Canadian Securities ExchangeThe Daily Bell

How Fintech is Shaping Sustainable Investments

Summit on Responsible Investment 2024

November 22, 2024Summit on Responsible Investment

About This Video

As part of the Canadian Securities Exchange's Summit on Responsible Investment, Anna Serin (CSE) and Nawar Asaaldi (Kanata Advisors) explore the evolving world of sustainable investing. They unpack key trends like the maturing use of ESG, challenges from geopolitical events like the Russia-Ukraine conflict, and the push for more reliable and comparable ESG data. Nawar highlights the rise of AI and innovative tech transforming ESG analysis and engagement—making sustainable investing smarter, faster, and more impactful.

Key Highlights:

Maturing ESG Integration:

While there's been a slight decline in investors incorporating ESG factors, the approach has grown more sophisticated—focusing on meaningful integration into investment processes.

Geopolitics Matter:

Events like the Russia-Ukraine conflict have had significant implications for sustainable investment strategies.

Regulation Drives Standardization:

Frameworks like IFRS and CSRD are transforming ESG data into more standardized, comparable insights.

Smart Data Use:

Investors are increasingly leveraging ESG data to assess risks and opportunities—moving beyond simple classifications.

Retail vs. Institutional Approaches:

Differences in how sustainable investing is embraced by institutional and retail investors reveal unique opportunities.

Tech Innovations:

Kanata Advisors is working on cutting-edge tools to automate and streamline ESG data analysis and engagement, making it easier for investors to make impactful decisions.

This conversation showcased the evolving landscape of sustainable investing—and the exciting possibilities ahead!

Subscribe for more great CSE insights and interviews here: https://go.thecse.com/CSETV-Subscribe

STAY CONNECTED WITH THE CSE

=============================

- NEWSLETTER: https://go.thecse.com/CSE-Mailing-List-Subscribe

- PODCAST: https://blog.thecse.com/cse-podcasts/

- INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/canadianexchange/

- LINKEDIN: https://ca.linkedin.com/company/canadian-securities-exchange

- FACEBOOK: https://www.facebook.com/CanadianSecuritiesExchange/

- TWITTER: https://twitter.com/CSE_News

- BLOG: https://blog.thecse.com/

- WEBSITE: https://thecse.com/

- MAGAZINE: https://issuu.com/thecse/docs

Read the TranscriptAuto-generated by YouTube; names and terms may be misspelled.

hi my name is Anna sarin I'm director of listings development with the Canadian Securities Exchange and you're joining us today as part of our Summit on responsible investment online series I am joined today by Noir assal he is the founder and CEO of Canada advisors an ESG fintech advisory firm based in Toronto Canada operates at the intersection of Finance sustainability and Technology thank you so much for

joining us today Noir hello Anna it's a pleasure to be with you today well it's very exciting so the semone responsible investment just to give everyone a little bit of a background is an initiative that we started last year in 2023 and carrying it online this year in 2024 is really the idea of creating thought leadership content and education as well as highlighting some of our issuers in the

space this very fast quick evolving growing space in the markets around sustainability around U you know sustainable Investments and around the ESG side of the space that we're seeing in all different sectors Noir if you could just tell us a little bit about yourself your journey and what led you to create canidate advisors sure happy to do so so my my investment career dates back to the

late 90s I mean I if we really go back I was a day trader back in my teens so I I've been looking at markets for a long time but I would say for the purposes of this conversation I think the period that's really really relevant to us is the last 15 years or so where I've been focused on the sustainable investing side initially around 29 sorry 2009 or 2010 I was

more in the I would say activist investing Camp I would take large position in companies and engage with them around their corporate governance and their corporate strategy and I would say that was my first entry into ESG through the venue of the G side or the governance side over time I created a company around that concept of engaging with companies on their corporate governance and and strategy

called simper gustus Capital that was in 2014 at that point I expanded a bit further the prview of ESG issues I integrated in my investment Pro process to the climate and the social side to some extent and what I say I expanded I think it's important to highlight that for me and for a lot of sustainable investment professionals it's a learning journey I mean you introduce one data

point and maybe two data points and then you try to understand how that potentially expands or shrinks your Universe whether it leads to better returns or or or doesn't make a difference so I did manage that company for a number of years and ultimately I decided to go to the institutional space because I felt on a personal level I wanted to drive a larger impact I

wanted to merge my passion for investing in finance with a larger portfolio I mean I was managing still a relatively a small amount of capital for myself and a and a and a small group of investors so when I went to the institutional space I was able to oversee billions of dollars of capital first with Nei Investments which is the largest all this ethical

investment firm in Canada where they manage about 10 or 11 billion I was the director of ESG insights and from there I moved to the asset Doner space to Canada Post pension plan I still have the poster behind me where I was senior portfolio manager for ESG investing and and and during that period specifically when I was at Canada Post I oversaw about $16 billion dollar in

publicly traded assets and was focusing on decarbonization and in terms of aligning our public portfolios with Net Zero and that's really I I would say was the starting point for me to think about the creation of Canada advisers because what I did notice during that period is that although Canada Post was very interested in aligning its portfolios with Net Zero a lot of the underlying technologies that we needed

to do so were not there so on mainstream Finance you have Bloomberg you have fact sets you have risk models you have portfolio optimization tools on the climate and ESG side we didn't have enough tools or sophisticated tools to do so so I decided to make the leap to the startup space to exist in that intersection of Finance sustainability and technology in order to help startup companies develop tools that investors

can use to be better sustainable investors as well as corporate clients who may use these Technologies to manage their sustainable transformation so anyways that's an nutshell the last 20 years of my journey that's that's quite the nutshell Noir you know I was thinking it's interesting that you say that you became an activist in 2009 so just to bring people back to what happened in 2008 as we had the

major Global financial crisis so what an interesting time to get involved in the space in that role was ESG and sustainable investing something that the broader Market even understood yeah that's a great question and and if you go back back to 2008 and you think about the financial CR crisis governance was a big problem a lot of financial institution didn't have proper incentives didn't have proper

alignment between stakeholders that's how I really got interested into the g- side of things because I did notice that companies and large and systematically important companies can literally blow up if they don't have proper governance as well as risk management which often kind of ties back into into a proper governance structures so that to me personally was the trigger to look at governance as a

way to unlock value and manage risk in companies and in my portfolio but in terms of the ESG movement itself it dates back to prior to the financial crisis I mean there was a simal document that was published by the UN in 2004 called who cares wins and it it it kind of puts the it outlined the initial tenants of of

ESG investing it's why investors need to care about the E about the S about the G and how it does how these elements help unlike values so I was not really looking into it or or really didn't really care that much about that side of things until the financial crisis which in a way brought to to the Forefront topics that were highlighted several years prior by the ASG by by the

Pioneers in the SG movement I think it's very interesting you know mentioning what happened in 2008 that really governance was perhaps the most critical part of that ESG component that was really at risk and kind of the activism and its need for that one question I have for you before we kind of dive into this is that I feel like there's been a shift in as we have this conversation

today in 2024 around using the word or the acronym ESG has that shifted recently for us in the space I think to some extent it did shift and that's largely because of the nthg movement in the United States there was a lot of push around the acronym so companies or financial institutions they they steering away to some extent from ESG but it's it's really a change of label there's nothing

really changing under the hood a lot of investors are using the term sustainable sustainable investing if you look at corporate reporting in terms of the publication of ESU or sustainability reports ESG and sustainability are still the two most widely used terms so there is a shift but I wouldn't call the shift important Beyond kind of labeling exercise so we're still able to use it that's

good to know yeah absolutely yes we can okay so what I'd love to dive into is I just like to know from your perspective what are some of the key trends that we've seen as I mentioned in the introduction we did this event last year in person in Colona and there were some very key trends that were happening within the space What are some of the key trends that you're seeing in

2024 well actually I published earlier this year in April this year the sustainable business codium which is available on Canada advisor's website for free there are about 150 slides on the state of sustainable business and that includes a section on sustainable investing and what we're seeing is that there is there's a obviously we touched on the changing language around ESG and sustainability so that's still ongoing there is a

degree I would say of marginal Retreat within institutional investors to in terms of the the the integration or the implementation of ESG consideration then investment process so to give you an order of magnitude in 2022 we were at about 86 or 88% of asset owners integrating ESG in the investment process and I refer to asset owners because a lot flows from there asset managers in a way try to

accommodate what asset owners want and in 2023 80% of asset owners are integrating ASG factors so there's been a slight decline in the number of investors integrating theg strategies I would say the a notable trend is that I think there is a growing maturity around what sustainable investing means we're moving away from the greenwashing and the grandos commitments and and investors are getting more sophisticated in the

way they integrate ESG factor in the investment process what I mean more sophisticated is there are there there are there are certain Frameworks that are being integrated there are better technology is being used to assess data and capture data and Shar share findings the talent the the the the the the training or the skills within financial institutions in terms of how they can integrate ESG in a in an added

additive way that adds to financial results is improving as we move forward year after year and and also the regulation has really also advanced in many countries so we see the SEC they came with their climate disclosure regulation now it's it's it's being challenged but they finally publish a final document Europe is moving ahead we see the SC the csrd which although it's focused on the corporate side it

has massive implications for investors as they look for comparable and validated data that they could use in their investment processes and we see that Canada is also moving in the direction of integrating IFRS into a framework although still working progress so we're seeing progress in terms of Regulation we're seeing an evolution of language and we we're also seeing an evolution in how investors understand and apply and

and ultimately manage their investment portfolios with ESG not being as an add-on but as an integral part of the process I think you know you touched on something that's that's really valuable there because I I know that there's been lots of I've had lots of internal discussions with our regulatory framework in Canada as well as as the exchange and then I know our issuers are you know managing their disclosure

requirements under IFRS as you mentioned which for those of you that don't know is basically the platform that we have created in Canada that's different than gap for accounting and auditing purposes so how public companies disclose data points within their company we use a system called IFRS and that's where a lot of the stuff will get included into that some of that data you know this this goes all

the way from the top all the way down to the bottom of the the final investor of how they review the data that is that is mandated to be disclosed for their investment purposes this is a big this is a big shift that's happening within the markets and this is happening in the senior markets and the junior markets I in the meantime I feel like we're all running around scrambling trying to

adjust to the new information and how we use it wouldn't you say yeah I mean this is new to a lot of people and and I think Regulators are also experimenting with regulation I mean we see for example sfdr in in in Europe around around creating sustainable investment products they're labeled under article eight or article nine that's the kind of jargon often use this for example this labeling regime

which has been used for the last five or years or so is evolving as well because Regulators for example in Europe have re they've realize that this is not an efficient way to guide the creation of sustainable investment products so when I when you say people as scrambling it's it's basically there's this there's this Chinese saying that says you cross the river by feeling the stones and every every stakeholder is

feeling their way across this process and sometimes you know you you you you make a wrong step so so I I think that's for for an industry that large and so systematically important I think that's that's a normal part of the process as we learn how to integrate ESG in a nondisruptive way and to your point we're all Crossing that River together I think as a as an

ecosystem is there any major shifts that you think have or catalysts that you think have impacted or changed the space you know kind of within the recent years whether it's geopolitical or whether it's within the markets has there been any catalysts that have really pushed things further I think the a industry has been challenged by for example the the the Russian Ukrainian conflict has been

a big challenge for this industry U and the reason for that is there are two folds there are two I would say two ways to look at this the first one is around how investors view energy and energy security and to what extent investors should favor or disfavor the energy sector in in in in periods of political turmoil I mean we did have a

big reversal after a long bearish bar Market in the energy sector to some extent because of that conflict in Ukraine and and the way Russian oil was taken off the market so this challenged ESG investors to some extent to think about the short-term violent changes in the shortterm around certain sectors that are problematic from an environmental stand standpoint the other side of this is the defense sector the suddenly

Europe which has neglected its defense sector for a long time is investing hundreds of billions of dollar in defense and what does that mean for ESG investors who don't want to do harm so I do think these events around major changes in the energy Market moral kind of quandaries around how to support or not support the defense sector have introduced challenges to to sustainable

and ESG investors and each investor in a way is following their own logic and how they should integrate ESG in this context I don't think we have up to this point an agreement that okay that's the way to deal with that issue so I think this is this is a a an issue they'll probably deal with for the foreseeable future in terms of how to deal with

these unanswered questions yeah and I think you know more so than we ever have been in the history of time as far as capital markets are concerned we have the ability the very easy ability to invest in global markets more so than ever so we're investing in something that's happening in a very different jurisdiction where there's very different geopolitical forces that are that have movement so in a way it's

it's perhaps a much larger pool but we have a lot more options as far as where we where we place our investment dollars on that note maybe we could dive in a little bit further when you're kind of approaching various investment opportunities or you're adding to your due diligence Pro process what what metrics or ESG data do you apply to those decisions and where do

you find those first I I will say that I'm not proactively investing in the markets for my for you know I'm not managing money professionally for the time being since canat advisers work with companies or technology solution providers that are selling to asset managers and asset owners who are integrating ESG in their process so I can speak about this from two perspectives I can speak about my

own experience as a portfolio manager up to 22 can speak also about how clients of my clients are actually using technology to integrate ESG and ESG factors in their investment process so I would say the first phase of ESG investing was mostly a classification phase this company has high carbon this one has low carbon this one has a diverse Port this one doesn't have a diverse board it was relatively

simplistic we're entering a phase now where investors are although there are these key metrics they you're looking for some of these data points are being tie back to what we mentioned the IFRS disclosure requirement around sustainability metric so these are defined they tie back to saspi which is the sustainability accounting standard boards which was created in 2011 a lot of these metrics which focus on

financial materiality have been integrated in that Global regulation that the IFRS has created around sustainability which is called ifs S1 and S2 so investors are looking at the factors because they've been told that's where you need to look because corporations are told this is when you need to disclose we're seeing also the same thing with csrd csrd is encouraging the disclosure of in this

case it's more of a double materiality of how companies impact the environment or the world around them and how they're impacted by it so investors in a way they're governed by the availability of data so now when I say investors are looking at these data points they're not only look looking at how these data points are but they're not using them just only as a categorization or classification

tools they're trying to understand the alpha generation potential for these points the the risk that might be associated with a company that has for example a high turn employee turn turnover and one that doesn't have a high employee turnover they're trying to see if a company is committing to Net Zero what does that mean from its Financial from a from a financial standpoint if a company's exposed to the

sustainable energy transition how can they be aligned with that transition and yet also generate return so we we're having strategies that are a bit more nuanced and I I worked as a chief impact officer up to Mid 22 in between the creation of kada advisors and kapos with a firm called scope for Capital that was focused on climate impact and we looked at metrics that we call avoided emission

metrics or scope four emissions which are the that's the term that that it's a lot of investors less familiar with scope four than scope one or two and three and scope four emissions are what would be avoided if you were for example to invest in an electric car company and promote electric cars vis a you know ice cars or internal combustion engine cars so metrics like

this are are a little bit more exotic but has but they could be integrated in in a portfolio that is forward looking are metrics that are becoming more popular within at least I would say within sustainable investors we're trying to move beyond the classification phase so it is at the end of the day it's this is this is a very large Global industry and it operates at multiple

speeds but I would say that's the the direction of trouble for sustainable investing to exit all this political kind of noise around it it needs to actually dive deeper into integrated into integrating sustainability factors into an investment product process the same way you would integrate any other data point I mean at the end of the day I'll end up with this sustainability data is not something you put on a

pedestal it's just data and data has some data matters some other data doesn't matter some data some data points you can back test other you can you can't back test so the question is it's it's really about how ultimately investors use data data points to deliver on their fiducial responsibilities to manage risk and generate returns for their stakeholders so if we just look at it from that standpoint actually sustainability is

nothing special other than just additional data points that render the investment procer process richer and hopefully better I appreciate that sentiment not to put it on a pedestal but figure out you know what data points are important to you and and and a and a proper way to manage those do you mind just touching on maybe just breaking down scope one scope two scope three scope four for us yeah so I mean

scope one is just direct you know company emissions I mean you may have a building and that building is heated and therefore you know there are emissions that tied to that it's it's it's everything that is directly under your control now I mentioned heating well scop two missions ultimately ties back to where the energy is coming for example to heat your building is it

produced in a you know a Coal Power Plant on a gas power plant is it renewable energy so that becomes what we call scope two energy or scope two missions are tied to the energy that flows into your facilities scope three is is actually labeled as one category but there are 15 subcategories with it so it's it's it's about your Upstream supply chain it's about your

Downstream supply chain it's the whole value chain and and and it and and it it even includes the emissions associated with your employees and the way they come to work the emissions associated with the products that you're selling or the emissions tie that tie back to the the operations of your suppliers scope so it's almost like a secondary so you have your operations as

scope one you know kind of the the ripple effect exactly okay okay absolutely so it just get and it get larger and larger and I would say your degree of influence also dutes so you have direct control over your immediate emissions so let's say you have a factory you're you that that factory is I mean maybe you're using some kind of fuel you burning it in in in some

kind of oven or Machinery or some some sort the emission that directly that comes from that process are your scope one emissions but if you're buying electricity and then that's in a way under your control but not exactly you can change suppliers but you can't change the facilities where that energy is produced and then scope three are all indirect emissions that you that you're part of U the trick or the

challenge with scope three emissions is that your scope 3 emissions are somebody's else's scope one emissions so the challenge for investors is how do you look at that I mean how do you they don't want to double or triple or quadruple count the same emissions and then finally briefly touch on scope four emissions scope four emissions are this is this is really in a way it's a counterfactual so if I was

to if I have a choice between you know funding a natural gas plant and then I end up funding a solar you know solar farm then and the difference between the emissions that would have come from that kind of project and the solar farm becomes my avoided emissions I mean there is more to it there's something that we call a baseline or

Legacy emissions that this solution is replacing I mean if anybody is really curious about this they could go to a website called the crane Tool it's free and they can look at the avoided emissions of over 200 or 300 Solutions and it it will show them what that means in terms of market share and type of solution I mean it's a lot right it's a

lot to kind of process especially when you start getting further and further away from the original Source and a lot for investors to think about as they approach I know that you know I think what we're really seeing as a trend from us from the exchange perspective is you know I think people are starting to make consumer decisions that are different than they used to with a sustainable

approach and now they're wanting to apply that to their investment as well but it's trying to understand you know the degree of how far this goes and and what information is important I think one of my last questions as far as from the from the investment side is just curious you know I think there's a big shift when we see institutional investors approach the space versus the

retail investor and there's lots of times where they'll enter a space together at the same time or there's lots of times that one will lead the other down the beaten path what do you see as far as the institutional insertion into the space at this point and we're of course speaking in terms of the fact that the markets have been difficult over the past well so

it's not necessarily reflective but what has been the institutional movements you've seen so I I kind of alluded to that briefly earlier what I said the degree of e integration in the institutional space is is slightly there there's been a slight decrease from you know high 80s to low 80s on average but again this is highly Regional there are parts of the world where sustainability is at the Forefront where

you see a steady push again I mentioned Europe but if you look at the at North America is there are multiple markets within North America so there are asset owners more on the liberal side whether California New York very Pro ESG very Pro sustainable integration others Maybe in you know Middle America less interested or Texas you see that in Canada as well I remember when we was

when I was in Canada Post pension plan and we talk with other pension plans I mean no surprise we talk to you know our peers in in Quebec they are you know more focused on sustainable investing you when I speak to my peers or I spoke to my peers in Alberta they were a bit more nuanced around how you integrate sustainable investing I I don't think this has changed a lot but what I'd like

to actually use this I'd like to build on this point to to touch on the retail investor because retail investors are truly in love with sustainable investing more than 85% of retail investors in North America and Europe are interested in sustainable investing that was a data point that was published by Morgan Stan Stanley sustainable investment Institute more than half want to allocate more to sustainable investing actually the number that

really struck me was the criteria in terms of what retail investors are looking for from from investing their what they want what they would like to get out from you know deploying their money in the market 90% of them no surprise are looking for financial returns but 74% are looking to make an environmental impact so I was struck by how how many ret by the degree of

interest in generating environment Al impact that is coming from the from the retail invest investment site So that obviously leads to the creation of sustainable investment products that asset managers and own and that sorry asset managers in this case build and offer having said that the number of new sustainable funds coming into the market has greatly diminished a lot of there's still net growth in money

going to ESG funds overall between fixed income and equities but the number of new funds coming to Market has diminished well and I mean again it's tough to tell is that diminish just because the markets are taking a breather so to speak but you know it's nice to hear I think sometimes retail investors feel like they don't have a lot of impact in the greater market so it's nice to hear that they

really are the ones who are kind of leading the force and leading the way and might create a bit of that impact especially with something that's so important as we move forward okay so what I'd like to get into last with you Noir is just kind of you obviously are very integrated and work very closely with companies that are creating technology and that are becoming

catalysts in the market and creating change and and developing what the market will look like what's exciting you right now what is exciting Canada advisors right now as far as what you're seeing and maybe what is in the near future for us in the space so I love this question because I get to speak about my clients but but in no in all fairness I I'm coming I'm working with

some incredible Founders who are building tools that I think are going to change the the sustainable investing landscape just give you an example one of my client companies launched a platform called responsible Capital which is basically an AI tool to help undertake ESG analytics and what I mean undertake ESG analytics so prior to tools like this you would need a team for example of five people

looking at hundred of pages to understand the sustainability profile or sustainabil risk profile of a given company now you can use a tool like this by having a single person look at all this information and come to the same conclusions within an hour or two so the the efficiency that is coming out of AI is incredible you can really you can ask a single question or 100 question across

a universe of 10,000 companies and get your answer in a spreadsheet in terms of does this company have a biodiversity policy or not Does it include water management or not so these kind of questions that takes a lot of time are are these tools are going to change the landscape and actually reduce the cost because something we didn't talk about that it does take between 10 and 30% in

certain cases to integrate sustainability data and investment process it pushes that the cost of of of product creation so so I think tools like this are going to help lower the price point other tools I've looked at which I like in terms of productivity are tools that manage the engagement process so if you have issuers that are listening to us they do have investors asking them what their carbon what what

can they do better in climate how could they do better in terms of their social performance a lot of these communications are sometimes distracting it's coming from from different directions so there are tools there's a tool called impactive Tech that building an automated stewardship management tool that I wish I had when I was managing my fund at Canada Post pension plan because we were using spread sheets and

trying to coordinate with different departments now we can do it with technology like impactive Dex technology in a very efficient way and there are many other tools I mean the last one I will mention is company called eour that created 2,000 climate scenarios that can be dynamically tested against so if you want to align with a specific scenario coming with a from a specific Central Bank or or or an academic

institution you want to see how your company or fund aligns with that you can do that today easily with tools like this so all these tools excite me but I do think they do have a common thread a lot of them are thinking about how to integrate AI into the process to make it more more interesting and and more efficient as well more interesting in terms of decision usefulness but also

for the process to be more more seamless and and and better integrated with investors and corporate workflows you know I think I think the desire here at the end of the day so that's very exciting to hear and the power of AI I think the desire from the community is digestable information that's easily accessible and having the power of AI to take all those data

points and be able to pull them all together in something that works substantially for us you know as we as we enter the market so that's all very exciting before we go Noir I just wanted to reiterate some of the websites that you brought up so first of all there's Canada advisors and it sounds like you have some collateral that's on your website that might be

valuable for people as they want to take a look at that I know that you had just published something recently you also mentioned was it the crane tool yeah the crane tool which is a nonprofit profit kind of scope for avoided the mission assessment tool amazing and any other websites or or research points that you might advise people to go and check out well I mean it's a it's

it's a bit of a self-promotion but I would I would like to share with your audience because it' be the first time I speak about it a in a in a medium like this I'll be launching Canada Q which is basically a hub or a Marketplace to connect buyers or users of client solution software with the solution providers because I think this space is

getting very overcrowded you don't know which carbon accounting firm to use which is G reporting tool to use where to find them how to compare them so later this month Canada advisors will be launching Canada Q which is a free tool for anybody looking to look for Solutions you know they can go in there and and and hopefully find a solution that could help them or could

help enable the sustainable transformation of their fund or their company or their business because because that's something I I really strongly believe that technology is an important tool to help that could help us move further in in in in in our in the sustainable transformation of the global economy that's amazing so make sure that you check that out Noir is very accessible on LinkedIn and he posts

lots of great information on there as well as when he does podcast or when he sits on panels so I definitely encourage you to connect with him on LinkedIn and check out kada ERS Noir thank you so much for your time you really are a thought leader and expert in the space and and really do appreciate you educating us all so thank you again

for our audience out there thank you for joining us if you want more great content that was created under the summit on responsible investment it can all be found at csct TV and if you hit subscribe we'll let you know the next time that we upload a new piece so thank you again for your time Noir and I hope that we get to chat again thank you it

was a real pleasure