About This Video
Catch our replay of the “Curious and Conscious Investing” panel, moderated by the CSE’s Anna Serin, which featured Alyssa Barry, Principal and Co-Founder of irlabs; Cindy Broad, VP of Business Development at Business Television; and Carollynn Schafer, Co-Founder and GP of OKGN WMAN and Interim CEO of Accelerate Okanagan. Dive into insights surrounding investing topics, including key due diligence practices, the importance of management, cap tables and investor decks, the role of marketing and social media, and more.
The CSE’s Summit on Responsible Investment on June 27, 2023, in Kelowna, BC was designed to empower investors and entrepreneurs with the latest insights into socially responsible investing (SRI) and environmental, social, and governance (ESG) trends, regulations, and best practices. The full-day event featured an exciting agenda packed with expert panel discussions, presentations from industry leaders, company spotlights, and networking opportunities.
Subscribe for more great CSE insights and interviews here: https://go.thecse.com/CSETV-Subscribe
STAY CONNECTED WITH THE CSE
=============================
- NEWSLETTER: https://go.thecse.com/CSE-Mailing-List-Subscribe
- PODCAST: https://blog.thecse.com/cse-podcasts/
- INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/canadianexchange/
- LINKEDIN: https://ca.linkedin.com/company/canadian-securities-exchange
- FACEBOOK: https://www.facebook.com/CanadianSecuritiesExchange/
- TWITTER: https://twitter.com/CSE_News
- BLOG: https://blog.thecse.com/
- WEBSITE: https://thecse.com/
- MAGAZINE: https://issuu.com/thecse/docs
Read the TranscriptAuto-generated by YouTube; names and terms may be misspelled.
thank you this panel is curious and conscious investing we did have Sean peace good earlier and he did a lovely chat around due diligence practices and Bridging the the communication gap we're going to dive right back into that with some ladies who are are very heavily involved in this side of the space and invest in public and private markets so I'd like to welcome Elissa Berry principal and
co-founder of ir Labs Cindy broad VP of Business Development with BTV and Carolyn Schaefer Okanagan woman co-founder and GP thank you ladies I'd like to start off and have these ladies introduce themselves and just talk about what their business practice is Alyssa why don't we start off with you good afternoon everyone thank you very much for being here and for spending time with us Anna Anil and
Melissa and the entire CSE team thank you very much for pulling this together my name is Alyssa Berry I run an investor relations advisory firm that is across Canada we have team members from coast to coast I tend to choose to work with clients that have purpose better for you better for the planet my amazing business partner Caroline sawamoto is here as well and a couple of our companies that
we support are also here and it's a really great honor to be able to have a platform and an opportunity to meet new investors and be able to share some of our clients stories today thank you Alyssa I think you really redefine a little bit what an IR firm does you guys have really kind of come to Market and and redesigned it so to speak yeah it's you have to do things
different in this market and getting visibility getting the story out there I wanted to be a journalist before I got in the capital markets and so that having that storytelling lens I think helps absolutely Carolyn hello everyone so I my background is law I guess I come from law which makes me more comfortable having being on this panel to talk about due diligence but I then
became involved with Angel Investing after a company that I was involved with exited and I've been a part of the Okanagan Angel Summit I was a director of that in the Okanagan Angel Summit and both the Okanagan women are both set up similarly in that they're micro funds where individuals will invest five thousand dollars and then contribute towards a larger pool of 150 000 and
either make you know two or three or four Investments or make one large investment so my background is very much in the private capital and at the angel space and then I've been fortunate enough to be a part of Exile Okanagan for a number of years through the angel Summit and this might be a bit of a spoiler because I know this is coming out in the
next two days but I am going to be taking over for Brie two as the interim CEO over the next year breaking the news yes but you're only seeing that The Insider information Carolyn maybe to the to the local community this is this is a silly question but the Okanagan Valley has very much built out a large angel investor Network can you just describe what is
what is an angel investor what sets them apart because an angel investor falls into I guess I don't know which way you want to describe it but either the exempt you know they fall into that exempt category or they fall into the Venture Capital category and but they're at the first stage of venture capital and when people ask why would you become an angel investor in my mind you have to want to work
with the founders directly if you didn't want to work with the founders directly or support companies at a very early stage where there's still a lot more uncertainty on the direction they're going you should just be at the next stage or it's more Venture Capital where there's larger checks going in and there's a lot more certainty but we find most Angel Investors are either themselves somehow supported by an angel
investor very invested in the founder Community or want to support because they they see a like a there's just an alignment right so you become a bit of a partner as an investor as well you can I mean there's times where you may not want to be involved in as a Founder you don't want your engine investors too involved but but you definitely want them to be there as like side Support
Services right and future rounds of of capital capital needs as well yeah because they can hopefully make some introductions to those next stages of capital right absolutely Cindy hello again I I echoed the sentiments of thank you for hosting this fabulous event there's such great companies outside too that are very investable opportunities my name is Cindy Broad and I'm the VP of Business Development for business
television BTV and what we do is work with public companies to get their message out to investors and tell their stories in unique ways we partner with broadcasters in Canada and the US so BNN in Canada obviously is a great resource for business news and then CNBC and Bloomberg and fox business news in the US as well and help them tell their stories and reach investors and just
help investors discover companies to invest in wonderful thank you Cindy I think the the kind of basis of this conversation is really around the fact that as we are developing due diligence practices we're going to talk next about what some of those are and what are things that you want to look at when you're looking at a company is also you know it's it's happened very quickly I got my broker's
license 20 years ago and access to information has dramatically shifted you would call your broker to get information you could go to a wonderful website called Cedar which was probably built in the 60s to retrieve press release information things had to go across wire but websites were very archaic and very expensive to manage and not updated with regular information as well just investor presentations
you'd have to fly to a conference to be able to participate we're lucky enough in forums like these now where we can videotape it and we can we can have it online for people to see all over the place but the the the flow of information has dramatically shifted which is an amazing thing but it obviously also has some downsides because what information do we trust and what is important information to listen
to and and and what Tick Tock videos not to listen to perhaps so first of all I'd just like to start off with this I'm able to start with you what are some due diligence practices when you're looking at a company that are important for an investor sure I'm going to position it in a way to give tell you a little bit of I guess a story in terms of how I got
to where I am today that had to do with due diligence so I took a pivot in my career of being in-house investor relations for about 12 plus years and then I became a shareholder activist so I had the opportunity to underwrite companies small caps to Mega cap companies on various exchanges around the world looking at essentially being a value investor so finding companies that are trading at deep discounts and trying
to figure out what are they actually worth and how can we bridge that value Gap and that really opened my eyes to you know a lot of those check boxes that I'm sure many of you have in terms of a really solid management team and what does a capital structure look like amongst you know there's probably 20 things plus depending on who you are and what's important to you but the really
big thing for me when I I'm looking at my own personal Investments and also supporting my companies is shareholder engagement and making yourself accessible I believe it's so important to build that relationship with the CEO and maybe you don't always have access directly to the CEO but being able to engage in the materials that are being provided is someone responding from the company to be able to give me the
answers to the information that I'm looking for I think it's always worth taking that extra step of doing your own homework but then having an opportunity to meet a CEO the c-suite maybe other members of management as well to get to know them and I think that really gives you a lot of comfort it builds really great relationships between issuers and investors so that's not all the things I
look for but something that I wanted to share and really encourage all of you as you're looking at different opportunities is reach out to the companies directly reach out to investor relations and have conversation okay that's I think that's really important because I think people are afraid to do that you can pick up the phone and you can call the CEO or the investor relations person and ask them about their company this
is what they do for a living this is they actually really like doing it I think some of them do it in their sleep so if you're interested in a company don't be afraid to contact them and have that conversation directly for sure thank you Alyssa what about you Carolyn what are due diligence practices that are are important to you I think just coming off that because
with Angel Investing you are only ever usually dealing with the founder so it's a very different practice because you start the conversations with the founder and I find that you can actually because there is so much information available you can quickly become overwhelmed or overwhelmed and waste both your time and that of the founders so we find that it's best if you're very clear on your reasons for investing and and I mean at
Angel Investing level you talk about your own investment thesis but some of it is actually making sure that you have hurdles in place so that you're only asking for like if you have a very specific like if you're looking for like an impact investment for or you want like a Founder equity and you want like the founder to be you know X percent female owned that you put in
those hurdles in place to make sure that those metrics are in place before you continue to have conversations and continue to have hurdles like that to make sure that you're not wasting the time of yourself and the investors and the founders that you're working with because once you do like it almost becomes it's such a small acquisition but it almost like a subscription of shares or getting a small Angel
investment is like an acquisition of share so you can ask for like a wide array of information but it's good to make sure that you're just very focused on what you're looking for to start with wonderful thank you Cindy there's lots of resources out there like you were saying Anna to sort of do your due diligence getting to know the management team I I 100 agree is is so valuable
you want to make sure that the management team aligns with what you're what you're looking to invest in and and that the company is is falling in line with that as well there's libraries we have a huge CEO clip Library where you can go online and watch videos of management 60 second clips and they're giving you their 60-second elevator pitch basically on what the who the company is and what
they do you can get so much information around that and you want a CEO I think that is able to tell a very succinct message so that's really important as well it shows that they are really in tune with what what they're delivering and who they are and what they stand for as a company as well so wonderful thank you Alyssa I'm going to ask you this
there's a few things that we kind of talked about so management obviously is very important cap table can you explain what the cap table is where you find it and what you should be looking for in it okay every company that goes public or is publicly traded is going to have to disclose to their investors what their financial situation looks like and where their Shares are allocated so the
investor deck is a really great place to start and probably the best place that is least intimidating if you get into mdnas and financial statements and now there's disclosure it can be a little bit tricky and maybe sometimes overwhelming if you're not familiar with navigating those materials but definitely every investor deck or investor website should have a breakdown and it will show you how many shares are out there to be traded how many stock
options and other things such as warrants and other preferred types of Securities that might exist it's just really good to understand that if you're in investing in something that maybe doesn't you know maybe they're not capitalized maybe they don't have enough Runway to actually get to commercialization they've got a really great Vision but how are they going to get there those are important things to look at
and also incentives how much does management own is there skin in the game options yes absolutely yeah wonderful Carolyn when when you're looking at a private company how do you deal with valuation because obviously valuation in the capital markets is defined a little bit by the open auction but how do you deal with that on a private on the private side evaluation is a very tricky Topic at the
private stage especially at the early stage because I think the metrics are just not there to be looking at Revenue often for valuation so it's one of those things where we feel that Angels really need to like make sure that they understand the industry that they're investing into because the valuation will change depending on the like the sector that they're working within and then there are some very like basic guidelines that
angels can learn as to like what evaluation should start at and then what it should look like once it you know the attractions at a certain level or if you're again if you're looking at different metrics if you have impact what those metrics follow within with evaluation but again it's it's so sector by sector specific that you should really just be familiarizing with the industry you're investing in and I'm
not sure if you're a CFA or not but do you have do you have guidance when you're looking at these valuations you've just done it for long enough yeah unfortunately it's very like it's not like it there isn't called Carolyn is what she's saying because they always say that there's there's a saying and I'm just thinking about the top of my head but it's very much like more of an art than a science
yeah and because it is so early stage it is basically like there's factors as like who are the founders are what's their reputation because sometimes that's a factor as much as you know the team they've built do they what's their trajectory look like how is Raising because if VCS are very interested in that in that space then you know that they're more likely to be funded in two
or three years so that's also a factor so there's so many different like soft factors that are hard to especially because you guys have such a an amazing Tech Community there are groups that even I've gotten to know where you've seen them do three or four projects you know they might get a premium on their next project just because the way that they're able to execute and raise
Capital Cindy you mentioned something that I thought was interesting to kind of first of all explain and then how to decipher it but what is earned versus paid that's a great question and I think that both have their place in the way that companies Market themselves to their potential investors or bring on net new shareholders I think it was soffit Capital made the comment earlier today that all
companies start small and grow right so you might have the best story in the world and if nobody can find it because they don't know who your company is or anything about your story you're not going to grow you need eyeballs on your story basically and paid media is a very valuable piece of the marketing mix to be able to share your story with millions of investors which obviously makes for a healthy
company right so you're saying it's not necessarily a bad thing it's definitely not necessarily a bad thing I think it actually shows Management's commitment and ability to strategically plan getting them most out of catalysts and Milestones as they sort of cross certain thresholds in their business so it's also a really great way to go back engage have they met their Milestones or have they have they delivered on what they've they've said
they're going to you can go back and watch video clips or watch different pieces that might have been a paid content piece and see if they've they've met those it's deploying that messaging all along the way at the right time as well as really important yeah and yeah it also helps companies bridge the gap into earned media because now there's stories out there talking about quality of media as well
basically any pieces that are aired on broadcast are not only have to be compliant obviously these are publicly traded companies they have compliance that needs to be met but they're also vetted again for National broadcast right so these are high high quality pieces compliant pieces that you're going to be able to get the information that you're looking for out of and that's really important as well
so yeah that's that's kind of the benefit of it so one thing I want to ask all three of you because I feel like this is something we all need to approach as we're all investors in the space because it's new is you know investing in a stock and social media so we're seeing stuff come onto social media most companies now have an Instagram page and they have a
Facebook page and they have maybe a tick tock page they have a channel on C on on YouTube I almost mentioned our YouTube channel CSC TV check it out please so so how do you approach social media from the IR perspective how do you approach it I love this topic so it is really hard for our issuers our clients to get visibility a lot of the companies
that you're invested in today getting a desk presentation being able to get analyst coverage when you're new to the market and you're a small cap nanocap micro cap it is becoming even more difficult I'm talking or teams talking to investment advice users Brokers portfolio managers all day long and I would say 75 percent of the time they're not even in the offices not that that really impacts the conversation but it's
just becoming more difficult so social media is really important but my philosophy and how we operate with our clients is we want to put out quality content that is authentic and factual we leverage LinkedIn like crazy I actively on behalf of our business and my clients we're in LinkedIn all the time I feel like I'm at a conference every single day and it's it's working
out really nicely for us but I'm gonna use this analogy so you're you're wearing a really nice jacket and so you go on Tick Tock and someone says you got to buy this jacket it's the best jacket the best jacket you'll ever buy and they've been paid 500 or whatever it is to be able to say that so you get the jacket home and you try it on once and
it rips and it falls apart and it's piece of junk so you know the same thing I'm using that analogy because it's the end of the day and I'm trying to give give us something here but you know it's the same thing looking at companies you know if someone has told you that the company is great and they're giving you a promo piece and then you invested
it invest in it and then you go and do your research and the cap table is crummy and the management team as bad track records and they haven't performed so it's like the Gateway social media yeah I I it's a blessing and a curse it's a blessing and a curse so don't use it as your source of information but it could be what you use to start your
investigatory process with the company Carolyn what about you do you do you go through that with the private companies is there any element of your due diligence where you pay attention to social media it would again it depends really very much in the sector but I don't think social media plays a large role in Angel Investing unless you're dealing with consumer product goods which isn't something that we invest in quite a bit
but there are like funds that are specifically investing consumer product goods but I think when you are looking at social media it's only when you're encountering due diligence and then you're looking at making sure like it's not just like users you're looking at engagements and one of the benefits of being in these micro Venture funds is typically there is someone in the room who is like a digital marketing specialist who can
be like these metrics are like industry standard or not and it's interesting and we actually ask when we talk to Founders now if they know their own industry metrics to make sure that they put them as baselines for Angels because Angels just can't know all the different metrics that they should be meeting for social media right Cindy well I mean I think you want numerous voices telling your story so I
I think like from an investment investor standpoint that's how you can kind of walk through that right like you want credible voices telling your story numerous you don't want back to the paid part you don't want one voice on your story you want numerous voices on your story and you know we spend so much time looking into things like you know what we put in our body or what label we're
gonna buy or all those things and we're doing so much due diligence on things like that this is your hard-earned investment dollars right so you want to go through and and you know sure take other people's opinions and read them and and I believe that companies on social media should be telling their own stories not having somebody telling it for them because that's where it gets really a slippery slope they need to be
in control of that messaging for sure there are compliance issues around that so yeah I mean I think digest lots of content and spend time doing it and then you know you you can make better investment decisions that way for sure absolutely I think there's been a bit of a movement from my understanding on Tech talk there's been a movement there's groups that are not industry professionals by any
means but have the ability to make huge movements so I wonder how that will play out especially as the next generation of investor comes to the market and they're figuring it out for themselves so you know I think one thing that's really important for investing in general whether it's private or public there's professionals out there and they are mandated by self-regulatory bodies and and by professional designations and
definitely utilize them pick up the phone and make a call to help you go through that process before we wrap up does anyone have any questions we answered everything
oh I get the money this is someone who does does their research really well and I brought it with me so in 2003 there was a study that from Forbes one thousand firms found statistically significant positive relations between the presence of women or minorities on the board in firm value since we're all women that vote with our dollars and share our stories do you when you share these stories or vote
with your daughters or vote with your dollars pardon me hold them into account on what's on the board who's on the board probably speak to that briefly I sit on a forum with the bcsc and that's something that's being discussed from a regulatory level is the question around mandating diversity on boards so that discussion is definitely happening behind the curtain I think there's a everyone appreciates that
there is at a certain size to have those extra mandates on a small company who's doing their best to kind of get their feet off the ground and and we have to remember that diversity needing diversity comes in all shapes and forms so an all-female board is not diverse either right so there's definitely a lot of those conversations that are happening from a regulatory standpoint but do you guys notice that there's
diversity on boards that when you deal with companies I think when we look at particularly The Venture exchanges we see companies that are a little bit younger in their Journey they have great aspirations of uplifting or you know maybe they're going to get taken out or moved to a different exchange this is this is I I know this is what they're aspiring for but there needs to be more women on the cap
table so what I'm getting at here is a lot of a lot of men are building the deals they're bringing them to Market taking them public the more women who can actually get involved you know early Angel Investing Founders rounds or early series prior to going public I think that's when we're going to start seeing a shift and we're having a lot of those active conversations with a lot of
our private clients today well and Carolyn you can speak to that since you guys co-founded Okanagan women which is an angel investor group and it's only women is that right so we're seeing this shift no and I agree I mean Angels don't have boards at that level so that would be typically what you're talking about so we see it very differently but we are investing only in female Founders or
with companies with female Founders on the cap table and we do try and make sure that they there is a certain percentage in that that they're involved in the management of the team and but the metrics for Angel Investing show that you know if there are women like Founders or like women in the management team that the returns are better and that proves out that like that that statistic so I think that is
something that we try to make sure is emphasized at the Angel Investing level to be looking for that when you're an angel investor because it is something that will also help you return wonderful thank you I think we're gonna have to wrap up this panel we could probably talk much but we're gonna wrap it up and move on to another panel that is being put on
by accelerate Okanagan with some local companies so I'm very excited about that ladies thank you so much for your insights they will be sticking around so go and grab them later if you have any questions thank you



