Canadian Securities ExchangeThe Daily Bell

The Purpose Led Economy w/ Dr. Victoria Hurth

Summit on Responsible Investment 2023

July 28, 2023Summit on Responsible Investment

About This Video

Subscribe for more great CSE insights and interviews here: https://go.thecse.com/CSETV-Subscribe

STAY CONNECTED WITH THE CSE

=============================

- NEWSLETTER: https://go.thecse.com/CSE-Mailing-List-Subscribe

- PODCAST: https://blog.thecse.com/cse-podcasts/

- INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/canadianexchange/

- LINKEDIN: https://ca.linkedin.com/company/canadian-securities-exchange

- FACEBOOK: https://www.facebook.com/CanadianSecuritiesExchange/

- TWITTER: https://twitter.com/CSE_News

- BLOG: https://blog.thecse.com/

- WEBSITE: https://thecse.com/

- MAGAZINE: https://issuu.com/thecse/docs

Read the TranscriptAuto-generated by YouTube; names and terms may be misspelled.

I know I'm very big on your screen that might seem a little bit strange to you so I will try and keep my presentation Larger than Life to match just to say I very much enjoyed that opening ceremony I think it's a wonderful way to open our hearts and Minds to get outside of the sort of daily thinking I'm sure you did

that over teen coffee as well because my talk is going to be really about trying to take that wonderful opening that we were given and use it as a platform to sort of keep you there at that sort of bigger level that bird's eye view you might say we all need that I play I'm fortunate enough to play a you know a relatively unique role having

focused on the question of how we align organizations with a sustainable future for over 20 years and very concertedly on that question spanning lots of disciplines and lots of parts of sectors and and organizations so what I'm going to be doing today is to try to bring that to you the sort of conclusion and it was about four or five years ago I was I'm not really hearing anything new here I

think we know what we're trying to bring about I think we know what the problems are it's just very difficult sometimes to pin those down in in a clear way so I hope and I'm sure there's a lot that I could improve on that and I'd love your feedback but that's what I want to give you today so thank you for having me here this is as I said the the high level view now of

course your responsible investors so you're already starting or you're interested in responsible investing so you're already starting from a from a high bar you might say but even though my life is immersed in this topic like I said this reality check really matters and that's because there is a massive Gap as human beings there is a massive gap between what feels feasible what feels like we can say to our stakeholders what

feels like what keeps us in the realm of normality and then the real reality that's unfold around us and of which we really

and this reality but actually we're not in on this occasion I'm just checking can you see me okay am I am I buffering a little bit or am I okay yeah we got you buffered for just a moment there okay apologies for that as long as you can hear me sorry about that is that enough yeah we got you perfect super so moving to the next slide

then this is my summary view of of where we're at and as you'll see Finance is absolutely the heart of this so starting actually from the right hand side if we think about what happened during the pandemic when a crisis hits how far and how quickly Society will hold up their hands and say you know what this is too complex just make the decision and tell me what

to do now we're seeing the crises from unsustainability the degraded social and environmental systems that are really on their knees now with Humanity with toes over the precipice you might say I don't think I think the first thing we really need to acknowledge is the fact that we are potentially not far away from losing a market economy and moving to very much a command and control

system because what's in play even if we act quickly if we don't act really quickly and in the right way I think we will end up there because we'll get desperate and so really this is a plea to say that I don't that firstly that's an unworkable we know that people sat in a room making decisions is not going to work it's inefficient it's ineffective we lose the freedom efficiency and

democracy effects that we have with the market economy but if we want to save a market economy and we want Finance to be able to play its role then we need to be really Frank with ourselves about how the way that we are currently organizing the market economy and how we've concertedly organized it over the last number of decades has led to this situation that we now face where we are

threatened with moving to that ugly side of the equation and unless we do that head on and we transform the market economy to one that is fundamentally delivering four long-term well-being for all in other words the definition of sustainability and in fact the actual end goal of an economy which is there to serve the well-being of society as a whole unless we can remember that and govern for it very concertially and

quickly I think that's where we will be so where we are at the moment I obviously I just summarized that we have organized the market economy in a way that is resulting in unsustainability and I'll go into that with a different diagram a bit more in the minute in a minute but just to summarize very briefly is that we have made the mistake which we knew would be a mistake

we were told by cousins and others who who orchestrated this system that we should not over rely on finance as a proxy for the end goals of the economy but that is what we have done because it's beautiful it's simple it makes life easy and it's complex out there so of course you know there are lots of reasons why we might want to do that however we've reached end game time so

we have a GDP economy we have an economy optimized for financial income as a proxy for well-being we have organizations that are delivering to optimize Financial income and we have human beings working in organizations that we assume are driven primarily by Financial motives and so when people talk about the hyper financialization of life of the economy this is what they mean in terms of breaking down and I'm sure

that you all recognize this system because and it doesn't matter even what part of the world that you're in because ultimately this system has been embedded within our governance architecture globally and its reaches are are and I its reaches are also Way Beyond business this is the vortex within which universities governments and other organizations are pulled if we want to preserve the market economy then it is my belief that what we are all saying is

that we need to move towards at the macro level a well-being economy you can also call it a purpose-driven economy but the well-being economy is a very established concept that is essentially doing nothing more than actually accounting for and strategizing to the end goal of the economy as always was and kind of shedding a lot of those really unhelpful assumptions about how the machine of the market Works automatically to result in

well-being now of course you can have policy that tries to govern for that but ultimately what brings that about is organizations including government as an organization and so what we need are purpose-driven organizations whose strategic reason to exist the value generation point of what they do is specifically anchored to long-term well-being for all people in Planet I.E sustainability iedn goal of the economy and in doing that and focusing on that

Meso Level we unleash meaningful work as in human beings that are primarily we're driven by many motives but what we have forgotten is that primarily we want to act in service of the other if given half a chance that warm glow we get when we even pick up a pencil for another I mean absolutely crying out for that to be Unleashed but the point at which we need

our organizations because we have the mother of all issues going on we need our organizations to be unleashing the meaningful Works repurpose driven organizations into in order to solve these problems is the point at which we are still doing the opposite and we have to grasp my main messages we don't grasp that we don't grasp this I I really think we're not going to get that so I'm

not going to just zoom in on this Meso Level because it's it's the unlock for the micro level and also the macro level and to do that I'm going to use a modified daily triangle so Hermann Daly was perhaps the original ecological Economist he worked very closely with danella Meadows who you may know from MIT who wrote limits to growth amongst other things are very very clever

systems thinker who's written extensively on the topic and both of them came to the conclusion that this triangle or an earlier version of it is the best way yes this triangle is the best way to encapsulate what it is to have a a sustainable economy now they operated at that macro level that sort of policy making governmental governance level but what the work that I have been doing

in terms of observing I'm merely a funnel for what I believe we're all saying is to take that and adapt it to the Meso Level because ultimately the Meso Level is is is nested within this larger level and they're all part of the economy so I don't know if you can I hope you can see the words on there I'm going to take us through it briefly if not please do just

say and you don't have to look at me you can you can look at the slide so maybe just I'll just pause there if you want to put your hand up if you'd like to see the slides bigger yeah okay great because it's important and you can you don't really need to look at me for this bit so what we have and the key Insight

from daily was that the unsustainable economy is essentially locked into the middle of the triangle and what that means is that we are focused the ends of the economy and by extension the ends the goals of organizations are fixed on essentially financial and manufactured Capital these are derived capitals and the key way what we then account for and govern and manage as the key resource to do that is also financial and

manufactured capital so if we think about all the systems everything that the law what that points us to what it says the role of business is how we're governed the the systems that the legal structures they all sit around this middle of the triangle because what we essentially have said to business and organizations is you focus on that and of course and I don't have time to go to

it now I'm sure you know it's because of the assumptions we have about how the market machine will just therefore do its thing and well-being will pop out at the end so we've focused our Innovation nerve center on this middle of the triangle in doing that that means that the ends of the economy long-term well-being for all are out of sight but more than that you could even say they

were off limits because the way that we understand the assumptions of the market economy are the organizations shouldn't be concerned with well-being directly they shouldn't be trying to measure it influence it because that would be a market failure actually what organization should be doing is reading preferences in the mind market and then delivering on them of course the issue is that that system is co-opted particularly within marketing because

there's no way of regulating and curtailing the self-interest motive in order to manipulate those preferences so there's a huge amount of power especially in what I will say is a post-modern economy not going into that but it's critical because the power without responsibility of organizations to shape Society is massive but what is also so not just is the Innovative goal out of sights so we are not pointing our organizations in the

Innovative efficient effective Direction but what's at the bottom of the triangle is off-balance sheet now this is when people talk about sustainability this is the bit they tend to focus on so one of the key points is that we have to look at the whole but this is a really critical point that the natural human and Social Capital the non-financial capitals have been off balance sheet and

we know that their externalities and that is the Frantic work that's going on at the moment with ESG reporting Etc in order to try to do a couple of key things to get those non-financial capitals onto the balance sheet in some way shape or form and I mean even even before ESG I mean the sense that you know you're you as an organization rely on these other

capitals and you really should understand whether they in a healthy state of stocks and flows but this is not something you're obliged to do so it's always been in fact the law in many ways has kind of curtailed and made that difficult to do because we've been forced into the middle of the triangle but what sits beneath that sort of organizational level stocks and flows or of course these base environmental and

social systems that are the base value on which everything else is built and that could be social cohesion trust you know we don't value these things but they are systematically being undermined as well as of course the whole Suite and that is not just climate change and we need to get very real about this that in their Falls we could take planetary boundaries donor economics which draws

from planetary boundaries we could take the sdgs because they're mostly an expression of thresholds and what really we're talking about here is a sense of multiple issues from water scarcity antimicrobial resistance soil erosion ocean acidification air pollution climate change biodiversity loss these are multiple issues that have been perpetuated over time as we have not valued these core assets and so there's a scramble to try to do some

thing and the key message I I have is that if we and we'll go into this I think in the Q a is that we don't get real about that and we don't put all of the issues on the table at once then we are going to be Reinventing and Reinventing our business models and that is going to be very painful in fact I think we'll just kill organizations in

bureaucracy anyway so again we'll come to that what we have are organizations and maybe you fall into that category maybe as issuers maybe as investors because you're also organizations of course as well as choosing who you invest in where we are now moving to a sense of we need to move to the long term so The Narrative of long-term decision making this is the issue everything else about the market

economy and business as usual thinking about it is fine the well-being machine works but what we need to do is to think long term because if we think long term then we can create a business case for bringing and distributing investment and value in order to create the health of these means and I think that is absolutely critical it brings in stakeholderism stakeholder capitalism starts to come in

here because you actually start to care about the health of your stakeholders instrumentally in order for your long-term Financial self-interest but what's also going on beyond that is that some organizations in seeing the wood for the trees in seeing the bigger picture that I presented earlier are saying you know what I don't think that a financial business case is a motivating enough for ourselves and our stakeholders and B is going to give us

the expansive Innovation context in order to be able to really be front foot and Tackle these issues so yes we need to do the compliance around thresholds at the bottom of the triangle and I'd say to again that is something I don't think we've really absorbed that properly even many purpose-driven organizations but what organizations that are purpose-driven are doing is saying no we are going to actively move

our strategic clinical line of sight from Financial income and so from our self-interest to other serving interests and finance is a critical or let's say Financial capital is an absolutely critical means to that end but it stops being an end in itself which of course violence can never be an end in itself It Is by default a a symbolic good before I continue I just want to

check Hamish because my timer stopped how many minutes do I have yeah we have about five minutes left so we're gonna have to cruise through yeah that's fine no no I've said the major things so this this is this is good so so so the reality is that we then need to get really serious about what we mean if we if we want to bring about

a purpose-driven well-being economy serviced by purpose-driven organizations and unleashing meaningful work and meaningful lives then we need to govern it and we and the two key areas we need to focus on are governance and marketing including as Finance organizations because governance sets the frame it sets the direction the ends and the parameters for decision making we're at the bottom of the triangle that's the direction part it does the oversight as

to whether that's working and it's accountable for that but you can have all the structure in the world you then need to deliver it through Innovation in partnership with stakeholders and that's where marketing not in the sales version which is in itself a consequence of being in the middle of the triangle but Marketing in its full sense of value generation and so luckily we have been at work globally to

start to pin down these accountability frames where we can start to get clearer about that and maybe you could just go to the the previous slide a second so if that's okay thank you which is to say that one of the and I have another slide in a second on this we talked about pas808 on purpose-driven organizations and in it it's a wealth of things and I really

if nothing else because this should be going to ISO level within the next few months we hope and I'll be doing process and this is the opportunity to mobilize and activate the world in a very action-oriented way to say what does Paz 808 but expressed as a world what does the Improvement of that look like what is the gold standard of governing and managing for a well-being economy and

the definition that's in Paz 808 which will go up for Global scrutiny is that an organizational purpose but you could say project individual team Department brand is a reason to exist that is an optimal strategic contribution to the long-term well-being of all people and planets so you get that strategic alignment next slide thanks and so but precursor a precursor to that British standard in Purpose Driven

organizations was that sort of broader frame around governance it like I say it took five years there were 77 countries involved 25 liaison include Liaisons including many International organizations that you will know including un bodies and others and it was signed off eventually by 164 countries you can see here the map of those who are involved and it essentially puts purpose as the primary principle at the center with 10 other

principles that work to around that as a coherent governance system again I really encourage you to look at that it's sort of triple lock sustainability and it's the first time that we have an understanding of governance in really quite detailed practical terms that is relevant for any organization from one person to the largest organization to government to Charities to whatever in all parts of the world so we have

language that also works for all parts of the world so I do encourage you to lean on that okay so moving then down to two slides please or like let's go down one so yes maybe just up one a second I'll just show you that's the you can look at Paz 808 that's that's what it's called and interestingly it starts with World Views not just principles because it's all

very well and good to say let's apply some principles but if your fundamental assumptions about the world do not align you're unlikely to so I think you'll should find that interesting as well for yourselves and the people that you're investing in and then next slide please I'm almost there so you might want to expand this one this just to give you a sense of what's out there there's but and at the end of

this presentation are lots of things you can delve into lots of writing and evidence that I have to help you unpick this further but this was a really interesting survey now it's a diet one of those Dynamic surveys so you click on that link now and they've changed it but this is what it was in 2020 and they surveyed at 1 300 CEOs globally to ask them which of the following

best describes your view of the overall objective of your organization so this is a sense of to what extent do people in logic one the middle of the triangle in logic two middle and bottom enlightened self-interest long-term self-interest or in purpose and we can see there quite clearly that we have the are actually in the enlightened perspective so and I'm just checking that the figures so 69 said that they

want to embed purpose in everything they do to create long-term value and we know under business as usual that means financial value actually 11 only 11 were saying that they their primary overall objective was to deliver economic returns to stake shareholders and a 21 were leaning into purpose that their primary objective was to was public interest and to improve Society so this is a very interesting sense of anonymously what CEOs will say

that they think they're doing I think this gives a sense of where we're going so I'll finish there I think I'm on time that was another five minutes it's a set of provocations but it comes from Deep observation of what I've seen happening in the past where we are but also where I genuinely think we are going but that we need to go at speed and I think we'll cover this in a minute

but we really need Finance to be in to be leading this because as you can see it's financed that in many ways is in the driving states seat of a hyper financialized