About This Video
On a special Summit on Responsible Investment edition of the Canadian Securities Exchange (CSE) podcast, Stephen Maser of Aura Wealth Management at Raymond James joins host Anna Serin to unpack what responsible investing really means in today’s market.
Stephen brings a unique perspective—shaped by his background in agriculture, oil & gas, and wealth management—on how clients define “responsibility” in their portfolios. From the origins of ethical investing to navigating modern ESG complexity, he shares practical advice on balancing values with returns.
Key takeaway? Responsible investing is personal: "You have to remember all the letters—Environmental, Social, and Governance—and weigh them based on what matters to you."
Read the TranscriptAuto-generated by YouTube; names and terms may be misspelled.
Hi, my name is Anna Sarin. I'm director of listings development with the Canadian Securities Exchange. You're joining us here today as a special edition, a special sorry edition to the CSE podcast. I'm joined today by Steven Maer with Aura Wealth Management at Raymond James. Thank you for joining me, Stephen. Thanks for having me. okay. Stephen is going to be joining us on the stage live on June 5th in Clon at the
Innovation Center as part of our summit on responsible investment, our live day. I'm very excited to have you join us there. But I'm also excited for us to have a little bit more time than what the clock is going to countdown on stage. we're going to talk about what is responsible investment today and really break it down. you have some really intriguing views and so I'm very
excited about that. So, why don't we start off with you telling us about yourself and Oro Wealth Management? Sure. well, I grew up on a cattle ranch in in Alberta, a small town called Many Berries, which most people have never heard of, but it's south of Medicine Hat. And after high school, I actually studied agricultural production. And like most most families who are in agriculture, I got
along better with my dad when I wasn't working with him. So I left and spent 10 years in the oil industry and I got re-educated and got recruited out of that industry and became a a financial adviser. that's a bit of a leap. Yeah. Yeah. I definitely took the long way around. Yeah. especially considering that most of the most of my colleagues they came right out of
university and went right into finance or investing or you know whatever path they took within the industry. What a benefit though to be able to work in oil and gas and then be able to become a financial planner especially in Canada where it is a sector we do look at a lot when we're investing right yeah it definitely gave me a unique perspective I like to joke that I used to work for a
living but I I knew what it was to to be to be blue collar and then work in a white collar industry that perspective doesn't I I I found it not necessarily unique But certainly unusual. Absolutely. Okay. Tell us about oral wealth management. Well, oral wealth management was a concept that I came up with about I I would say about 15 14 15 years ago. And it was really
originally just a a structure on how to do the business. you know like most people back then most of my business was transactional commissionbased and I transitioned to you know an advisory practice but a lot of that had to do with practice management efficiency trying to drive cost down for the client as well as increasing revenue for the business and looking at a a system systemic way of looking after clients so
nobody would be forgotten. Absolutely. And Orura Wealth, I think you you also have implemented a little bit into your practice around, you know, responsible or sustainable investing and and I think maybe this was born from a lot of your clients wanting to have access to that. So, it seems to be something that you spent some time thinking about. You have a fantastic blog on your website. I
do suggest to our audience to go and check it out because there's some great articles on there that are all written by you, not chat GPT, but written by Steven Mer. and and some great topics on there. So, I do suggest people go and check it out. but I think that you really are diving into what has become a very I think it's a term that
we use very loosely in investing, which is this responsible, sustainable investment practices. and it's something that has been around for a little while and it started very simply. I think there was the start of I don't want tobacco products or liquor products in my in my fund or in my investing portfolio. that has evolved and become very complex. So, why don't you tell us a little bit about what you
think responsible investment is? Sure. Well, originally I didn't know a whole lot about, you know, socially responsible investing or ESG. It was I was aware of it but vaguely and ESG or SRRI investing actually goes back further than what even I realize. It goes back to the Quakers who would not invest in anything involved in the slave trade. So that Oh, that's interesting. I didn't know that. Oh yeah. Yeah. And so
over the years that evolved into what the modern, you know, definition of it is. So about I'm going to say about 13 years ago I had a new client and she lived on Haidaguay or still does lives on Haidaguay and her previous advisor you know it was a fairly traditional portfolio and she said to me I want to be ethical in my investing and I'm don't really
know what that means. what I did know is that there was a mutual fund company out there called Ethical Funds, which has since been bought by NEI. And so I looked into it and I, you know, did my due diligence and found the mutual fund that was most appropriate for her given her risk tolerance and bought her this mutual fund. The average return was about 7 or 8%, she was
essentially flat. So, you know, nobody would be happy with that kind of result. And we ended up going back to a more traditional portfolio. But it piqued my interest into what exactly SRRI or ESG is. And I ended up writing a seminar on it. You know, the history of it and how it, you know, kind of evolved into what it what it became today. But I came to a
number of conclusions about it at least from a retail advisor's perspective. And that ESG or SRRI is really something that is very individual in its definition. Absolutely. So as a retail advisor, I have clients that range the political spectrum from very left to very right. ESG has I don't want to say it has a stigma, but it has a certain connotation. and it has certain preconceived notions about it depending
on how you sit politically. you know, and for the record, I identify as politically agnostic. Okay. Okay. And I think it's important that a retail advisor realizes that you're going to have different perspectives. 100%. I mean, look, I think what you're touching on here is something that maybe we haven't really defined properly, and that is this is a very individual decision of what is responsible investing for you. I mean, you know, we
see that there's companies coming out there that have sustainable practices or have developed ESG programs on their mining operations or on their exploration. they have social governance requirements that they've built into their corporate you know, their corporate structure. So we have this coming to market but also as investors are coming to market what they're looking for is so unique. So maybe you could just touch a little bit
on some of the some of the variety or spectrum of responsible investment mandates that you're seeing amongst your clients. Right. So one of the things you have to do is first recognize and establish what a client's baseline is. Right. And a number of years ago, we developed a what we call the risk and suitability questionnaire within the practice. Okay. Now, part A is the Raymond James standard risk tolerance
questionnaire. You know, it's it's about seven pages and you know, you go through the battery of questions to get a risk score, but that's not where it stops. I mean most experienced financial adviserss will say you know the risk score is useful but it's not you know the end all beall of of a client. It you know risk tolerances come out are born out of conversations and experience. And
then part B is what we call the suitability part of it. And one of the first questions is are there investments you wish to avoid? Yes or no? And then if yes, explain why. And we just kind of leave it at that because the question in and of itself can be very revealing. Some people will say, well, I don't want to own, say, a tobacco company. Right? Okay. Or some people will say, I don't
want to own a mutual fund. You're going to get very different answers. That is a very different answer, you know, and but that is that's apples and kangaroos. Absolutely. you're you're really getting a perspective into the client's mind and then you can say okay well why tobacco or why you don't want to own a mutual fund or why you don't want to own this or that depending on on your experience
and a number of the questions come out of the CIM program you know so you know it forces the client to actually instead of just picking you know AB C or D on a multiplechoice questionnaire to actually put pen to paper and think about what you're answering or why you're answering a question in the way it way you are. And from there you can really, you know, have a much deeper
conversation about how a portfolio should be constructed from an ESG perspective. Now, what I remind clients of is that ESG investing or SRI, the root word is investing. That's right. There is a profit motive here. That's true. Okay. And that you still want returns at the end of the day. Exactly. Going back to my client in Haidaguay, that was very informative to me. I I remind investors that there's no perfect
company. There's no perfect investment, right? There are certain certain things you're going to have to compromise on. If you're looking for perfection, maybe you shouldn't be investing. maybe you should pull pull your money out of the market, donate your time and money to whatever cause you feel most passionate about and do that. But if you're talking to someone like myself, the idea is that you want your dollar to become worth more than
that over time. And you'll get all kinds of different push backs or reasons why an investor may not want to own this company or that company, right? but that come from probably a very a very personal place, right? There's probably very personal reasons. So, I mean, first of all, I do have to say it is so valuable for us to seek out professional guidance when we're looking to invest. And I
think that especially in the startup and growth space, there's a lot of people that will choose to manage their own investments in the startup and growth. But we definitely I do encourage everyone to get professional guidance. But if people are out there asking that question to themselves, what types of questions should people be asking themselves so that they can start defining what their responsible investment looks like to them? Sure.
Well, let me give you an example. I had a conversation with a client a few weeks ago about Walmart and you know the US administration right now is pushing back on DEI hiring policies on a number of different firms. Walmart's getting getting pressure from from the US government as is Apple as is a number of different different companies and Walmart changed their DEI hiring policy. ripping it up might be a bit extreme,
but basically they're ignoring what? A revamp. Yes. And she was adamant that she wanted to get rid of Walmart within the portfolio. And I said, "Okay, well, tell me more about this because you want to get rid of an investment that essentially returned you 50% last year, right? So, tell me more about this." Well, it would came down to the DEI hiring policy that Walmart has essentially gotten rid of. And I said,
"Okay, first off, what we have to do is actually look at their hiring policies in practice, not just in writing before the DEI policy that Walmart enacted. Did their hiring practices change at all from, you know, from before then to after they wrote the policy? And because this is very new, will those hiring policies change substantially afterwards? Was this just a performance piece to get the government off their
back or is this something real and you know substantive that Walmart as a company has decided to stop doing? Right now, I don't necessarily know the answer to you know the last part of that question because it's been too new, right? But before, and this is good advice in any event, regardless of the reason why you may get rid of or add an investment to a portfolio, you know,
don't do a knee-jerk reaction. See what they're actually doing, right? If the right if the writing of the policy in it in and of itself is important, then fine, you can eliminate it from from the portfolio based on that basis. but if nothing changes in practice, you know, are you is it essentially the same company from a DEI perspective? Right. Yeah. And I mean, I guess to
something as big as Walmart, how could you possibly know the ins and outs of various different practices or policies that they're implementing, how they're treating staff, how they're dealing with their chain, you know, their their their their distribution chain as far as what's coming in, where it's coming from, is it coming from China, how their practices, and we do have some regulatory framework that is starting to
be built around that, which is great. but be maybe be cautious too of going too far down that rabbit hole because you know, it might you might never get to a final answer, right? If if that's where you're if that's where you're headed. So, one of the first places that I go you know, we use faxet, we use faxet, okay, for, you know, a lot of research. It's our quotes
monitor. And within the fact that application, there is an ESG section under under the research. And there's a lot of words smmithing that goes on, but it doesn't necessarily tell you a whole lot or or it may not. Yeah. It's very difficult to kind of parse out what exactly a firm is doing. Yes. From ESG. So, and just the best way to go about it is just read a lot. Okay. you know just
there is no one place that you can go to. you really need to go to a place like Faxet, go to you know, just go online, you know, do a Google search. you know, a first point of research, even though it's not perfect and there can be errors, but it gives you a foundation is a company's Wikipedia page, right? Okay. And while there, you know, that can have its own factual
errors, at least there are links to that information. read their read their quarterly financial statements. Yeah, absolutely. You know, I mean, I think the one thing that's interesting and and it's this could be at least a good start is that when somebody says they have a developed ESG program, take the next step and go, well, what is it? Well, that that's that's a really good point because ESG
depending on how you define it, you can either be inclusive inclusive or exclusive, right? meaning I will own it and try and enact some sort of change within the firm, right? Or I just won't own it because I don't agree with them at all. Right? And inclusive ESG practices is basically only affordable to institutional money, right? I mean, as a practice, my team and I, you know, we manage
hundreds of millions of dollars, but that's that's just a drop in the bucket. Yeah.
And we take all that money and try and buy our way onto a corporate board. Well, you'd never get on it. That's right. Right. So, at the retail level, you have to be exclusionary or exclusive. You can't be inclusive. Right. Okay. From based on that that that definition. So if there's a company that just does not fit to your idea of of morals or you know whatever your politics may or may
not be, you just have to say no it's a bridge too far. You know the obvious stuff we mentioned you know tobacco, arms manufacturing, right? you know, some people would say oil and gas or mining, but you know, it gets very gray very quickly, right? So, maybe try and have a more highlevel approach. you mentioned politics and and I you have a very interesting view on this. And I
think another thing that maybe we don't really think about enough as investors, but you talk about in one of the articles on your blog, you talk about be wary of politicizing your investment choices. So tell us what that means. Well, it used to be that you know, you just didn't politicize anything in investing. It wasn't good practice. Yeah. But it's it's almost impossible to separate politics from anything these
days. Yeah. You know, it's just it permeates everything. Another example, I I had I had a conversation with a client and they didn't want to own Walt Disney Corporation, right? I'm like, "Okay, why?" Well, they've gone woke. I'm like, "Would you define that? What are you talking about?" Well, they were they they use the phrase go woke, go broke. And I'm like, well, first off, that's not really a thing. Okay. No, in
capitalism, that's not really a thing. Okay? You know what Disney was doing? And his thing was, you know, the remake of The Little Mermaid and Black Ariel. And I said, "Hang on a second. Are you telling me that Bob Iger, who has to report to shareholders and a board, made a financial decision and spent hundreds of millions of dollars making and promoting a film because they've gone woke, right?
Obviously, that's not how a company like that works. Yeah, they did focus groups. They did studies and decided that this was going to make money. Now, as we all know, in entertainment, you can lose money very easily. There's a million things that can go wrong. And it didn't it didn't make the money that they were hoping to, but someone with his perspective, it was just like, well, they tried to do something that I didn't
agree with politically and therefore it's a bad investment and I shouldn't and I shouldn't own it. And I said, "Well, you're looking at one small piece, the larger pitch of a company with a much larger scale, right? Didn't matter. Didn't want to own it. It seems like a very slippery slope to bring woke into your investment decisions. I mean, we spend a lot of time dealing with
technical data, with historical data, forecasting, analysts, and financial reporting, disclosure. So to bring woke into the mix seems like a very slippery slope. It's silly. Yeah, it it really is. What you have to do, so when I look at an investment, the first thing I do is start from a very basic foundation. Is the company providing something that people want or need, right? Okay. Base level.
How do they do that? Is it profitable? And then you can start, you know, funneling through the other pieces of that investment of whether or not you want to own it. But the first criteria for any investment is is could it make me money? Right? That's it. All other considerations are secondary, right? Those secondary considerations can be, you know, stackranked, right? Depending on who you are and what you're trying to
accomplish, whether it's risk tolerance or ESG considerations or or anything like that. But the first thing you have to consider is is it profitable? Okay. And then as I say, funnel your way through the other considerations. Here's my options that could make me potential gains. And then from there, I get to pick from here what might fit into my vision of what is my mandates, my personal mandates of how to
inve I've used Apple as as a bit of a case study for for this sort of thing. You know, generally speaking, Apple is, you know, is is a very well-run company. They do their best to, you know, have all their operations their energy produ, you know, their energy needs are renewable. Yeah. You know, they're not they're pushing back on people asking them to scrap their DEI policies. They
don't want to do that, right? but they also use subcontractors like Foxcon out of China and their the treatment of Foxcon's employees hasn't been great historically. To give credit where it's due, Apple has been working with Foxcon to try and improve worker conditions in China. But you have to ask yourself, is their environmental and DEI hiring policies outweigh their subcontractor choice? And maybe Apple doesn't have a choice in
subcontractors, right? That's a bit simplistic. Clearly, they do have a choice because they're diversifying their their supply chain out of China into India. But well, are they are they coming into the US as well? They have some big plans to be able to move their operations into the US, which will dramatically shift things. They are reshoring some of their production. And if memory serves, it's an investment of
about 500 billion now. Now, is is that right? I Yeah, in Texas, that's exactly right. Yeah. But but you wonder what that'll do to the investment and to the margin on the investment when they have to invest that kind of money to bring it back in. Well, what we have to ask is what kind of production are they really onshoring back to the US? Right. Good point. It is very sophisticated
production that you if you were to onshore the entire production of the iPhone Yeah. on to back into the US, you so right now an iPhone in the United States on average costs about $1,200, right? With tariffs, it pushes the the price, you know, assuming tariffs stays static, which they won't. They won't. but you're pushing the price of that iPhone up to about $2,500 approximately. Yeah. If you
were to onshore the entire production of the iPhone to the US, you're looking at a handset worth about $3,500, depending on how you do the math, it's not practical. Nobody is going to be spending or the vast majority of people will not spend $3,500 on an iPhone, right? So, yes, they're on shoring certain things, but not everything. And the vast majority of their production is still going to be offshore. It is just
not practical, right? Absolutely. If somebody wanted to implement this into their portfolio and and maybe it's not something where everything needs to be have some sustainability approach, is there certain sectors that investors should look towards where they can appease having this as part of their investment strategy? I think the best thing to do when you're looking at this sort of investment philosophy is look at individual names and base your decision
on the individual names as opposed to broad sectors. You're going to find good and bad players from that perspective in every industry. Right. Right. So if you're looking at at a say say a junior mining company, right? you know, how they go about reclamation of the land versus do they just leave a a raw open pit somewhere in in a country that doesn't have strong environmental standards say compared
to Canada, right? you know, you also have to realize as an investor there is going to be a cost associated with that. the rate of return may be less because they are doing you know expensive environmental reclamation. Yeah. And you know if that's if you're fine with that the sustainability of an investment is extraordinarily important. If you look at you know take insurance companies you know it is more expensive
to insure property if you can insure it at all along coastlines. Mhm. You know, look at the Florida coastline. You know, in some places you can't get home insurance. You know, that that's a good indicator as to whether or not your business might be sustainable if you're in a place that could be underwater in 50 years. Well, yeah. Is that sustainable? The going concern has has a shelf life. Yeah. Right. But sorry, just
to go back to your mining point, I think that's something that is maybe a really good takeaway for people is that if you want to invest in the mining sector is having an understanding of from a jurisdictional perspective, Canada has very deep entrenched reclamation requirements, safety requirements, diversity requirements, Aboriginal and indigenous relationship requirements. they have, you know, I think we're coming more to terms where
they have some seat at the table of what's happening on on the territory. And so if you're wanting to invest in the mining space is picking jurisdictions that already have that, you know, that there's some element of that built into the sector just from where it's happening, right? You can also look at it from the perspective that a company that might be mining overseas, you may be creating jobs in a place
where jobs aren't easily very good. You know, higher paying jobs just aren't available. Yep. So, you know, you can go well on this hand and then on this hand, you know, there's a lot of back and forth that you can do. And so, find your happy ground, then find your middle ground. again. Yeah. It comes back to my Apple example. Yeah. You know, what is the greater consideration to you? Yeah.
And if you know the good far and way out outweighs what you consider bad, right, then invest. Okay. But if if something that they're doing is just a bridge too far for you, exclude it from your portfolio. Okay. Yeah. Okay. Great advice. just to end off here, Stephen, maybe you could just give us your thoughts on is this something that we're going to We started the summit on
responsible investment only two years ago. This is our third year running. and it felt very niche even amongst CSC listed issuers. This year we had a much bigger pool of issuers that are focused on the space that we could bring into our live event and our online content that we're building out this summer. is this something we're going to see more and more of as investors? Is this
going to become an important you know foundation in how we invest? I believe so. I've had more conversations around ESG in the last 5 years than I have you know in the previous 15 of my career. You know part of that is just by you know by extension you know growth of of the practice and dealing with more people. But it's a conversation that is being prompted not
by me but by the investor. They want to know what they own. They want to know why they own it. And you know from a conversations about Disney to Walmart to Apple or whatever investment you own. Maybe it's a mutual fund or an ETF. You know, maybe somebody doesn't want to own the S&P 500 because it's American. and they don't like the current president. Maybe they want to own Apple because
they're they've got a huge push to having 100% recyclable devices. It really comes down to the individual, but that conversation is h happening more and more. And I found too after the development of our risk and suitability questionnaire that question about investments that you want to avoid even though it's come it's framed in a negative in a in a negative right very positive and interesting conversations are born out of it some people sure
they're just I don't care just make me some money but there are more than more than a few people are going well let's have a conversation about that explain this and when you know a new client comes in and I draw them up a a proposal for their money it's very detailed and you can say okay well why this company as opposed to this company is it profitability is it sustainability is it
based on their governance and what we have to remember is you know ESG you have to remember all the letters that's right right and governance is a big part of that. That's right. Absolutely, Stephen. such great insights. Thank you so much for joining us. And, I do again suggest that you go and check out Steven's website. It's Oral Wealth Management. He is with Raymond James here in Colona. Really wonderful
insights and I just really appreciate that this is where we're starting to transition. Again, can't can't say enough how valuable it is to have a professional help you with your investing practices. So, thank you very much, Stephen. Thanks for having me. Thank you.



