see here in Canada too. And all we're asking for is to level the playing field with the American system. So to your point, there is a there is an allure, there's an attraction that the American system, the American ecosystem has. And I get it. It's big.

it's liquid. but there's also some tax benefits to that. And I'll just sort of name a few of them. HST is just one of them. So when when when a Canadian buys a Canadian listed Canadian domiciled ETF, they have to pay HST on management fees. The US does not have that. In fact, I believe that that Canada is the only jurisdiction in the world to charge sales taxes on

management fees. So even if our fund managers are doing a great job from a fee perspective and they're level set or they're in line with with their American counterparts, we're always going to be structurally 13% more expensive. >> Mm. >> there is withholding tax issues that we're trying to fix. Canadian domiciled ETFs that invest in the same type of assets as their American equivalents that would be listed in the US would

have an automatic 15% withhold tax if held in an RRSP, in in a registered account. If that Canadian were to buy in their registered account in the US, there is no 15% withhold tax. So Canadians then by by default would be better off to just buy directly from the US because there's no there's no there's no withhold tax. The number one thing that we're trying to fix is actually allocation to

redeemers. That's another sort of tax treatment that was changed in 2019, implemented in the 2022 budget. And that is without a doubt the the the number one thing that the association is is focused on. That's the number one thing that we're talking to governments about. That needs to change. And in a nutshell, this is the issue. >> Yeah. >> And I'll use you as an example, James. You and I own the same ETF. You make

$100 in capital gains and you decide, you know, I'm going to sell, right? And so the way the CRA now attributes that capital gains is they'll now instead of allocating the capital gains tax to you, James, they're going to allocate so they're going to allocate it to the fund. And then the fund will then attribute some of that capital gains to you. And all the remaining unit holders like

myself and others are going to be hit with your capital gains tax bill. Now, nowhere in the world does that make sense. It probably doesn't even exist in countries like North Korea and Cuba, right? And so the the the point that I'm trying to make when I speak to federal stakeholders is an investor expects that when they buy an ETF and when they sell it, they will get hit with the capital gains. They do

not expect to get hit with the capital gains for something that they did not do, for something that they did not sell, and they shouldn't be paying other people's capital gains. And so these are just a you know, a few examples of of some of the tax issues that we're citing to the government, that we're telling the government that we need to adjust if we want to try to repatriate

or keep our money here in Canada and prevent it from flowing back to the US. And let me let me just circle back just very quickly if I could to the ETF share class. So the Canadians and and and I believe anyone else outside of the US never had access to American mutual funds, right? But the nature of an exchange traded fund of an ETF is that it now

grants access, very easy access to anyone including Canadians, right? Anywhere in the world, right? >> and that unlocks yeah, all sorts of things, yeah. >> Correct. And so if you think about you know, the American mutual fund industry, Canadians never had access to it. And so some of the most successful funds in the history of the funds world were never accessible to Canadians. Now as they convert from mutual funds to to an

ETF share class that means now Canadians and and everyone in the world will now have access to these to these funds whereas you know a few years ago they never had access to it. So the Vanguard patent that was held by Vanguard expired a number of years ago. There's now approximately now this number changes approximately 115 US fund managers that have filed for exemptive relief. 99 have received

approval. 18 have already filed prospectus and so this is this process is happening where you know American fund managers are starting to convert some of their mutual funds to this ETF share class which will now give everyone in the world access to some of these funds and so if we think that $300 billion is a lot to lose in our economy we're asking the government to change our

tax and regulatory system to level the playing field, keep our money here in Canada because once Canadians get access to these funds 300 billion might in hindsight look like a small amount when we when we look back a few years from now. >> Yeah I mean if the interest rate ever gets better too exchange rate I should say going and investing in the US might even be more attractive so so there is a bit

of a speed bump there is there not like you'd have to buy a US fund in US dollars or >> Sure if you're investing in the US you'd have to but you know putting aside the currency risk of the the you know there there there are things that we're asking the federal government to do to let's prevent this money from flowing to the US. There's jobs at stake, there's tax

revenue at stake, there's you know if you think about it there's no regulatory oversight. Once a Canadian exits our our industry there's no regulatory oversight and so if something goes sideways in the US and Canadians are left holding the bag I'm not sure that they're going to have much success calling the SEC and saying hey can you help me out here because the SEC's obligations are going to be to

Americans. They're not going to really care about it. So I guess I guess there's there's a lot of reasons why we need to fix our our system but also I'll just sort of put this out there investors excuse [clears throat] me and advisors need to be careful when they invest in the US because there's no regulatory oversight that that you know that could protect them unlike if they were to keep

their money here in Canada. >> Yeah, no, it's capital. There's always a competition for it and you got to you got to incentivize the tax. It's just one of the the many things. let's talk about this next point which you have with the Maple Investment TFSA. So everyone has a TFSA. I I would imagine who's watching this or knows of TFSAs, but what is a Maple Investment

TFSA and what what does it do for an investor that that's investing in ETFs? >> So the TFSA I believe is one of the best sort of savings or investment tools in Canadian history or if it's not the best, it's among the best. and for good reason, Canadians will invest in there and will be able to shelter their their money from from from taxes as as as it grows. Amazing.

However, we know that approximately 50% of Canadians hold cash in their TFSA, right? And so when it holds cash, it doesn't do the economy any good. It doesn't even do the investor any good. In fact, the investor is actually losing, let's call it 3% a year just just simply because of inflation. >> Mhm. >> and so that's sort of point number one. So 50% depending on some forecast, it's

actually up to 60%. So you know that that 50% number could be an understatement of the actual amount that's that's held in in in cash. So that's a that that's issue number one. Issue number two, because of this 300 billion that's gone down to the US, what we're telling the federal government is two things. Let's incent Canadians to repatriate some of that money. Let's incent Canadians to stem the flow to the US and

let's create a TFSA where if they invest in Canadian listed, Canadian domiciled ETFs, stocks, bonds, mutual funds, the government will match dollar for dollar up to $1,000 for Canadians earning $90,000 or less. And so this account will do two things. It'll hopefully encourage the 60 50% of Canadians that are holding their money as cash to invest it. So, we're calling it the Maple Investment TFSA to to to be

a trigger or a cue to investors to actually invest the money and not hold it as probably what they're what what they think it is, which is just a savings account or a high high interest savings account. And it'll encourage Canadians to repatriate the money. And it signals by the federal government that they're with investors, they're with Canadians. We know Canadians aren't saving for retirement. We know they're not saving

for the future. So, that will be a signal from the federal government that we're with you. We're going to put our money where where where our mouth is. We want you to save. We want you to invest. And here's $1,000 matched dollar for dollar if you invest. This program is not that that dissimilar to an RESP. If you put money into an RESP, the government matches I believe it's 20%

up to up up to a certain amount. So, the Canadian government, the federal government has all sorts of tax programs and incentive programs for education, for home buyers plan, the TFSA. So, this this is just another sort of avenue to encourage Canadians to keep their money here in Canada, repatriate the 300 billion back to Canada. And so, we're we're actually very very happy with with the idea and

we're hopeful that that the federal government is listening and they'll be able to implement it. >> Okay. So, all of this again from the perspective of the industry as it is today, but as I mentioned [snorts] you know, we we just listed our first two and and our constituent on the listing side is primarily small medium enterprises, companies in the mineral industry, exploration, technology, you know, things that are

you know, relatively near startup. So, where do these guys all fit in when it comes to the world of ETFs? So, are we are you do you envision a world with all these products where we see more of these smaller companies and younger companies get included in some of these baskets? I know you mentioned one of the providers in our pre-chat they do a lot of thematic investment.

you know, do you see a role for the the small cap in the ETF world or is this just going to be the domain of the the larger, more established issuers. Cuz I guess one of the things I'm observing is we've got all these new ETFs, but you need underlying securities as well. And at some point there's going to be too much of a divide, I think. But what

what are your thoughts on that? >> Well, the short answer is why not? I I guess, right? You know, like the the Canadian industry has 52 fund managers. and like I said at the onset of our conversation, there's literally something for everyone, right? There's every type of asset class, there's every type of ETF that that's imaginable. And this thing changes every single day. Fund managers are very, very responsive

and very receptive to to changing investor needs and wants. and so I mean, why why couldn't a fund manager, if the demand was there, wrap some of these smaller companies, mining companies, oil and gas exploration, you know, whatever it is with an ETF wrapper? I mean, I'm not a fund manager, so you know, maybe I'm oversimplifying the process. But I don't I don't see why not, right? you know,

if if there's investor demand for it and there's potential upside, which is what every investor looks for, why wouldn't a fund manager you know, create funds with with those with those assets in there? >> Yeah. I mean, risk is probably the big one. Do risk it, but that is why you bundle them and >> Yeah. >> the other one is liquidity. So a lot of these issuers were have to be have

a certain amount of free trading stock or some some form of proven liquidity, I would think, before the the managers dive in. But yeah, I mean, we we've had talks with with people who are interested in this side of it. And I think you're right. I think it's a matter of time. And we've, like I said, just entered the the whole ETF era for the CSE, and we're just

getting started. So I'm sure there'll be more on that. okay. Well, you've got all these great policy ideas. but what what's what's the path forward for you guys? How do you connect with Ottawa and how do you get them to pay attention? I mean, this government seems particularly interested in in being more self-sufficient and trying to make a regular Canadian have a better shot at

of generating some wealth, but you know, taxes are hard to undo things like that. So, how do you how do you find your path forward with Ottawa? >> Well, what I say is I'm I'm in Ottawa several times a year, probably actually more often than that, and I have very regular virtual meetings with stakeholders in Ottawa. The good news is that this government, this new government I think I can still call them new.

They're relatively new. >> it still feels fresh, I guess. >> It still feels fresh. Our great stakeholders. They're very willing to listen to us. They're very willing to meet with us, and every time we're in Ottawa or every time we do a virtual meeting, they show up, which which is which is awesome. I think this new government gets it. I think they have sent many signals that suggest that they're here for Canadians,

they're here for investors. They they want to make they want to make Canada, let's call it, more independent and more self-reliant, and I think there's been numerous signals that that suggest that. However, there are a million things that the federal government needs to think about. We're just one of the million, right? And so the way that we engage them is is is very simple, I think. We have models

that suggest the benefits of doing, for example, the Maple Investment TFSA. There's tremendous economic upside when Canadians repatriate this $300 billion or some of this $300 billion. What could the tax upside be? What could the economic benefit be? What could the investor savings and outcomes be? And so we've modeled all of that out with the help of Statistics Canada modelers and and economists and statisticians, which is which is great.

And now we just have to keep engaging them. And so, you know, even if we don't get an immediate, you know, let's call it a win or response, I don't know if response is the right word because they always respond to us, which is like I said, great. But you know, you know, we keep fighting and and we keep we keep promoting and we keep talking about our

ideas and we keep advocating. And so, you know, we just have to keep, we just have to keep on keeping. >> Yeah. Yeah, no, good, good point. And I mean, you you are represented and supported by most of if not all the major financial institutions in Canada now cuz everyone's, you know, doing ETFs. But to that end, I think you've got a you got a a really good group behind

you. for people who want to connect with CETFA, you guys just built and launched a new website which has some great features. Maybe just talk about that real quick. >> Sure, sure. so this is actually something that we just did this year. very proud of it. So thank you for for taking note, James. complete redesign of our brand, complete redesign of our website. something that we didn't

talk actually at all about, but one of the pillars of of CETFA is education. So advisor investor education. And we've got some amazing tools on our on our website that maybe I'll just spend a second talking about. So we have sort of two tabs or two sections of our website. If if you go to our website, cetfa.ca. there's the ETF comparison tool and this tracks all 2,000 plus ETFs in

Canada. And it has, I would say, most of the relevant, meaningful information that an advisor or or an investor would want to know about that ETF. And the tool allows advisors or investors to compare funds, look at you know, performance, look at the history, look at what the funds are about, etc. etc. And so we're actually very very proud of that tool. That's that's a you

know, a new aspect of our website that we just created just a couple months ago. We're getting tremendous traction with it. We're getting, you know, hundreds of views every single day, which is which is awesome. The other thing that I'll I'll mention is we have an insights section of our of our website where we've got a number of the banks research published there. We publish our own research there. Any

thought leadership sort of papers, white papers, any information from our members that is relevant to advisors, relevant to investors that we think would, you know, help them in their investing journey, we publish there. And if advisors or investors are interested in getting monthly updates from us, we do have a newsletter. Just go onto our website, sign up for our newsletter, and we'll be able to send some of this information

out and some of this insights out as as it comes out. You'll be the first or investors or advisors, whoever signs up will be will be the first to know about it. >> Awesome. Yeah, it's it's all good and I want to congratulate you again on the progress thus far on the new site. I myself am involved with you guys now and and the CSE is a member, so we're proud

to be members of CEFA. For those watching today, that's Eli Uufest, the executive director at CEFA, that's the Canadian Exchange Traded Fund Association. For more information about the organization, their website is linked below. And for more CSE content podcast, just don't forget to subscribe. If you're on LinkedIn or YouTube, this is where we broadcast most of our content. Thank you for for for that in advance. Thank you again for watching. Thank you,

Eli. It was a pleasure having you here today. >> Likewise. Thanks very much.