About This Video
CSE's Phillip Shum is joined by Siri Genik, Principal & Founder of BRIDGE to "dig" deeper into important acronyms like CSR and ESG - Environmental, Social and Corporate Governance. Siri also shares examples that illustrate the consequences of successful - and unsuccessful - implementation of ESG. Here are the highlights:
0:00 - Introducing Siri Genik and BRIDGE
2:00 - Soft issues that have a hard effect on dollars
3:17 - The evolution of the term ESG
6:30 - What stewardship really means
11:13 - The most important facets of ESG
15:37 - Good values will drive a positive bottom line
17:09 - CSR v ESG
20:00 - ESG has to be cross-functional throughout the organization
24:24 - Examples of failed ESG
29:00 - Examples of successful ESG
32:49 - Debunking a common ESG myth for small companies
Siri is the principal and founder of BRIDGE , a business leader with a successful track record working in numerous countries and across a broad spectrum of roles and responsibilities. Her knowledge and expertise span over 20 years working on complex major capital projects. Siri is particularly sensitive to the importance of culture and prioritizes its integration into all facets of business, strategic planning risk and commercial management. It is core to her approach to Social Responsibility and Stakeholder Management.
Related link
https://www.bridgeconsult.ca/
Subscribe for more great CSE insights and interviews here: https://bit.ly/CSETVSubscribe
STAY CONNECTED WITH THE CSE
=============================
- PODCAST: https://blog.thecse.com/pe-podcasts/
- INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/canadianexchange/
- LINKEDIN: https://ca.linkedin.com/company/canadian-securities-exchange
- FACEBOOK: https://www.facebook.com/CanadianSecuritiesExchange/
- TWITTER: https://twitter.com/CSE_News
- BLOG: https://blog.thecse.com/
- WEBSITE: https://thecse.com/
MB01XMFO9FPRSMF
Read the TranscriptAuto-generated by YouTube; names and terms may be misspelled.
welcome to mining over canada join the canadian securities exchange and our partners in a first-hand look into our country's vast mining landscape hi it's philipp schrum from the csc i'm the director of listings development here today i'm happy to be with siri gennik who is the founder of a bridge we are talking about the abcs of esg today she's a specialist that is very much focused in this so we're
extremely excited to hear all about this today welcome siri phil thank you welcome and thank you for extending the invitation to you to the csc team it's it's always a pleasure to talk about what i'm passionate about a little bit about myself and bridge so no secret i'm a lawyer have been for 30 years and esg wasn't even on anybody's radar screen at the time worked through became was a partner
at a major law major canadian law firm and then joined a major engineering and construction company not as a lawyer and i wanted to learn about projects and understand projects and understand the risks so i'm not technical i i mean i have an mba i have knowledge and finance etc i'm not an engineer a geologist but i love the the process of building something and also understanding the
risks around projects and what can actually affect them and prevent them from actually coming to life or affecting operations or their their shareholders and the people that are part of them had some great mentors worked with incredible project directors was fortunate to work with the likes of extrada to the glencore estrada bhp suncor and about it years ago decided i'd bring together all my experiences or most of my experiences my
skill sets and work in the space of project risk management for what the at the time was called non-quantitative risk so risk was often either financial or legal and the other concerns at the time called soft were not necessarily tracked or trapped as concerns that could affect the bottom line i believed otherwise and i had seen differently and so i decided to build a consultancy around what i thought were soft issues
but had a hard effect on dollars so when i started eight years ago i called the company bridge exactly for that reason bridget linking idea ideas with reality what are those ideas and how do you pragmatically turn them into results for your bottom line in the natural resource industry so mining oil and gas but also infrastructure so i've worked with the port of montreal hydro quebec the concepts remain the
same esg as you mentioned is an acronym and one of an alphabet so the choice of title is excellent abcs of esg it started off as hns which was health and safety it became hsc health and safety and environment it became hsec so it helped the environment and community and then it was csr and then it was esg and i would almost add one more it's not very elegant but
wtf i mean you're in the mining business it's not very ladylike it's my miner's mouth but i i i was sitting on the other and going of course people don't understand every time you get comfortable in the space it evolves so part of today is very much evolution with covet 19 everything has changed literally overnight covet 19 has kicked the esg and you see it everywhere it's
hard to have a mining conference or any kind of a conference without those that acronym when you throw into the mix the acronyms around the metrics so sass b mcsi tcfd sdg gri i mean you're just like forget it i need you know do i need to go back to school learn how to spell and that's a bit unfortunate esg is is really all about stewardship esg stands for environment
sustainability and governance and those are today the three driving factors that coach the project development and project opera business operations didn't exist i would i would say i should catch myself it has always been important for mining to be a good business partner a good corporate citizen what that meant was a whole a whole different debate of course you need a great asset or as good an asset as you can
not too remote not too deep not too difficult geopolitically safe the long list of risks around management but more and more the world is concerned about carbon footprints about the people and about how it affects the future of our planet and they seem like very lofty goals and maybe a little bit fluffy in an industry that's hard rock i mean my dad was a geologist i know it's like
if the gold isn't there it doesn't matter fair enough the problem is that if you don't get the financing for that gold or that oil and gas or to build that energy plant it's going to stay in the ground or stay on a an architect's drawing board so esg if we take the acronym away i think a more comfortable word that we could work with is stewardship and
so it goes mostly to the g in the esg good governance and it means it may there are two groups of people in this thought process you have the asset owners so the the gold mining companies of all sizes from the rios to the juniors and you have the investors on i don't like to stay on the other side because it's not it should not be them in us together absolutely and you
go from institutional to retail to the banks and and so what esg what stewardship means is from an own assets perspective i have a business model that is concerned with my shareholder value with making profit but i also i follow policy i follow guidelines by the government but i also have a purpose word that you're going to be hearing a lot of also in the upcoming years i believe and
so another one for the for the mellie of of sustainability and stewardship so what does that mean to me as a small cap as a junior what what so for a small cap or a junior it's just me it means as simple as having a good board maybe not three guys or three girls who play golf together but three people who are knowledgeable in the field but bring different skill sets to the
table right it could be male female it's not just gender related absolutely not it's knowledge it's all the different aspects of the industry and if you're a small company it can be three people it could also mean that the people on the board and the leadership team even if it's small don't each make 100 million dollars a year so the there has to be a relationship
about what's going on with the the company and the role it also means that you understand the environment and i mean environment with a capital e so the landscape in which you're functioning are you in the far north are you in the arctic are you in africa who are the communities but also be aware of your stakeholders and amongst your stakeholders we can't forget our investors important so what are the investors looking for in
this esg equation or algorithm depending on the day they want to make sure at the end of the day that they get a return on their investment and that their reputation is protected so we'll go into some examples later on but i want to know that if i'm lending you 10 i will get increasing amounts my 10 plus but i also want to know that i won't get my
egg all over my face because you may have dumped into a water table you have maybe not hired locally or you may not you may be using tier 1 suppliers when you could be perhaps using suppliers on the ground or maybe not paying your suppliers and this starts as early as drilling and goes all the way through until closure so if we conclude this part we're talking about
stewardship and for it to be successful regardless of the size you're going to think of your bottom line to where profit purpose and policy come together and in harmony so your investors happy you understand what your stakeholders looking for the stakeholder is happy because he says he sees you're working hard you have good team a good leadership right your reputation is solid and then the government the policy side
you're following the guidelines the consultation the information on the the biodiversity what have you so that is a bit of a big picture of what esg is yeah and certainly this whole concept of stewardship as you were talking about when it really comes down to it it's you know as you as you'd mentioned there are multiple stakeholders there are different different aspects which are involved here but
ultimately when it really comes down to it it's it's it's really important to be able to to run a a good company and i'm doing air quotes good company because there's many many ways of looking at what the definition of good is but really and the importance of doing all of that is quite paramount but really if you want to if you were to enunciate that to a ceo
what would you say is the most important facets of esg and why you should do it it's the survival of your organization it is the ability to carry you through crises so if you look at covid if you're not agile if you're not able to look after your own employees as you go through covid if people are not treated in the way that they feel empowered and and involved
if they feel that their leadership doesn't care you'll lose them and you can't really run even a very tiny mining company without your team it means you have a long-term vision it means you're able to not just look at the next quarter but to look at what it's going to look like when you come out of that store or how do you go through that storm
so you need to be agile you need to have a long-term vision you have to look at your value chain understand your business from the bottom up and the top down so again even if you're in early days of drilling understand who are your suppliers are they people that need help are they part of your ecosystem if you don't build trust if you don't build respect and if you're
not transparent whether it's your internal stakeholders which are your employees or your external stakeholders what can be community governments even local businessmen you won't last very long you won't make it to that third or fourth quarter because nobody will want to do business and your reputation especially with social media today you know much better than i do in in real time you can destroy your reputation you can
go to bed one night thinking you're great next morning the world is collapsed like i said we'll get into examples in a bit but you just need to be responsible you need to think empathetically from a business perspective so you need to understand the business this is not this is about hard dollars and making sure that the people that have trusted you with their investments are going to
see a return so that means acting so stewardship as a good corporate citizen and what does that mean so you treat your employees and you respect them well you make sure you understand who's in your supply chain that's part of the organization's value change you're agile sometimes you can have to change up literally on a dime as we've all had to in the last six or seven months things
open up they close down again we've had to put in different health protocols that slow things down absolutely but at the end of the day people have gotten used to it not doing those things the pro the challenge with stewardship and esg is if you don't adopt a behavior that's that's a good corporate citizen you're gonna have issues if you are you will always attract the trust of your stakeholders the
respect of your of your ecosystem and you will be transparent no bank will fault you for for having some difficulties along the way if you're not transparent with them they will lose trust in you right the same goes so it's it's about i would say those three words building trust building respect so building relationships and always being transparent that's really and i would almost say it's your
personal life and your your professional those are common traits of just good behavior yeah you know what translates into good dollars as well yeah and when i would say certainly in my personal profes and personal and professional life you know i would say for the most part what you see personally is actually very similar to what i see professionally for me so i would i would hope that someone
else on the other side of the table it's you know we don't want to use that word other side of the table but the people that you're dealing with for the most part also have a similar philosophy in terms of life and and if you can you know we're all it's always better to work with people that you like to like to work with it just makes life so much easier as well well when
you have to work 24 7 you know people who are on shifts people who are in remote areas that's when it gets really tough and having done it the number of time when you're tired and you're cold or you're hot or you're exasperated these things make a difference and so you are one team i mean and and mining brings a lot of really incredible things to our
environment to our economy and environment as well but to the people that are part of it so the better we are and again it's not about motherhood and you know apple pie and it's really about good people drive good teams and drive good results and that has been consistent there's data i don't have the data with me but there is consistent data out there that strong leadership strong vision empathy
will drive strong bottom line results right and of course you definitely need the asset i mean you can't mech about with what's in the ground but that will never be it will no longer be enough let's just put it to you that way well that's that's great to know so i i also wanted to bring up one facet in many ways a lot of people may confuse
esg with csr and i wanted to see if you could maybe elaborate about the respective differences sure well it's another it's it's another acronym in the in the alphabet soup so csr is corporate social responsibility and if you had a diagram corporate social responsibility would fall under esg is the framework within which you structure your organization within that you're going to give your different teams and your different
departments roles and responsibilities to roll out that that environmental social and governance framework corporate social responsibility is one of those areas okay that will then transform into actions what on the ground where the the s part if you will how do we translate that corporate vision from the top from the leaders to the to being on boots on the ground so it can mean a million things but it is
it is a com a very important component so sometimes you hear slo another acronym social license to operate it's about building those partnerships those relationships with people on the ground again as corporate citizens so that when you work with the government you go through the consulting process and you're going to be there for a while you you actually structure partnerships and build it into your into your model so that when
it moves back up to the top then you've got something to deliver so it is one of the very important parts of esg but they they absolutely are people mix them up and in the evolution we started with health and safety and we went through those acronyms csr was the latest one before esg now in in the business we really talk about either sustainability or
stewardship to get rid of a lot of acronyms and to work with something that's more perhaps generic but it means something different for every organization so you tailor it there's no silver bullet you work with what your business vision is and what are the issues that are material to delivering that business model and you'll find very quickly that the vis business vision or the business model and some of those material issues are
around the environment your process plants your tailing ponds etc etc so that very naturally they will come together so you've worked for various large firms in the past and how are many of these organizations structured you i suspect based off what you just said that you have like an esg is really more of a strategy so to speak the term and then csr is one
component as you'd mentioned but how do how does that inter get integrated or what does that look like from an org chart standpoint oh my goodness if i had the answer to that question i'd be a trillionaire it's evolving so so the the challenge has been that up until relatively recently concepts around sustainability were parked in a department so you had hr you had legal
you had csr and there was somewhere down that hallway and then you had of course the the business units and so a lot of silos and cs as csr but but esg needs to to flow it needs to be cross-functional if you you were drawing drawing a matrix it would be cross-functional it has to filter through everything through hr through legal through health and safety but through design and engineering
so when you you start drawing when you get you you probably get to the point where you've got enough money to start digging they also ask you for a closure bond and everybody's always like well you know why and it is usually it's getting heftier and heftier even for the really small the juniors the reason is that there are expectations that when this organization leaves you will have created the least impact
possible and if you don't that money serves to remediate so a better approach is why don't i reverse engineer the solution why don't i look like look at what i want this site to look like when i leave i'm mining company i'm a junior this is how i want i wanted green fields and corn flowers and and beautiful playgrounds and all that kind of nice so how do i reverse engineer it design
the creator yeah to get the right pro will it be more expensive up front probably or most possibly but as you work your way through the permitting process through the consulting through the approvals you will find you have buy-in and if you work with your stakeholders you're both the investors so you share within the challenges as well as the communities and the unions and the government now you have a bunch
of partnerships not a bunch of people that are beating you up so often it's again just like human relationships the the more you talk to people the more i certainly learned that in my career as a lawyer i moved to certify as a mediator because the concept of i was a litigator of me versus you even when you're the winner you don't win anything that and that's it's a
personal view it's my view as a lawyer very proud to be a lawyer by the way but as a mediator you said everybody around that round table and there has to be something in it for everybody and it doesn't cost money to talk to people so it's understanding what those issues are and tr again putting them on on a diagram and mapping them out in a risk
a risk diagram and saying what are they and they move so you have to be on top of them but it's not and i mean it's very respectfully it's not rocket science it's just part of doing business that is up front less expensive to talk to people to understand what concerns are what needs are it's not always simple either geopolitically it can be a challenge but be being aware of them is is part of
managing the risk not addressing them when you know they're there is poor risk mitigation no i i i love that concept about retrofitting or rather working reverse engineering reverse engineering it works really i've worked on it with clients and and i've worked with big guys but my clients now are more mid-tiers and small and junior and it works really well you know a whiteboard a diagram and we talk it through and there's some
really and some solutions today are amazing and and then communicating them yeah you know and and we've we've talked on in this discussion about like why it's important what are the acronyms but ultimately you know the hope one of the purposes of this video is to make sure that we're educating individuals about why the importance of esg but so walk me through a scenario or rather
examples or reasons why people should do it and ultimately what's the effect if you don't do it so i can i'll take two extreme examples but they're public and they're very obvious so and to the point where a few of my clients or some of the juniors will say well look this is all great siri but i just i don't have the money in the teams to
do all this stuff so a very recent example very unfortunate that happened in september is the explosion of the yukin caves you can gorge caves by rio tinto 46 million 46 million year old caves just incredible history i've worked in that in that area they're right they're incredible where in australia so in the pobara in north west australia so pilbara pure are in our country it's and it wasn't that they didn't
have all the bells and whistles they had tools they had reports they had all the csr teams the challenge there was what we talked about earlier there was no tie-in i i believe to the top to the leadership there was no or the perception that we have anyway we'll never know what happened we weren't i wasn't at rio at the time and i wasn't part of that decision-making process but
from the outside and from what we hear is that what went from the top down never came back up to the top so there was a lot of issues structurally and organizationally that are currently being addressed and fixed so it's important in an organization regardless of the size to talk to each other so that the permit department talks to the communications department that talks to the engineering department
and that you make sure that work your way to the top of the leadership that was a dramatic example it's it's a side example and and it's obviously all over the place and so to those people say well i don't have enough money they had everything but yet that stewardship approach the the the this concern about am i do am i doing as a leader i think we need
to ask ourselves am i doing the right thing because i am at the end of the day accountable so it's that accountability a reason not there are many reasons that have not gone well of organizations that have bought or merged with small organizations and geopolitically challenged situations where communities were enraged or not satisfied and no due diligence was done and eventually the assets had to be abandoned and there's any number of
those but it was much better assets were abandoned therefore they they sunk two billion dollars okay we sent two billion dollars into the ground to to buy this asset and then turned out that there was community issues the you know and again an example but it's it's it's very big and complicated it could be barrican and preschooler and i think at this point no it's chilean argentina but but it is
a challenging site geographically etc but it it at the outset getting community by and understanding the impact of water so those are some dramatic examples of when you don't when you when you don't pay enough attention or you don't think it's important there are many others where people have bought at companies in peru and in argentina that had issues in africa and thought well when we take
them over we'll fix it and they were unable to it's hard to build trust when trust is broken yeah it's hard to build respect but there's some really good examples of when even the small smaller companies are prop are are good corporate citizens that in an m a situation or a jv situation a larger company will go now the asset is good geographically it's closed but you know
what they're also doing well and i'll give you two really one very recent one less recent in fact three that come to mind is newmont and gold now they're larger given but new mountain goldcorp had common sustainability cultures and gold corp has muscle white which is a very attractive canadian asset for newmont and is continuing to be if you look at kirkland gold and detour
gold the same thing an australian company detour had a very strong a very strong approach to corporate sustainability and to to to just the broader respect and that are very very light in the muskrie environment the other in the saint barbara and atlantic gold so saint barbara again is australian and bought nova scotian atlantic gold the same thing atlantic gold embraces the so obviously the asset is
is good and has promise and its pipeline future but it also has strong corporate sustainability behavior the most recent one that i really like because it's it's it talks to the smaller companies that always are worried rightfully so is it nico equal and mabel gold now i'm in the space but i hadn't really maple gold was not on my radar screen agni koiko certainly is and that nico are known along with
pneuma to be right at the top of those mining companies that embrace esg that is part of their framework that's how they do business so i know for a fact that the nico has it they have a checklist obviously when they do their due diligence the whole sustainability and stewardship component is absolutely vital if an asset doesn't have that they won't even consider it well okay so very recently at nico and maple gold
jv i think it was last week maybe two weeks ago but this the the value of the of the stock of maples just shot it right up and they're doing well and they're you know sorry you're going to see no and and and that's that's an interesting facet because ultimately i i think when it comes down to it if you don't do the the right things with esg it's going
to cost you ultimately and it could you mentioned sinking two billion dollars into a property and then it having to but on the flip side if you do it right you can get you can get bought out or you can merge with a larger or it's starting so you know there is no that i know of and i and i stand to be corrected direct relationship to date
between a strong esg framework and attracting the equal number of dollars so but the bank everybody now is is looking at it is considering it the institutional investors absolutely are they're all members of the principles of pri which are the principles of responsible investment they subscribe to all of these important requirements and so even if you're small if you don't die and it doesn't mean you have to have
a report so that's one one myth i'd like to debunk on this platform is it doesn't mean you have to have a glossy report with you know lots of results around sdgs and gris and again these all these this terminology i help clients work with the spread an excel spreadsheet and i tell them pick two or three things that are really material it could be concerned around polluting
water concern about providing local employment and that can be it identify it on an excel spreadsheet and track it how are you doing where can you do better that is as much a report as the very fancy ones and like i said there are many you know valet had the brazil tailing dams disaster they have reports coming out of the yin yang so it is rio so at the end of the
day you have to live your results you have to be your results it's more than just a report so when you get a report you can say yeah no i actually we changed our process for this approach for this gold because we knew it was going to pollute the water table or our tailings have been moved or so there is a story that is that you can talk to your investor and understand
what your investors looking for and now you're having building a relationship for the long term because reputation can be killed in an instant as we know but what in our business if it's good it'll last you in good stead for a long time and that's what we're looking for it's managing at the end of the day your reputational risk regardless of what you've got in the ground and how good it is right and
when you said long-term relationships that means trust and and engendering trust by actually living it living and doing what you say you're gonna do and respect yeah yeah and so this is being extremely interesting i very much appreciate you for your time and your your expertise with everything how does one keep keep abreast of getting in touch with you or how do people
figure out so thank you for asking fella they can go to my website so www.bridgeconsults.ca or go go through linkedin i'm on linkedin or even through yourself and you can forward the questions any just if people need help or just some thoughts i am happy to to talk to them i mean it it's it it's not to get discouraged not to think it has to be
a huge report or lots it's more about starting small but starting right and understanding what your business model is and with that we can build a foundation that is attractive to everybody and at the end of the day makes your shareholders happy okay great thank you so i want to thank you again once again it's philip shum from the csc i'm the listing development director here in toronto
canada i'm here with siri gennik that's g-e-n-i-k if you're looking for her on on linkedin and so thank you very much this wraps up another video for mining over canada and certainly for other types of mining over canada videos please subscribe to csctv once again thank you very much siri thank you phil and have a nice day everybody thank you
you
More Mining Over Canada
Frank Holmes on the Millennial Impact on Mining SpeculationCSE Presents Mining Over CanadaDec 11, 2020
The Investment Opportunity in Mining w/ Frank Holmes, Rick Rule, and Adrian DayMining Over CanadaDec 2, 2020
