Canadian Securities ExchangeThe Daily Bell

Beau Whitney on Data-driven Economic Models for Cannabis

November 16, 2022

About This Video

The CSE’s Barrington Miller is joined by Beau Whitney, Founder of Whitney Economics, to discuss data-driven trends in cannabis globally, including US legalization, emerging markets, and environmental, social, and governance (ESG). The conversation also addresses how Whitney Economics uses data to help cannabis operators navigate the industry.

Here's an overview of what Barrington and Beau discuss in this edition of The Exchange for Entrepreneurs Podcast:

00:00 – Introduction

02:00 – Global trends in the cannabis industry

03:28 – The cannabis industry in Canada and the US

07:05 – How do American cannabis companies differ from coast to coast? How is the industry shaped by state legislation?

11:33 – How do ESG (environmental and social governance) mandates tie into the valuation of multi-state operators?

14:40 – Is the current economic data contributing to the liberalization of cannabis policy in the US?

16:52 – What are the data points that have shifted over the last 7 years?

19:32 – Have there been any surprising individuals, organizations, and corporations that have reached out to collaborate?

22:59 – Within the business of data, who are Whitney Economics’ competitors and/or collaborators?

24:29 – Key findings from the business report that Whitney Economics published in 2020

Subscribe for more great CSE insights and interviews here: https://go.thecse.com/CSETV-Subscribe

STAY CONNECTED WITH THE CSE

=============================

- NEWSLETTER: https://go.thecse.com/CSE-Mailing-List-Subscribe

- PODCAST: https://blog.thecse.com/cse-podcasts/

- INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/canadianexchange/

- LINKEDIN: https://ca.linkedin.com/company/canadian-securities-exchange

- FACEBOOK: https://www.facebook.com/CanadianSecuritiesExchange/

- TWITTER: https://twitter.com/CSE_News

- BLOG: https://blog.thecse.com/

- WEBSITE: https://thecse.com/

- MAGAZINE: https://issuu.com/thecse/docs

Read the TranscriptAuto-generated by YouTube; names and terms may be misspelled.

hi my name is Barrington Miller director of issuer engagement at the Canadian Securities Exchange and today I'm here with Paul Whitney from Whitney economics and this is part of the Canon for the Cannabis investor series and I wanted to talk to Bo because one he's a really nice guy but two I find what he does fascinating bo please tell the people what it is you do where you're from a

little bit about your background and why you're here yeah sure so Whitney economics provides cannabis-centric economic data analysis and Consulting Services to folks in this space either on the adult use and medical side or on the hemp side and we have a global global clientele and basically what we do is there's so little data out there that's really reliable so my firm goes out tracks down

what's good what's bad that's it and then we produce customized reports some general reports and the like and we offer that as a service to the Cannabis industry and we're based out of Portland Oregon Portland is one of the meccas of cannabis going back generations and I just happen to enter into the space about eight years ago just by random chance I was teaching

an economics course at the University level and a student mentioned the Cannabis industry and at piqued my curiosity and the rest is kind of History I do have experience in the Cannabis industry I ran a or I was the CEO of a cannabis related company that was had ownership in Canada but operations in the U.S and we were fortunate enough to be one of the first if not the first to go public on the CSE

that is a great story and yes and it's all true Let's let's let's talk about the big picture what what are you seeing globally and then we'll sort of break it down into North America what are you seeing globally as far as cannabis is the trend still this is it plateauing is it coming down countries are seeing the economic opportunities associated with cannabis and cannabis is

generically defined it could be industrial cannabis it could be medical cannabis it could be adult use or lifestyle cannabis but regardless of how you define it countries are seeing the potential of this they're seeing it in terms of climate change they're seeing it in terms of alternative fuels they're seeing it in terms of a way in which to reduce Healthcare expenditures to gain access to hard currencies

like in Africa and so there's a lot of for for various reasons a lot of these countries are seeing the economic benefits of deploying legal cannabis in their country country and the pace of that deployment is starting to accelerate you're starting to see it on practically every continent now and so and I've been fortunate enough to have access to those countries and then I've been providing data and

insights and and hopefully some sound guidance to help them transition from you know in a legal regulatory environment to a legal one now what about a little bit closer to home North America we can talk let's let's talk about the US and because I think we know what's going on at least in Canada a lot of grow-ups a lot of oversupply I think Canada burned 468 tons of

unpackaged cannabis last year in 2021 which was up 50 percent versus the year before so yeah it was over 200. this is not good this is not we're not heading in the right direction as far as that and we need to Reign that in when I first started looking into the Canadian Market this was right in the run-up towards their legalization and deployment and you could see the writing on the

wall you could see the massive amount of plan capacity and installed capacity and I think at that time they were positioning the Canadian firms were positioning themselves to enter in to the U.S market in a big way and so but the timing was off unfortunately and so all that plan capacity all of that supply and the like needed to go somewhere because of course it was greater than the total amount

that could be consumed in the Canadian domestic market and so they started looking for other opportunities and so you started seeing you know Partnerships in South Africa or you started seeing Partnerships in in Germany or in the European Union but even with those Partnerships it wasn't enough to satisfy all that supply and and consume all that supply and so then unfortunately you know this is kind of what what is

happening now contrast that to the United States I I think it's a it's a it's a joke around the United States that for the last eight years cannabis Federal legalization is five years away and so so yeah everything's still it's still five years away it's still five years yeah and so that's been the mantra for eight years now but and and so there's as a result of

that lack of federal legalization each state has had to deploy their individualized markets where you have to set up an entire infrastructure the supply the product manufacturing the retail the regulations and all that and so what I'm seeing in the United States is those that legalize early like Oregon or Colorado or Washington they're starting to Peak they've satisfied about as much demand as they that as they can

unless they do something like adjust their taxation or make greater access or lower the price or what have you but where the market is moving in the United States is more towards these emerging states that are just now starting to deploy their legal programs so legal states such as as New York New Jersey I mean those just legalized and they're just starting to stand up their regulatory programs but

it's going to take a while for them to really hit their stride no it's we're we're keeping a very close eye on New York for several reasons that seems to be the the Bellwether culturally spiritually economically it's it's at the it's at the intersection and well you know you've got you've got New York and Massachusetts and Florida on one side Pennsylvania is a pretty enticing

Market as well once they go transition away from medical and into adult use but you know don't underestimate the power of California on the west coast no no no no no no no no no no trouble no problem no California California is actually the the old New York if you can make it there you can make it anywhere yeah it's yeah and what what we're

seeing is there's a battle of it's a battle of Brands almost because now you have California brands that want to come to New York but they're not trying to displace the New York Brands but the New York brands are the ones that are in control because if they if they don't like you you're done then simple as that and there is brand Big Time brand loyalty going on a majority of the supply that's

produced in the United States actually comes from California and so there's this massive export Market my firm put together a supply report that looks at legal and illicit Supply looks at it from the canopy perspective it looks at it from greenhouse and indoor and outdoor so we have this really full picture of the entire supply of cannabis in the United States and and so there's this massive export Market out of

California that satiates the demand in New York in Florida and elsewhere and it's really interesting that while California and Oregon Colorado are really good at cultivation on the East Coast the real skill set there is on the distribution and Retail side and so I think ultimately as the market matures and full Federal legalization or at least some interstate commerce is allowed you're going to see Supply from

the West being distributed in the east and this is all this is all a legal Market this is all a great Market or whatever you want to call it yeah you know in 2021 there was roughly 25 billion dollars of legal sales and but that's out of about 105 billion dollar total market and so that 80 or so billion dollars in 2021 was satisfied through illicit or Legacy channels

now that's the Legacy Market isn't going away and I I've been arguing this for a number of years now I think the Legacy Market needs needs to stay it needs to be that that checks and balances that keeps everyone even Keel I mean yes eventually down down down the road but especially in California if you if you're if you if the taxes are too high on on cannabis

then you'll see a massive turn to the gray Market simple I mean that's how they were figuring out all right 18 no no no way too high ten percent okay it's livable 12 I'm not quite we're going back and so I I found it I found it really really interesting yeah my firms actually calculated the elasticity of demand and so you know consumers are willing

to to pay a premium to do things in the in the legal Market but they're just not willing to pay too much of a premium and so they like the idea of of tested Goods of relatively Safe products and the like Brands and and some type of control but if the pricing differential between legal market and the in the list of Market is too great if that pricing

differential then they'll just remain in the in the illicit market and this is really really predictable I was able to actually analyze multiple states where there was a pricing change or a change in taxes and what that would do to the legal sales and I was able to nail those numbers almost exactly I mean that's how predictable it is why one of the things that we deal with at the Canadian

Security exchange is of course Investments and investors and people looking to get into how do I get into cannabis and I want to get into cannabis there's three little letters that keep popping up over the last couple years and they ESG and there's a number of ESG mandates that are out there how does ESG tie in to The multi-state Operators and when valuing these multi-state operators

well right now the the whole concept of ESG environmental social and governance is it's just starting to take off and so I think the infrastructure is starting to be developed and and promulgated so that people can understand really what this is but there is really compelling data out there that shows if there are firms that are environmentally conscious and have programs associated with social equity and social justice and have a

good governance a good board that is that values these Concepts the data shows that these companies generally have greater success in the marketplace and it's almost as though there's a multiplier associated with and I haven't calculated that multiplier quite yet but there's actually a multiplier that shows if you have ESG programs if you're environmentally and socially aware have good strong governance then it's going to benefit not only the company but the investors

and the stakeholders in that firm that's that's something that we were seeing as well of two companies are equal and one has an ASG program and one doesn't the one with the program will get more money or we'll get money versus not getting money yeah and some of the environmental impacts of adult use and and medical are pretty significant and those are mandated by The Regulators you know like

plastic packaging I mean there's just this plastic crisis and and it's just it's horrible environmentally but there are paths where if you know adult use companies team up with plant-based plastic companies especially in the hemp industry then they can combine their resources and address the environmental issues while standing up both sides of the THC industry right so there's lots of opportunities and I think that the industries are just now

that there's an awareness out there of ESG now that there's a greater sensitivity towards environmental issues and social issues I think now you're starting to see opportunities present themselves in the marketplace now is this is this economic data contributing to the liberalization of cannabis policy in the United States well I think right now there's been so little data in the United States at the federal level there's there are

these things called NYX Codes North American industrial classification codes and they helped track the flow of goods and services throughout the US economy because cannabis is federally illegal there are really no NYX codes and if they are they're very very general in nature and so it's very difficult to track the flow on goods and services throughout the economy but when you do dig into the data and that's why I have

a team behind me that does this great work and they're just very diligent in tracking this stuff down you know once you track that then you can see the trends and you can see where the opportunities exist you know I mentioned my Supply report earlier you know I had a team of analysts on on at my firm look at the canopy of the legal canopy of the United

States by state and we could identify how much output is associated with that canopy and whether or not they're in a over you know Supply position or an under Supply position and so what that would tell investors is well if you're over supplied prices are going to go down margins are going to be compressed and like maybe that's not a state that you want to invest in

and so that's how we're using data to help investors and policy makers I've given the the policy makers a model that basically says here are the number of licenses that you need in a given state to satisfy the demand at various stages of your ramp right so a lot of this stuff helps not only investors you know be set up better for success but it's also helping Regulators do a

better job of not getting into those positions in the first place and I want to piggyback off of the some of the data and tracking over the past say seven years what data points have shifted as as our understanding of the industry has improved as it's evolved as it's gotten better what was there seven years ago that isn't or vice versa well I think data has been used to more effectively

look at Public Safety and serve as a tool for law enforcement you know and so in that sense there's been a little bit more control over the industry but it's also helped assuage the fears of a lot of a lot of the opponents of cannabis legalization for example I've been presenting some data on crime statistics and so while there's some evidence that shows that there may be some criminal

elements you know when when you deploy cannabis in a community with all of the security measures with all the cameras crime in those areas actually goes down and by through the legal reform the closure rate of other crimes hard crimes you know human trafficking you know Murder rape Etc the closure rate of those increases and so that means that more crimes more hard crimes are solved and then there's

data out there to look at the impact on Health Care opiates the amount of opioid prescriptions pain relief and and sales of prescription drugs associated with pain so this data is starting to slowly enter in become more standardized and and then it's beneficial to you know help articulate what the issues are associated with legalization you know are there bad things that happen sure but a lot of times the people just

don't understand the impact that's positive in nature and once they see the data then they're a little bit more open towards reform and so that's the role that data is played and how it's evolved over time is it's just been now that there's a a larger body of work then people are using that body of work to help address some of the questions answer the

questions through education you know where you know there just hasn't been Data before I'm gonna shift gears just a tiny little bit is there anybody who's reached out to you or tried to employ your services who I I guess it would be you just didn't see it coming or you were completely shocked that this person group organization branch government country reached out to you and that actually surprised you is

there has that happened yeah and that you're allowed to say you know I there's been some multinational corporations for example that said hey we've been following your work for a long time and we want to engage on a deep dive analysis that's relative you know that's it's important for their for their businesses either through investment through acquisition analysis through market analysis and Market

entry strategies and so I've been starting to get some of the really large multinational firms you know coming on board and that's been you know whenever that happens I give the team a call and I say hey look folks you you made this happen you know a lot of the hard work that's gone in some folks that have been on my team for a while you know they're working really

hard and I try to celebrate those successes with them because they're the backbone of the success of my firm right so so yeah I've been surprised others you know there's been some surprises from left field as well on the negative side some people are you know they maybe don't like the fact that I'm I take a neutral position I don't advocate for any set policy or anything I just you

know I don't take a position on legalization or anything and so when I do this analysis it's sometimes it rubs people the wrong way and so but when people are sending both positive and negative feedback I think I might be doing something right that's exactly what you want you're right down the middle you don't want either side to only one side to love the love the report

and there's been instances where where I've said hey look I'm going to do this analysis and I'll present the results as I see it based upon the data and I'm not gonna bias it for you know your goals and you know kind of you get what you get and for some folks for most almost like 99 they're like yeah that's cool that's that's just what

we want but then for some there said no no I want you to change the messaging or I want you to bias it you know in favor of us and I'm like I'm sorry I just won't do that and so I'm always up front at the beginning of an engagement that says hey I'm just going to do this and you get what you get and you don't throw a

fit you know as we used to say to our children it's awkward and and if people don't want that then I'm happy not to engage with them quite frankly one of my my last Point like we've talked about data and and the business yeah you're in the business of data what are your competitors peers what are they like do they reach out to you do you talk

do you collaborate do you kind of just stay in your own Lanes how does that work well I try to share my data and insights with everybody regardless of if they're a competitor or not I think it only strengthens the industry and strengthens the data and the narrative and so I try to collaborate as much as possible there's some some groups that you know keep things behind the

paywall and I do you know with some of my data as well but and generally I'm I'm pretty open I think the time for that real hardcore competitive spirit it's not quite there yet with the Cannabis industry and so we need to collaborate and you know some people have specialized in other areas and so there are some swim Lanes being developed but I tend to be more on the here's

what the data says now and here's what it's looking like for your future and that's kind of what's differentiating me right now there's not a whole lot of data folks out there that makes these predictions about the future they tend to say what happened in the past what's going on in the in the current you wrote a paper or published a report in 2021 do you want to Let's

let's talk a little bit about that what were some of the findings it was the one that you shared with with some of the members of CSE but was that the one on the related to the business conditions and business sentiment yeah you know a lot of there's been a lot of reform proposals in the U.S Congress there's reforms going on internationally as well

and but there hasn't been a whole lot of well what does the industry say about this stuff you know and so what I did is I put out a survey a business condition survey to as many licensed operator in the United States as I get older and we got a really overwhelming response it was great and now we're trying to do this every quarter

and so similar to what I contribute on into some of the mainstream economic groups that I'm a member of throughout the United States and internationally and because business conditions predictions right it it's you know that's what people want what was really interesting was that in the United States there wasn't a whole lot of profitability being gleaned from the Cannabis industry it's kind of a counter

narrative everybody thinks that people are rolling in the dough but in fact they're actually struggling and part of the struggle is operational efficiency part of about a majority of the struggle is based upon federal policy you know lack of access to financial services lack of access to you know stock markets and so that's why the CSE has been so great in terms of providing that service to those that otherwise don't have

access to financial services so that's a tremendous service that you guys are providing and it shows up in the data oh is the top concern for cannabis operators in the United States is access to financial services and Banking and then another one was just heavy Taxation and so but this has been a narrative throughout the industry for a number of years but there's never been any data behind it and so that was

the goal of my firm was to go out talk to people get the data roll it up and then and then publish it out so I literally gave the report out for free to anybody that really wanted it including policy makers and including regulators and including operators and investors in the space oh well that's that's a smart play and that's a smart way to do it Bo I I just want to say thank you

every time we talk I learn so much more on behalf of the Canadian Securities Exchange on behalf of the the Cannabis investor series which you can find on YouTube csctv also check us out on social media this has been great like normally we talk with obviously we talk with our issuers and we'll talk with lawyers and bankers and financiers and investors but this is an opportunity now to talk with

somebody who really has a neutral position and makes decisions solely on what the data is telling you so we really really appreciate your insights how can people find you just yeah so I have it's a whitneyeconomics.com and you can contact me via that website and so I get notifications when people inquire if they have a quotation that they want I do some expert witness

testimony in legal trials and so you know attorneys will reach out investors will reach out and so that's really and then I put a fair amount of data to download or to purchase on the site but then I have a lot more behind the scenes that's available as well so really the best way is just to engage on the website I'll give you a call or part of

my team will give you a call and then we'll just go from there I've been your host Barrington Miller from the Canadian Securities Exchange and I was with Bo Whitney founder of Whitney economics foreign