About This Video
Mining Over Canada Sponsor Panel - Go Public! Our veteran "go public" team of Ian Mitchell of Gowling WLG Jenna Kaye of Odyssey Trust, Maruf Raza of MNP LLP, and the CSE's own Anna Serin and Rob Theriault break down the A to Z of going public in the mining sector.
Subscribe for more great CSE insights and interviews here: https://bit.ly/CSETVSubscribe
STAY CONNECTED WITH THE CSE
=============================
- PODCAST: https://blog.thecse.com/pe-podcasts/
- INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/canadianexchange/
- LINKEDIN: https://ca.linkedin.com/company/canadian-securities-exchange
- FACEBOOK: https://www.facebook.com/CanadianSecuritiesExchange/
- TWITTER: https://twitter.com/CSE_News
- BLOG: https://blog.thecse.com/
- WEBSITE: https://thecse.com/
MB011AUPAHZLPNM
Read the TranscriptAuto-generated by YouTube; names and terms may be misspelled.
welcome to mining over canada join the canadian securities exchange and our partners in a first-hand look into our country's vast mining landscape hi my name's anna sarin i'm director of listings development with the canadian securities exchange today i am joined by our sponsor sponsors for mining over canada we have gowling's mnp odyssey trust and my own colleague rob tario with the listings department at csc we're going to be talking about going
public and everything that you need from a to z in the go public process whether that's ipo or rto and we're also going to discuss the intricacies of what needs to happen to get ready as well as what happens once you're public we're going to start off today with ian mitchell he is a partner at gellings thanks so much for joining us ian thank you anna and thank you to the csc
for organizing this as anna said my name is ian mitchell i'm a partner at gal and wg wlg which is a global firm with offices across canada the uk europe and in china we're very focused on the mid-market and we're very active in mining and so we're very happy to be involved and to be here today my practice involves companies ranging from pure exploration plays to producing companies
dealt with all of the issues in between there we have a team in place to deal with anything that may come up from financing construction permitting regulatory environmental and indigenous issues so i had to be involved in this initiative and look forward to working with mining companies going forward so our role in the growing public process as a law firm is to be one of your key advisors so
moving from a private relatively unregulated existence to a public highly regulated existence can be a challenge and it's important that you get the right team in place to do that and we'll hear from a roof at mnp and gen ed odyssey and obviously the cse who are all parties who are going to help you to get through that process early on you want to think about sort of what your structure is going
to be and where you want to end up and we're going to help you talk through that and some of the things you're going to need to think about from a legal perspective are are you going to do this by way of initial public offering are you going to take your existing company and turn it into the public company are you going to look at a reverse takeover
which is finding a shell and then merging your company with the shell or ending up with your company becoming a sepolian subsidiary of that shell and a number of different issues will play into that where your shareholders are located for example if your shareholders are in some jurisdictions the tax treatment is going to vary and so we'll want to pay attention to this to make sure you don't
have any unexpected hiccups at the end of the day where your shareholders are unhappy with what you're doing we'll take a look at what documents you're going to need to prepare to do that you may need a prospectus which is a disclosure document that is reviewed by the regulatory authorities and i'll touch on what's included in that a little bit later when i talk about the form2a listing statement
because they cover a lot of the same areas or you might need a circular depending on if there's a corporate transaction that requires shareholder approval you may need you know and you may you may you may not need either of those you may be able to do it by way of share exchange depending on the circumstances so it's really important to talk to us early in the process to
try and map out your plan in addition we're also going to talk about whether you need financing obviously one of the reasons you're moving into the public market is to take advantage of the capital markets and so if you want to raise money we're going to need to talk about how you want to structure that where that fits in can we do that on a private placement basis does it need to be done
on a prospectus basis and all of that will affect some of the decisions you make the other really important thing to think about in moving public is do you have the right team in place do you have the right management do you have the right directors do you have a qualified person in qp and i'll touch on that a little bit later in my discussion and this is really
important because i can't stress enough how important it is to have a cfo who has public company experience a lot of your reporting moving forward will center around financial matters and marouf will touch on that but having someone who understands that is very important and then also making sure that you have enough independence on your board so your board can't just be all of your management team we're going to want
to look at that there are rules around independence especially related to audit committee and financial literacy so we're going to talk about all those things just to make sure you have the right team on board to make your listing a success and when i say that i'm not talking about removing people i'm usually talking about supplementing and adding so from a csu perspective your main listing document is your listing
statement which is a form 2a and this is this this is a disclosure document which tells the story of your company it's very similar to a prospectus in that it can it needs to contain full true and plain disclosure about your company it's you telling your story to form the basis for your public record moving forward and then all of your disclosure after that will supplement it
and so we're going to work through things like what's your corporate structure how did your business develop a snapshot of your financial position we're going to look at your capitalization talk about your principal shareholders your directors officers compensation material contracts and obviously in mining the most important part of your material projects in moving to a public environment transparency is key and it's important to remember and this can be a slightly odd concept for people
who don't work in public markets that an omission to state a material fact is also a misrepresentation which attracts liability so as much as people only want to talk about the good things you want to make sure that you have a balanced picture of your company and the best way to do that is for you to sort of be on top of anything that you think may be a negative and we'll work with
you to help frame those in the best way possible in your disclosure the last item i want to touch on briefly before turning it over to marouf for financial statements is national instrument 43101 so the securities regulators in canada have put together a framework under which disclosure for all scientific and technical information must be completed 43101 is always talked about in the context of reports as talked about globally 43 101 reports
everyone talks about them even in jurisdictions other than canada but what i always find it's important to remind people is that 43101 governs all of your disclosure so websites social media press releases corporate presentations anything that includes scientific and technical information needs to comply with 43101 and so it's really important to remember that but from a listing perspective when you're first starting out this is pretty easy to tackle because you'll
have so many advisors looking at everything that that's not going to get missed and your main document is going to be a report so you need a report for each of your material projects and that has to be prepared by an independent qualified person and a qualified person if you're not familiar with it is someone with the right education experience and ethics and so really this means a geoscientist
or an engineer with at least five years of experience relevant to the project and they have to be a member of a recognized professional association and that person will put together a report in the form required by 43-101 in respect of your project and this is this is this is required because it provides consistent disclosure across mineral projects you get the same categories of information sort of across the field which is what
investors and regulators want to see to be able to make decisions and i always remind people that you know although it's a 43-101 report they come in all different shapes and sizes so you can have a 43-101 report for an exploration project that doesn't talk about resources or reserves all the way up to a feasibility study which has detailed information that demonstrates why this project is economically mindable and extraction can
be justified and for a listing you don't need to have a full feasibility study it's perfectly fine to have something at the early stages but you're going to want to make sure that there's at least a hundred thousand dollars in expenditures there that's one of the listing criteria i think rob will touch on this a little bit later and don't not all qps are created equal not all
reports are created equal there's a cost to going public people don't like to talk about it but you want to make sure you have good advisors upfront because the only thing that's going to cost you more is having a bad report or having bad advisors at the outset because you're gonna have to fix that you're gonna have to fix that before you go public people are gonna notice it
people are gonna catch it and it's just it takes way more time and effort to fix something later rather than just having it done right in the first place and the only other thing i'll say quickly about 43 101 at the end here is be really careful about what you say if you're not used to this for example if you make a public press release about a resource on a project that maybe
you required or on your project and you don't have a technical report lined up you're gonna have to file a technical report within 45 days of that press release so you know you don't want to get yourself caught in a circumstance where you can't comply so it's important to think ahead and to consult your advisors before you sort of make any decisions or any disclosure of a scientific
you know or technical nature and now i will turn it over to maroof to touch base on financial matters thank you very much for that you brought up some really great points the first thing i wanted to bring up because i answer this question a lot first of all the the csc doesn't have a shell program what is a shell right yes sorry so when i say a shell
company taking this back to basics i mean a company and it doesn't have to be listed on the on the csc you can take a shelf from wherever but it's a company that has previously been listed or has reporting issuer status so in canada we frequently talk about listed companies but being a public company in canada has two components largely being a reporting issuer which is what
the secure which which is what the securities commissions refer to so when you file a prospectus you become a reporting issue in each jurisdiction which you file the prospectus and we're provincially regulated so you have to follow multiple places if you want to be a reporting issue in multiple jurisdictions and then on top of that you have to list so technically you could be a public company without a listing but
when we talk about a reverse takeover and finding a shell what we mean is a company that has already completed that part of the process so it's already a reporting issuer in at least one jurisdiction and usually has distribution which means they usually have some shareholders public shareholders out there because one of the other listing criteria rob will talk about i suspect is your distribution and so what you're looking for
is a company that has previously been or is still a public company and previously had a business but no longer has a business and so what you're going to do is take take advantage of their reporting issuer history and their distribution combine it with your business and then move that and list and then that will be the new the new listed company thank you that's pretty important note for people to understand
and this is where rtos i think really you know gain their traction is especially in the exploration space because if you have a property you go and do a drill program and you don't get the results that you were hoping for you're now left with a publicly traded vehicle and it's time to go find something else and and that's really quite often what we refer to as people trying to
build shareholder value so the property that we have doesn't have the resource that we're looking for so let's go and try and bring something else in and create that shareholder value so thank you very much for explaining that yeah i also wanted to touch on as you talk about your team of advisors and and this does come up a lot as well especially in the small cap space
you know the importance of having these professionals help you in this process and and everyone that's joining us today is is almost you know i you wouldn't want to go public without everyone that's at this table today these are the advisors that you need to have but my question to you as legal counsel how early should a company be coming to you when they want to go public
so early months ahead of time it really depends some companies show up and they sort of know they need financial statements and they know they need a report and so they will have done a lot of that leg work but if companies haven't done that leg work then that's going to take months you know possibly to get that stuff in place so even if we don't spend a lot of time
with them at the outset if if you haven't sort of thought about it and you haven't put those things in place then you want to come you know months ahead of time like four or five six months ahead of time and say we want to get this done you know in the next six months we haven't done anything what do we need to do because depending on where you're you
know to do a technical report requires a site visit so you you know you have to be able to find people who can then get to site take a look at it with coven that's obviously more challenging you know than it was previously you know financial statements can take a while to get into place and then you may want to clean up your capital structure there may be changes you want to make sort of
ahead of time before you list to get that dealt with and so you know ideally if you've done nothing you know six months ahead of time if you're in great shape you already have audited financials you have a 43-101 then you know three months you know it could be sooner but it takes more time i think than people are aware to try and get their house in
order to make it a seamless process when you get to the listing point yeah absolutely one last question and it kind of touches on something that you brought up there i want to touch on the 43 101 just for a second because it is a critical element for going public in the mining space do you and i'm putting you on the spot here so i'm sorry if you don't know
this but can you describe why the 43-101 came into place because there was a very specific reason it became a regulatory requirement yeah so my understanding is that and more from from hearsay than from research is that this is this is largely a response to what were some scandals culminating in briefs that happened a number of years ago and the regulators decided that after that point we needed
to put in place a standardized system of reporting to try and create a playing field and a system that everyone understood and that provided some certainty some consistency and some reliability into the system and so that's sort of where this has evolved from that's a number of years ago now 43-101 is now recognized sort of glo globally as a standard because it does sort of put some rigor into what is otherwise sort
of a very mismatched mismatch system globally well and i i have that because it's very important for investors to know that this is put in to protect investors from fraudulent activity that happened in the past is there as a tool for investors and i i bring this important point up because people should look at it and take a look what the qualified person you know ascertains
in that report as far as what the valuation of that property is and what the potential work program should be on that property and if that company is actually executing that work program so you know these are resources that are available you know distribution wise it's available on multiple channels for investors so take a look at it and and does the does your legal counsel
have any involvement in the creation of the 43-101 or is it just a package that you use as part of your prospectus filing no and that's why i sort of said not all are created equally so right now we've been heavily involved in working through some issues in a 43-101 it it really depends i always want to review them and sometimes you know there's always something the forms of
certificate or something so always get your legal counsel to review it hopefully we don't have a lot to do and it's in decent shape but that's not always the case and you know as i said earlier you want you want to get that review done earlier because if you leave it until you get to the listing and all of a sudden you get you know a 16 page comment letter you're not 16
but i've seen five page comment letters on 43 101s you know you then are back to square one and you may be a couple of months while you sort that out with your qp so it's always best to get us to take a look at it and even if i can't tell you what the answer is from a geological or engineering perspective depending what the issue is i can say this disclosure is not
consistent with the level of disclosure we've seen in the past or we think you're missing this section or you know this part needs beefing up and we can at least provide guidance and highlight the area so you can have the discussion with the qp again my hope is always that you know it's in decent shape and we don't have to do anything but another set of eyes is always
useful and we look at it from a different perspective than the geologist will we'll very much look at it we'll put the form up we'll take a look at it and then we'll take a look there's obviously guidance for certain issues on when you can use a pa to re-scope like there's specific securities commission guidance on some issues and so we may pick up some issues that the qp may not
have picked up on depending on what their experience is in the past as well wonderful well thank you enough from information the one last i want to make is that a 43-101 doesn't live forever so these need to be updated i'll let robterio touch on what is considered stale dated and not but these are not documents that live forever so if it was done you know several years back there
will be updates that are required ian thank you so much i really appreciate it you know ian works in in in securities with gowling's and you want to make sure that you always have legal counsel when you're going public this is not something that you want to do without so thank you very much ian you know obviously you know your stuff and we
really appreciate that you've been such a big partner in mining over canada so thank you again i'm gonna i'm gonna bring roof up to talk about the joys of financial reporting next thanks ian thanks roof my friend and colleague marouf raza is with mmp he's a partner and he will talk to us about the joys of auditing and financial reporting in the go public process thanks marouf
thanks anna the many joys of auditing not really but you know we'll get into it anyway thanks again and and yeah just a quick introduction to m p you know we're we're a canada white firm you know 70 offices across across the country i head up the public markets group here and we obviously being in canada and being a firm in canada very heavy in in resources and
extractive industries and so it's it's terrific to see you know the comeback i think the comeback is official which i'm sure we'll we'll touch on later but as you know i think we you know as part of the process of the go public you know ian referred to you know the the legal documents that need to be filed and while primarily there's a lot of
legal information that goes into there some marketing a big chunk of that you know document involves involves the financial statements of the of the company and so there are some rules relating to what's needed for those financial statements so you know as a rule of thumb you generally need two years of audited financial statements that go into a prospectus or filing statement both years need to be audited
under ifrs so as in canada we apply international accounting rules so that's important if you're coming from outside of canada or you're coming from the private side where the rules are slightly different the public rules are ifrs generally it's a two-year requirement depending on i mean venture issuers are always two years you know if you go into one of the big boards it could be it could be three years in some cases
the audit requirements for historical financials could actually drop to one year you know depending on whether you meet certain junior issuer rules and typically that's if you're under 10 million in assets or revenues so that is we don't see that too often but if you are a smaller entity and and with a mining startup it's quite possible that that you know you may you may meet that
so always keep that junior issuer rule in mind because it is it is one year so the the financial statements are audited depending on the timing of the transaction depending on how far away you are from your natural year end you may also need to provide interim financial statements now those interim financial statements are not audited they are reviewed which is sort of one one level of sort of examination down so
it's a little bit easier to do the final statement that you should be aware of it's not always required but you know typically when you're doing a reverse takeover or you're doing some significant financings you would need to prepare a pro forma financial statement so performance statement it's not a projection it's not like oh you know i'm going to make this much revenue and i'm going to have this
much expenses it's not a pro forma in that context it is basically a representation of what the deal would look like had it come together today and so for example if you're doing a reverse takeover what the performance statements would show is what is the combination of the of the of the shell that we refer to earlier and this target company that we're that we're going public with it's not audited or
reviewed but as an auditor we would take a look at it just for reasonableness but it's so it's it's it's a much lower threshold down of course each of these financial statements are accompanied by mdna so management discussion and analysis which is half compliance where the security the securities legislations have very specific items you have to put in there and have sort of a little bit free form
where you can describe the company what you're doing a little bit of marketing involved we don't as those are not audited or reviewed however as as auditors we do tend to read through just to make sure there's nothing inconsistent with with anything that we are aware of but that again is primarily a management document that and in fact that i think lawyers are the legal counsel team is also
pretty pretty involved with one thing to note you know primarily because you know in terms of your auditors or or hiring auditors one of the things to note is that a lot of mining deals tend to come into canada from foreign jurisdictions from a canadian perspective once you're public there is a requirement that your auditors have to be registered under the canadian public accountability board so they don't have to necessarily
be canadian right but they do have to be registered under what we call cpap and so that is a requirement under under securities law so so just keep that in mind in case some of the legacy history is audited by foreign advisors so the really key areas to to just be watchful for you know in terms of the financial statement requirements i mean look the statements are not cumbersome
particularly with mining i think we need we should separate you know obviously you know we have mining that's in production and mining that's you know at an exploration or development level very very different types of financial statements that come out of that so the vast majority of venture type deals that go on the csc for an example are typically exploration level companies those financial statements are relatively easier to audit because there
has not been a tremendous amount of activity there hasn't been a tremendous amount of revenue or any revenue it's really money being spent towards a development exercise so the key areas there just to be wary of is you know looking at equity transactions because as we know in mining lots and lots of equity transactions equity transactions for compensation equity transactions for property acquisitions so just understanding the valuation on
those on those items is key that's something the regulators will look at and question so really honing in on on on on that area and then one of the main areas is all the expenditures that you're you're spending there's a big discussion on whether you capitalize them which is put them on your balance sheet or you expense them from an accounting perspective you actually have the option to do either most companies tend
to throw them on the balance sheet some companies for simplicity put just expense them all the way through the p l immediately so that's always a policy choice that you need to make up front certainly when you get out of the more development stage entities and going into operating companies that are actually in production of much much more you know detailed audit requirements because you're auditing inventory you're auditing
stockpiles on auditing asset retirement you know and site restoration costs so those audits can tend to be more cumbersome and so just from a time perspective when people say well how long well it really depends are you just in exploration which can be done pretty quickly versus are you you know further along the development chain which which will you know put a put a different time element into it
so common roadblocks to just just keep in mind you know always be aware of stale dated financial statements so if you know if your if your transaction is drawing out your your historical audits your historical reviewed statements interim statements may have become stale dated so you may need to update that so keep that keep that in mind i think one of the ultimate things is just you know making sure that we include the
the the csc or the securities commission early in the process if there's anything funky or if there's anything you know like if there's any foreign assets always good to have a discussion up front to make sure we're we're not we're not missing anything from the perspective of the of the regulator that's great thank you so much move i mean obviously there is so much that goes into the financial
reporting element of it and they really you know need to come to you as quickly as they can there's a few questions that come up for me on a regular basis i thought we could touch on and firstly i just wanted to point out one thing that you brought up a few times that's really important for people to understand there is a very big difference between
an exploration company and a mining company so when we talk about the mining sector and mining companies you know there is a very large proportion of those are that are actually exploration companies so those are companies that are looking to find you know a resource and and then you know the ideally the exploration companies would then if they found something they'd sell it to one of
typically one of the senior companies that has the operational logistical capacity to be able to execute the actual mine itself so i think that's important for people to understand sometimes is lost on them a little bit you also mentioned venture issuers and i just wanted to clarify when you talk about venture issuers that is a certain size of a company not necessarily an exchange it's we refer to venture chinese and senior
companies so just wanted to make sure i clarified that one as well the one of the big questions that i always get and i'd i'd love for you to clarify this what if what if i have a brand new property and i create a brand new corporation and i put this property into that corporation does that mean that it's free and clear of all of its past expenditures and i
don't need to get it audited it's a very good question and it and it it it can be a tricky question i think so the general answer is that if if two third parties are transacting and all i've acquired is a property or a bunch of claims right typically the legacy would not come into any any financial statement so the real question is do i need to go back and somehow extract
that legacy and present that to the public as part of my transaction so the answer is that typically with an exploration type property the answer would be no because you are usually getting a very singular asset now if that singular asset now starts taking on more of well i'm getting you know all of the equipment and i'm getting all of the employees and i'm getting now it sounds like i've actually bought
a business right so there's what the regulators consider a business test so if you if you are if you can if you're if you kind of demonstrate that you really bought a business rather than a singular asset it could trigger some of that history now coming in and so you you know you refer to you know companies that are exploration stage versus companies that are further along you know in production
typically you wouldn't see that in a in an early stage company right because you're typically as an exploration company you're going and buying another exploration stage asset whereas if you're acquiring a late stage company that says already in production which is the other extreme likely you're probably getting a business and you do need some history of legacy that that comes in well and that brings up a really good point so the second
part of this question is what if i have a property and i would like to use the past expenditures and rob tario will touch on this but there is priests expenditures that need to be sent on spent on a property before it can be used as a go public asset if i wanted to use somebody else's expenditures on that property then does that initiate the the need for an audit on
those expenditures so i think that so this is where we you know we would separate the securities requirement from the audit requirement so from an audit requirement perspective as any of that legacy to unless we're actually reporting on those financial statements would not come into the new company right the new company the starting point would be whatever i've paid for for that for that property the idea being that if there is value in
those legacy expenditures it would be reflected in my acquisition price now from a securities perspective i'll i'll probably let rob answer that but i think there are some nuanced differences between financials and and securities law here wonderful thank you so much it's always great to hear your your insight you're the most entertaining auditor that i know so i'm always happy to have you join me i'm going to introduce next jenna
k but marouf stay with us because we're going to start a roundtable discussion after this so thanks again thank you jenna kay for joining us jenna is president and co-founder sorry is it president or ceo ceo and co-founder of odyssey trust sorry about women ceos anna so thank you so much for joining us i think that the odyssey trust is a transfer agent and
i think people are less aware of the role of the transfer agent than probably they should because you play a very important role in the go public process and post public process so i'll let you talk a little bit about what the transfer agent does in this role absolutely well first of all thanks so much the cese for allowing us to co-sponsor this event we're really excited to be involved
with both mnp and gowlings as anna mentioned odyssey trust in the ceo and co-founder we are a trust and transfer agent we have offices across canada so we're vancouver calgary with co-agents in toronto and denver colorado we have about 400 clients that span a variety of industries and we've handled over 4 billion dollars in corporate trust transactions one of the reasons why we're so excited
to be involved in mining over canada is because mining companies are a huge huge part of our business when we originally started our team in vancouver is the previous management team of pacific corporate trust which is a company that's very well known to a number of mining issuers and we've been very lucky in in starting odyssey to have that support of those local mining companies and i think
they really value the aspects from super trust that that we bring so the expertise of a transfer agent the nimbleness and and cost effectiveness that we bring to the industry things i'm going to cover today so as anna mentioned i'm going to talk about the role of a transfer agent in a going public process i'm going to talk about the role of transfer agent
in the in an ipo versus rto scenario and then talk about a few specific things to ask your transfer agent as you're getting closer to going public so first of all when you're getting ready to go public the role of transfer agent ultimately we are the gatekeeper of your securities so ahead of going public you may have been managing your cap table on a spreadsheet
or with your legal counsel but as you're getting ready to go public this is a responsibility of an independent party your transfer agent so that's the main thing to know and then our role is really from there broken down into three different aspects so there's a client side a shareholder side and then an ancillary services side so for you as the client the things to know is once you engage a transfer agent
we are then responsible for all of your issuances and cancellation of of your cap table essentially we are are that gatekeeper we also have you know through that process we have a number of other roles so we're responsible for the compliance of your share register fintrac reporting aml anti-money laundering cost basis reporting in that role as a transfer agent we also do things like run your annual general meeting which
you'll have when you're a public company which includes proxy voting tabulation scrutineering organizing the printing mailing of your materials and generating any reports that you have and we also handle things like dividend payments if that comes comes later on down the line so from a client perspective we are your point of contact for anything that's happening with your cap table secondly on the shareholder side we now
become the the entity that will deal with your shareholders so the nice thing for an issuer is those questions don't have to come to you anymore they can then come directly to us so anytime shareholders have questions like re-registrations share transfers a loss in the state question trying to get access to their their shareholdings on on the web or they've lost their certificate those questions will come directly to us
again you will no longer have to be in in that process and the third aspect of our role is any ancillary ancillary roles that that you would need us for so things like acting as war and agent if you have a warrant class sub receipt agent if you're doing a raise debt trustee if you're doing a debt raise collateral agent so any of those ancillary roles we also
will manage for you so again you can kind of tell as you sort of formalize this the type of entity you are from being a private company to a public company there is quite a bit more administration happening on this side and we have systems in place to make that much more efficient for you so in the situation of an ipo versus an rto our role generally is is quite the
same really for an rto what when we're engaged what we try and look at very early on is who the shell company will be who is their existing transfer agent we may have to step in and move you to us ahead of the rto but i mean generally speaking both an ipo or an rto the setup and engagement of a transfer agent is very very seamless
and we have you know compared to i think some of the other groups being an auditor or legal counsel we really try and make our onboarding process seamless so that we can fit into your timeline when you need us to so really not much to say in terms of the difference between an ipo and rto but in both you will need a transfer agent and then the last thing i just wanted to
speak about quickly were a couple of specific things to ask your transfer agent when you first are bringing one on board as part of your deal team so one question is is your transfer agent also a trust company in canada most public companies use a trust company as your transfer agent because when you do things like a debt financing or a collateral agent or or another appointment down the line where you need
a trustee your transfer transfer agent will also act in that capacity and then secondly when you think about the plans of your company one question to ask is do they have an office in the u.s do they have exposure to the u.s because if you're looking at a co-listing later on that's something to consider the third is what type of ancillary services can your transfer agent provide so again when you're looking at your
your share structure you might be asking yourself do we have an employee plan is that something that our transfer agent can facilitate who's going to handle my cdr and set eye filings which are now going to be regular regulatory requirements can my transfer agent do that for me can they facilitate press releases can i consolidate those all in one place do they have a medallion guarantee at
their office is something that will probably be a new concept to you as a public company but in order to transfer securities from one shareholder to another you will need to provide from one registered shareholder to another you will need to provide a medallion guarantee to prove that the transferee is who the transferee is and some some transfers will provide that service for you and then fourth is how tech savvy is my
transfer agent so is there a platform that i can go on as the issuer and look at my shareholder register myself run any reports that i want to do you know look at my voting results online that's one question to ask also am i able to send my crs statements instead of share certificates to my shareholders via email how how focused on dematerialization is my transfer agent and i think companies
went public now really need to think about where the world on the capital markets in capital markets is turning and i think that is very much focused on dematerialization quickness efficiency of processing and you want a transfer agent who has that flexibility and the fifth thing is maybe speaking to the broker community so if you're doing a raise concurrent with your ipo talk to your broker and ask them you
know who do you guys work with as a transfer agent who who is easy to work with who has a strong back sort of securities and an operations group who can really help with processing and getting things done easily so those are some questions to ask and again our role when you look at it from an issuer standpoint we are going to be your point of contact
with all things relating to your cap table and any issuance and your agm and there will also be your point of contact for your shareholders going forward and we're also there for you for any ancillary services that you need from us oh that's so much information and that's so great because you guys you guys really do so much in this process and and i don't think
people know just how much the transformation sorry the transfer agent is involved in being a public company there's a few things i wanted to touch on with you one is you said the magic word that everyone says and it's it's like the pot of gold at the end of a rain rainbow the medallion guarantee let's talk about that for a second because everyone's looking for one
can we explain why someone would need it because this is very important in in kind of the issuance of stock certificates the medallion guarantee sure so i mean again it's like the difference here from a private issuer is you're engaging a transfer agent because that gives the market and your shareholders confidence that somebody is is watching closely what's happening with your securities and and you know that you're issued an
outstanding will always be correct and again just somebody who has a very robust system to facilitate that the medallion guarantees come into play because you essentially want to prevent fraud from happening so if i'm transferring a security to you anna we're not going to process that with just you know my name on a piece of paper and your name on a piece of paper and we go okay we're good to go
we need confirmation that i am the beholder of that security and that i am signing off on that transfer so modeling guarantee when you set up an appointment with us to come to our office we will ask you for your driver's license we will verify that you are the holder of the securities we will have a securities transfer form pre complete and once we satisfy those
requirements we can then process the transfer and really i mean it protects us from from processing something and making sure that that it is right and compliant but also protects the issuer because you want to make sure that your shareholders have a certain level of confidence in how they're actually transferring traffic security so it is a very common it is it is required for all
registered shareholders but not all transfer agents have one available at their office and particularly with our mining clients we are very very busy in providing medallion guarantees to facilitate those transfers quickly and easily so on that note the other question i have is what's your advice for a potential issue or when they're going public because a new system has obviously come in place over the recent years called
the drs system so can you touch a little bit on those two and what your advice is to issuers as they start going down this path which one to use sure so really i'd say up until i guess it has been 10 years ago when you were issuing securities you would issue them in paper form so people would get a yeah a piece of paper that they
would hold you know in their safe at home or in a deposit box at their bank sometimes under their mattress but once actually the trigger event to move to again dematerialization was hurricane sandy that hit new york and so it hit central depository and it actually flooded their their the basement of their building which then caused a loss of all these securities so they were all insured but you just
you just had a major problem and it caused people to really think about okay why are we forcing people to hold physical piece of piece of paper to represent their ownership and really as a result of that the world started to move to drs which is essentially there's a global book entry position that your transformation holds and then you get a printed statement to show what your ownership is
and the nice thing about that for your shareholders is that they can request from us a pdf copy of that statement anytime it's just like a broker statement that shows what you're holding there and they don't have to be worried about losing it and we really it would be a rare situation that we would issue physical securities anymore we really push drs for our clients and again
part of that is just for ease of their shareholders but also if you again if you lose it you don't have to pay an insurance bond to get your drs statement reissued it just gets reprinted and we're and off we go that's so interesting you know i was just thinking when you were telling that story i didn't know that story about hurricane sandy and it's just interesting there's a
lot of areas in the capital markets that we really have to get a little bit more progressive in being able to use newer systems and i think the pandemic has actually forced some of that movement as well so it's interesting you know sometimes that it's those things that push us to finally you know create easier systems to work through so thank you so much for all that
information i actually learned a bunch there as well i really appreciate it we're gonna end off this this speaker view today with my colleague rob tario who is director of listings and regulations rob tario has had his finger on every single filing that's ever gone through the csc that's true right rob i'm not making that up wow that's every single one no not every single one i've been around
since the dawn of time that's true but i haven't i haven't been involved in every single file but i have been involved in a lot of them more than i care to remember well i can't thank you enough for joining us i know that it it it's so important for people to understand what happens for you guys in the listings department you guys see this final product that
people such as ian and roof and jenna help our clients put together these packages and they come to you so why don't we talk a little bit about some of the csc listing qualifications in specifically in the mining sector and then i think it would be great to hear some of your processes from the listing department side sure sounds sounds good thank you for that introduction again my
name is rob tario i'm the director of listings and regulations at the canadian securities exchange i oversee the listings managers group and as well as the listing application process for the exchange and as anna mentioned i'll just briefly go through the listing requirements the policies are designed to allow for mining issuers to list at an early stage so what the company needs is to either own or have the ability to earn a
significant interest in a qualifying property now significant interest is not defined in the policies but it's largely dependent on how advanced the project is so if you're looking at a grassroots project there's no resource or or anything like that it's just the exploration program we probably want to see a larger percentage 50 or more but if it's a more advanced project then we can be a little bit more flexible
so the property as well must have a technical report that's compliant with national instrument 43-101 and in the report the author must recommend an exploration program and phase one of that exploration program must be a hundred thousand dollars or more in order to qualify in addition we the issuer must demonstrate that at least 75 000 in qualifying expenditures have been incurred on the property within three years of listing
and qualifying expenditures include stuff like geological and scientific surveys it excludes staking land maintenance fees investor relations you know that kind of stuff right so purely exploration work on the property that's the that's the mining aspect of it now there's also a financial resources requirement so the issuer must demonstrate that they have at least the fan the financial resources to fund their 12-month objectives from the time of listing or 200 000
whichever is greater because typically the mining companies we list are exploration companies they have no they're considered non-operating so that's the requirement for not operating company 12 months or 200 000 whichever is greater and we don't have a requirement for unallocated working capital or anything of that nature so it is very very straightforward the final listing requirement is the public distribution the issuer must have at least 10 percent
of the issued note standing in public hands and public holders excludes officers directors employees anybody who owns or controls five percent or more of the issue than outstanding and finally you need to have at least 150 public holders holding a minimum of one board lot each so that in a nutshell are the listing requirements for mining issuers now and asked me to go into the process a little bit which i'm happy to do
it depends on how you're going public ian mentioned earlier prospectus if you're a prospectus filer we rely a lot on the review that's done by securities regulators i mean we do conduct our own review absolutely but it's very much in the background we'll often ask you for all the comment letters and responses from securities regulators just so we're not duplicating and asking a lot of the same questions
but the review process is the same you have to submit the application it gets assigned to one of our listings managers or me and it gets reviewed and the time it takes really is dependent on how quickly the the company and council for the company can get through the comment and response usually there's several iterations of this with securities regulators and once they clear you to file your
final materials at that time we provide you with our letter of conditional approval which you can include in those materials and then you become a full reporting issuer and then depending on what it is it's usually either well it's either a non-offering prospectus in which case we can list the company soon after final materials are cleared or it's an ipo and then they go and market the thing and
once it closes then we can list it so the time frame for that is again it's dependent on how quickly you can go through the process but in our experience on average and for a very very straight forward mining issue where you're looking at two to three months on average now the other way companies go public and this has been discussed earlier as well is through the reverse takeover process
which is you find a reporting issue or shell and you vend in either a company or a project the difference with that is you're not dealing with securities regulators which i think maybe is preferable in some cases considering everyone asked for shells but you know that's a whole different story but in that case we're the principal gatekeeper so we conduct a thorough review to ensure that the disclosure is adequate and
that it qualifies for listing meets all the listing requirements of course and you know that process even though we are exceptionally busy right now which is great news for all the folks at the cse we are trying to keep the review process within the six to eight weeks window but that of course assumes we receive a complete package and there are no major deficiencies that need to be addressed
now the other thing you asked me to mention was the personal information forms we have our own form three so you can't use the piff form that's in 41 101 or god forbid the tsxv one i mean that's a different exchange like if you're applying for a loan at the rbc why would you bring a td application to anyway that's that's the whole other issue but yeah
you have to complete the form three specifically because it contains all the consent forms that allows us to gather the information that we need to do the background check so that that's it for me anna i'll look i'll turn it back over to you i i'm going to keep you on for two more secs rob if you don't mind i have a few things i wanted to chat with you about
now you're on the hot seat oh boy okay so so one thing i think that's really important for the audience to understand because i get this call so often and and i really hope that people eventually can understand the process a little bit better but but you you really shouldn't call the exchange and ask them how to build a shell and you shouldn't call the exchange
and tell them your plans to build a shell and if they can help you build the shell we do not have a shell program at the csc i think some people are fairly aware of programs at other exchanges where you can create a bit of a blind pool and vend in an asset but you know we we don't have that program and as your colleague and my colleague mark faulkner says we
wouldn't have it even if we even if we could i one thing i wanted to talk about a little bit as far as process just so that people are educated and how to handle with you guys i know that people are always wanting to just have a quick call with you and i know that the process has always very much been it really is in
everyone's best interest to email you with their questions isn't it absolutely i mean i mean it depends on what you're looking for like you mentioned earlier about shells and things like we're not there's a important distinction to make when it comes to shows there's companies that listed and then had a bona fide attention to pursue the objectives that were set out in either the perspectives or the listening statement
and things don't work out that's that's fine that happens all the time and then you know these guys as i said things don't work out so they they decide they need to or they seek a new opportunity for for that company you know that's fine what we don't want to see what we're not interested in like i said we do not have a shell program we don't have the equivalent of
a cpc program we're not interested in any of that but unfortunately some of us what we're seeing in some cases especially on the mining side because it the mining side is so established and you know it's almost like it's just you know you've got the technical report it's just it's very easy to you know find a property you know that may have some merit but not so much
get a technical report go public that way and then start marketing it as a show and then you you never actually pursued either the phase one program or any of the other objectives set out in the prospectus or the listing statement we have a real problem with that and if you if you do something like that and we have in the past especially for prospectus filers we say to them listen
you know we listed you as a mining issuer and you know you have done nothing to pursue those objectives so if you want to do another transaction that's entirely up to you but you have to de-list and basically start all over again yeah i mean that that obviously is an extreme case you know i think the point really to drive home there is that if you list as a mining issue with a property and
you're raising capital from shareholders to invest in that property then you probably should be doing a program on that property see what your results are and and move forward from there you know so absolutely absolutely that's that's all we're looking for rob thank you so much you know i think it's just it's a rare insight to actually get to hear from the voice of the listings department
so thank you again for your time with us today we're going to wrap up this portion where we've kind of gone through all of the really integral parts that you need as far as a team to go public you know obviously we haven't even touched on raising capital that could be a whole other panel thank you again everyone i i also wanted to mention that everyone involved in today's
panel is a sponsor to mining over canada they've worked with us on several different initiatives and have just been a great support to us and we're big fans of theirs so thank you gellings mnp and odyssey trust and thank you again rob tario for your time today thank you
everyone
foreign
More Mining Over Canada
Frank Holmes on the Millennial Impact on Mining SpeculationCSE Presents Mining Over CanadaDec 11, 2020
The Investment Opportunity in Mining w/ Frank Holmes, Rick Rule, and Adrian DayMining Over CanadaDec 2, 2020
